2 ms·
> I would tenatively assert that the majority of philosophers now and in the past have believed the following two things: 1) moral statements like "murder is wr
by paganel 10y ago
> I would tenatively assert that the majority of philosophers now and in the past have believed the following two things: 1) moral statements like "murder is wrong" are objectively true or false. 2) philosophical statements are also objectively true or false.
That is not entirely true about Heraclitus. Aristotle accused him of believing that there is no "true" or "false", and even though Aristotle was biased (don't know the reasons, but it seems like he holds a grudge against Heraclitus) by skipping through the remaining fragments from Heraclitus I'd say that Aristotle was at least partially right, there are indeed moments when you think that for guys (they were mostly guys) like Heraclitus there wasn't a clear distinction between "true" and "false".
I've said it before on HN, in slightly more eloquent terms, that Aristotle and his principle of "tertium non datur" is what allowed our civilization to scientifically and economically prosper, it's what allowed us to put a man on the Moon and to hold mini-computers connected to the Internet inside our pockets, but if one reads those Heraclitus fragments there are hints of possible intellectual/not-sure-what-to-call them worlds where indeed the difference between "true" and "false" is relative, where a thing can be "true" and "false" and in any other state at any-one time.
I can't comment about Heraclitus's or pre-Socratics' views on morals, AFAIK that was mostly a thing that started to matter with Plato and then with the Stoics. It certainly became "a thing" in later Anglo-Saxon philosophy, where things like "sins" and the like started to become important.
- throwaway91111 10y agoEastern philosophy also holds some middle path values that reject true/false dischotomies. However, the vast majority of western philosophy—what people tend to refer to with "philosophy"—is built on objective truths and deductive reasoning. I'm comfortable with his point #2 above. The actual existence of truth--that's another story.
- hyperpape 10y agoGood point. I'd edit my comment to read "Western philosophy" if I could still edit it.