6 ms·

The issue prevented all transactions which had all z-address inputs and outputs (that is, fully anon txes) and no t-address inputs or outputs (public addresses)

by droffel 10y ago

The issue prevented all transactions which had all z-address inputs and outputs (that is, fully anon txes) and no t-address inputs or outputs (public addresses) from being mined.

biafra 10y ago
What is your source for this claim? I did these kind of transactions during the beta.
- plasticmachine 10y ago
  This is well known: https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705
  - biafra 10y ago
    The ticket says "In some cases, some transactions with joinsplits do not get mined." So this does not prove droffels point. He said all tx with only z-addresses could not be mined. Any other source for this claim?
    - plasticmachine 10y ago
      He's 100% correct, as is the GitHub issue. Transactions that were z-addr -> t-addr, or vice versa, were being mined, but private transactions (my z-addr pays your z-addr) were not. Per the ZCash website (https://z.cash/blog/state-of-the-network-2016-10-31.html https://z.cash/blog/state-of-the-network-2016-10-31.html) - "There is one known bug, which causes private transactions (those in which all of the inputs and outputs are shielded addresses) to not get mined."
biafra 10y ago
I am sure, you're mistaken. I just created and executed a tx with only z-addresses with zcashd version 1.0.1. It was mined and can be found on the block exlorer. Please stop spreading FUD about zcash.
- plasticmachine 10y ago
  It's not FUD, he's entirely correct. They had one thing to get right before launch, and they got it wrong. Speaks volumes for the so-called dream team. References: - https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 - https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/zcash-bug-prevents-private-transactions-soon-after-launch/ https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/zcash-bug-prevents-private-t...
  - biafra 10y ago
    It is FUD, because droffel claims no private tx could be mined.
    - plasticmachine 10y ago
      No he doesn't. Go read what he wrote again. Private transactions (one z-addr sends to another z-addr) were not being mined.

by droffel 10y ago

The issue prevented all transactions which had all z-address inputs and outputs (that is, fully anon txes) and no t-address inputs or outputs (public addresses) from being mined.

biafra 10y ago

What is your source for this claim? I did these kind of transactions during the beta.

plasticmachine 10y ago
This is well known: https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705
- biafra 10y ago
  The ticket says "In some cases, some transactions with joinsplits do not get mined." So this does not prove droffels point. He said all tx with only z-addresses could not be mined. Any other source for this claim?
  - plasticmachine 10y ago
    He's 100% correct, as is the GitHub issue. Transactions that were z-addr -> t-addr, or vice versa, were being mined, but private transactions (my z-addr pays your z-addr) were not. Per the ZCash website (https://z.cash/blog/state-of-the-network-2016-10-31.html https://z.cash/blog/state-of-the-network-2016-10-31.html) - "There is one known bug, which causes private transactions (those in which all of the inputs and outputs are shielded addresses) to not get mined."

biafra 10y ago

I am sure, you're mistaken. I just created and executed a tx with only z-addresses with zcashd version 1.0.1. It was mined and can be found on the block exlorer. Please stop spreading FUD about zcash.

plasticmachine 10y ago
It's not FUD, he's entirely correct. They had one thing to get right before launch, and they got it wrong. Speaks volumes for the so-called dream team. References: - https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 https://github.com/zcash/zcash/issues/1705 - https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/zcash-bug-prevents-private-transactions-soon-after-launch/ https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/zcash-bug-prevents-private-t...
- biafra 10y ago
  It is FUD, because droffel claims no private tx could be mined.
  - plasticmachine 10y ago
    No he doesn't. Go read what he wrote again. Private transactions (one z-addr sends to another z-addr) were not being mined.