3 ms·
The problem with the h1b is that it is a lottery. If it was instead auctioned to the highest bidder, then we wouldnt get companies undercutting American jobs.
by stale2002 10y ago
The problem with the h1b is that it is a lottery.
If it was instead auctioned to the highest bidder, then we wouldnt get companies undercutting American jobs.
Don't just give the visa to someone randomly. Give it to the company who is willing to pay a 50k tax bill.
If the employee is worth it, then they will have no problem paying the bill.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoIf it was auctioned to the highest bidder, then only software engineers predominately in Silicon Valley would make up 99% of all visas.
- stale2002 10y agoYou are right. That is what would happen. If other companies don't like it, then they should make their salaries competitive.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoBut the other salaries are competitive when scaled by cost of living, it's that SV and NYC salaries are so high because there's a housing shortage going on. Also: quality of life, who wants to live in a shoebox in Oakland? People will trade a lower salary for a less insane commute. One theory is that software is concentrated in SV because employee turnover is so fast in that line of work, it's quickest to find a new job in SV as opposed to anywhere else. The dominance of SV is people taking a salary hit to insure against catastrophic outcomes, i.e. running out of savings/unemployment and health insurance. Why not have a commission decide on how big the shortage is and then issue green cards depending on occupation? Whoever wins one can work for whomever is pleases him, instead of being tied to the employer for years and years. Yes, I know it's possible to change jobs, but it's not for those with weak stomachs or dependents.
- xiaoma 10y agoEbay auctions aren't scaled by cost of living adjustments either. The highest bidder wins. I agree that work permission should be either open or open after the first year, though. It's a huge artificial inefficiency to have talented people stuck in a sub optimal place for years just due to fear of losing residency if they change jobs.
- ajmurmann 10y agoIf the money goes to taxes I'm afraid it will lower the employee's salary. How about going by the highest salary offered instead? That would ensure that the pay stays competitive and foreign engineers don't get hired just because they are cheaper.
- stale2002 10y agoThat works too. Or do a minimum salary of xxx,000$.
- xiaoma 10y agoThe way to do the auction is, the engineers with the highest salary offers get to come (national security permitting). This way the slots would be used only to bring in people who were truly highly valued in their profession.
- prebrov 10y agoWouldn't this incentivise companies to pass down these costs to an H1B employees in the form of even lower pay and/or reduced benefits? High cost of labour acquisition, IMO, is a huge contributor to "workplace" abuse in black markets and debt is the mechanism of modern slavery.
- stale2002 10y agoIt might pass down to the h1bs, but it would NOT pass down to Americans (why pay an h1b 80k +50k tax, if you can pay an American 120k). But you can also solve this by just having minimum 100k+ salary requirements.
- kevbin 10y agoThe problem with visas is that they're restricted at all. Human beings should be able to pursue the American way of life w/o winning a lottery or convincing some company that they're worthy of a valuable "slot".
- masonic 10y agoChattelizing human beings You're equating H-1B applicants to chattel slaves?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]