6 ms·
> Short version is that the road is full of things at the 99th percentile that won't be programmable so the car will either fail, bail, or simply stop. Autonom
by naasking 10y ago
> Short version is that the road is full of things at the 99th percentile that won't be programmable so the car will either fail, bail, or simply stop.
Autonomous cars aren't programmed, they're trained, like humans. So I don't think this reasoning applies. If they behave poorly in some circumstances, they'll just create new training simulations covering those cases with better outcomes and push an update out. The cars will learn better and faster than humans.
- dilemma 10y agoThat training is a different method of programming the system. It will never be able to handle unique and novel cases because it cannot think. "AI" isn't intelligent, it is a dumb bureaucrat executing instructions.
- naasking 10y agoI think you're overestimating the difficulty of novel cases. Handling them better than humans doesn't require much intelligence.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 10y agoOne thing that humans have going for them is that they have an understanding of what is going on around them, including in the minds of other people. I don't think this is fatal to your argument, but it is something to consider. I am in the apparently unusual position of believing that autonomy is both feasible and desirable, while thinking that the capabilities of current implementations are being oversold.
- naasking 10y ago> One thing that humans have going for them is that they have an understanding of what is going on around them, including in the minds of other people. I hear this argument often, but I see no evidence for it. It just sounds like yet another flawed attempt to make humans more special than they really are. I guess we'll see over the next 5 years as autonomous vehicles become deployed.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWell, I at least have empathy. Maybe we could say "some humans have an understanding..."? Nobody was claiming 'only humans' - Chimpanzees clearly have empathy.
- naasking 10y agoI'm not sure empathy is relevant understanding another driver's mind. This thread is still about driving right?
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoUnderstanding the state of mind of another is the definition of empathy. "Did that guy see me? Is he waiting for me to go?" is exactly the kind of question that requires empathy to answer.
- naasking 10y agoI won't dispute your use of empathy because that will start a whole other debate. Instead, I'll simply demonstrate that understanding another driver's mind has nothing to do with the scenario you presented. The rules of the road define who has the right of way. Of course, sometimes other drivers don't see you, but you literally have no way of knowing whether or not they do. The only thing you can do is begin your attempt cautiously in accordance with road rules and abort at the first sign of potential collision. Notice how this decision process is completely algorithmic. Proper understanding of another driver's mind is a red herring. You use the almost-collision to infer what the other driver knows, not the other way around like you seem to think.
- mannykannot 10y agoFrom your replies to me, I was beginning to think I was being trolled, but I see you probably simply have not experienced the full unpleasantness of urban driving, in which people violate both the rules of the road and common sense for motives, not just through a lack of awareness. From my experience and informal discussions, I am very confident that people weigh the presumed motives and purpose of other drivers in their predictions of future outcomes - in fact, when I am in urban traffic and not alone, discussions of other drivers' motivations and likely behavior do come up. Now, I do not doubt that if all (or most) vehicles were autonomous, things could work as you describe (though traffic might flow more smoothly or efficiently if vehicles could signal 'intent'), but that is not how it works at the moment, and the transition is probably the hardest part of introducing autonomous vehicles.