6 ms·
What is there to suggest that the arrow of causality is going in the way that you imply? Personally, I am fairly convinced that academia and science being "lib
by eropple 10y ago
What is there to suggest that the arrow of causality is going in the way that you imply?
Personally, I am fairly convinced that academia and science being "liberal" is, I think, much more a characteristic of the underlying philosophies involved than some externally-imposed groupthink. "Conservatism", at least the modern variant, and "exploring and expanding knowledge for a greater good, while entertaining ideas that you don't necessarily agree with" are literally antithetical. I thought of myself as a conservative before I went to college and realized that, hey, American conservatism is not only railing against stuff like observational science, but "morally" against the existence of these fellow human beings who have done nothing wrong and deserve to exist.
So, yeah, maybe "the public" would trust academia and the whole "science" thing more if it was More Conservative, but who's to say that it'd actually work as well? It's not like this stuff exists to tell people what they want to hear--and the epistemic closure of the American conservative is such an ideological purity test that if you're not telling them what they want to hear, you're not conservative. It's not on "science and academia" to break itself for such a warped thing, is it?
- godzillabrennus 10y agoI read The_Donald on reddit and they believe they are the only ones willing to entertain ideas. First, and most notably, they believe that being liberal means full embracement of leftist group think like the USSR had during its communist days. That is the most fundamental problem with reaching them since you can't unmoor the thought of leftism from liberalism with them. They believe the scientific community has become strangled by this leftist/liberal ideology. I'm not sure what happens next but I think it's bad for humanity. If half the population needs a reminder on why science is good I guess they'll get it. Usually that's mass death.
- justavoice 10y agoFunny thing is, membership in a group does not limit the spectrum of thought: there are people on both sides of the liberal/conservative divide that are rational. The problem is in the meta-group-think going on for the groups as a whole. Kinda like emergent behaviour in insects. The reasonable voices on both sides are drowned out by the crazies, on both sides.
- eropple 10y agoYour read jibes with my own when I've studied that community (and washed afterwards). I'll give what passes for a "left" in this country a lot of flak on a lot of things, but a fundamental unwillingness to work with people who disagree with them on some things but are willing to find common ground on others is not one of them. Often to their, and our, detriment.
- MichaelGG 10y ago>fundamental unwillingness to work with people who disagree Identity politics is even worse than this. From what I can see, among people not totally ideologically driven, this discredits the left very much, and liberal values will be caught in the backlash.
- eropple 10y agoThat's a can of worms, huh? I mean, yes, I would definitely say that that identity politics/bloc voting is problematic, from the perspective of "how do we best run a government?". It is also in many cases understandable, especially in the face of extant threats to a given polity. (In such a case, however, it is important to stress that "identity politics" is not the problem--the threat and disenfranchisement that led to the formation of an identity bloc is. Even for Trump voters, who I'll touch on momentarily.) But from a social/messaging perspective, I think that it is less that identity politics discredits the left and more that white people (and it's mostly white people who have an axe to grind about identity politics) feel threatened by identity politics and thus by the left. The reactionary clumping of the Trumpist bloc of whites (as evidenced both by voting patterns and the frankly shameless xenophobic pandering by Trump and his surrogates in the campaign) is no less "identity politics", and is arguably more aggressive than the identity-focused blocs that have formed prior (it's a lot less aggressive to say "we should be able to get married" than it is to say "you should not be able to get married", get me?). But that's not castigated as "identity politics". I would submit that that's because white people don't think white is an identity, but the default. Identity politics are fine, so goes the thinking, when it's your identity. In a society overwhelmingly dominated by white interests, fairness is gonna feel like you're losing. (This is the genesis of the notion of "privilege" in the first place, as I understand it.)
- return0 10y ago> If half the population needs a reminder on why science is good I guess they'll get it. I don't know if you looked at science lately, but the majority of the science published is actually not-that-great, if not bad. The public SHOULD distrust scientists - as well as most else.
- enraged_camel 10y agoOK, I'll bite: who should the public trust when it comes to science then, if not scientists?
- return0 10y agoThe question is whether they should trust scientists about policy decisions, not whenther they should trust scientists about science. Political/ideological decisions don't have to rely on science, this "political scientism" is a very recent thing. The entire 60s revolutions for example were primarily anti-technology, anti-corporatism and anti-established science. Part of progress is breaking up with established ideas, and that includes bad science (e.g. the neoliberal economic approaches). This applies of course mostly to social sciences, it's pretty pointless to fight the laws of physics
- donut2d 10y agoExamples?
- return0 10y agotoo many to list. see here: http://www.forbes.com/sites/patrickmichaels/2014/01/09/the-latest-epidemic-to-infect-the-scientific-community-bad-science/#ea85a453c46c http://www.forbes.com/sites/patrickmichaels/2014/01/09/the-l...
- brighteyes 10y agoOn the one hand, those are fair points - maybe conservatism is just not consistent with good science. We can't just rule that out. But on the other hand, I think we can. The percentage of conservatives has declined rapidly in recent decades. We haven't seen an increase in scientific productivity because of that. Science worked just as well back when there were more conservatives doing it. And we also see conservatives talking about how hard it is for them to be themselves on campuses. It isn't that their politics interfere with them doing science. It is that they are a hated minority.
- eropple 10y agoI think your definition of "conservative" is cheating around to suit your argument (that's not a slight against you, most people make this mistake). In "prior decades", conservatism was a different thing. It wasn't a refusal to acknowledge that there are aspects of reality that will not move just because you want them to. We are very, very far afield from an intellectually respectable conservative movement that resembles the one where a conservative academia existed. For example: never mind that Richard Milhouse Dirtbag Nixon created the EPA--the idea of clean air and clean water being a social good that should be available to all people is a liberal idea now. That is a pretty big swing. The conservative movement that attacks facts because facts refuse to coexist with their ideology was a Pat Buchanan minority before about 1990 and didn't exist in the mainstream of political thought before about 1970. Do you realize that the modern conservative movement defined "reality-based community" as a pejorative because they believed they could simply create their own realities[1]? Turns out that when you fight reality, reality fights back. It's not really a surprise that burning effort on that struggle is not conducive to scientific pursuits. > And we also see conservatives talking about how hard it is for them to be themselves on campuses. It isn't that their politics interfere with them doing science. It is that they are a hated minority. When your belief system is predicated upon what modern conservatism is predicated upon, yes, you're going to be disliked. It is a very dislikable system of belief! And I mean, I'm speaking from experience. It wasn't that long ago when I was one of those Campus Conservatives, speaking truth to the Liberal Elites. I delighted in being the gadfly. I got shit because I acted like a little shit. (And I regret it now, because my desire to be Loudly and Emphatically Conservative actually hurt people; I was never so broken as to fall in with the racists and the homophobes, but I had no problem with the very morally upright hang-the-poors ideology and saw nothing wrong with "well, why don't they just work harder?".) So pardon me for being real skeptical about how very oppressed they are. [1] - http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/17/magazine/faith-certainty-and-the-presidency-of-george-w-bush.html http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/17/magazine/faith-certainty-a... (the puncher quote there is largely believed to be from Karl Rove)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lend000 10y agoI don't think this is true. Significant numbers of liberals tend to be just as anti-science when it serves their agenda. Some examples: "Monsanto is evil", "GMO's are destroying our planet", GreenPeace (just in general), "geo-engineering is horrible", "nuclear is too dangerous", etc. If you count economics as a science, liberals tend to discount/avoid even the basic principles of that as well. Liberals just tend to have a few more prominent things on their agenda (primarily climate science related) than conservatives so it makes one side look less-uninformed than the other, when in reality they are both willfully ignorant.
- eropple 10y agoEhhhh. The difference, to me, is that the conservative moment defines rigidly what is Acceptable Thought in a way that I really do not think is true on the other side of the fence. I don't have to agree that nuclear power is dangerous (it's not!) to be a "liberal in good standing". I don't have to agree that GMOs are dangerous (they're not!). I don't have to think positively of GreenPeace (and boy, do I not!). We are able to have a dialogue about these things internal to our own camp and even disagree with each other with at least some assumption of good faith. And that's really super-duper important. On the other hand, a Republican Congressman in Ohio who went on record as acknowledging that climate change is real and is happening would be primaried by his own party. There are things about which a Democrat would be primaried by his or her own party...but I think they'd be more like "attending a Klan rally" than "accepts that scientific consensus means things," and so we're talking differences in kind here, not merely degree.
- sien 10y agoHere is James Hansen being called a 'Denier' by Naomi Oreskes in Gurandiad. That's good faith? https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/dec/16/new-form-climate-denialism-dont-celebrate-yet-cop-21 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/dec/16/new-fo... Nuclear Power advocates on the left are frequently attacked by Greenpeace and many others. As far as Acceptable Thought goes the practice of 'no platforming' and restricting free speech at Universities is not something that the Right originated. Again, that isn't debating with any assumption of good faith. That's just trying to block out views that the Left doesn't like.
- edblarney 10y ago""Conservatism", at least the modern variant, and "exploring and expanding knowledge for a greater good, while entertaining ideas that you don't necessarily agree with" are literally antithetical." This is completely not true. I think you might confusing 'popular' liberalism (i.e. progressivism) and 'popular' conservatism (i.e. evangelicals, social conservatism, small government etc.) - with actual liberalism and conservatism. Universities were always fairly Conservative, it started to change in the 1940s-1960s. The 'liberals' in University that people are complaining about are progressives - not liberals: 1) There is a lot of 'social justice ideology' that is not particularly scientific and more perversely 2) a lot of ideas are openly suppressed because they don't promote the ideological narrative of many academics. The banishment of speakers, not allowing profs to talk about certain things because of potential 'trigger warnings', historical revisionism, and the shaping of courses to meet ideological narratives (CLASS Montreal protestors demanded a 'feminization' of the entire course material etc..) - none of this is remotely liberal by any definition. In short: Universities liberal arts faculties are are illiberal institutions. On the whole - I think it has much more to do with the admins and Uni culture - as defined by a vocal subgroup of students - than the course material itself. The student unions are more than 50% of the problem.