6 ms·
Short version is that the road is full of things at the 99th percentile that won't be programmable so the car will either fail, bail, or simply stop. I don't d
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Short version is that the road is full of things at the 99th percentile that won't be programmable so the car will either fail, bail, or simply stop.
I don't disagree with that sentiment but there were all sorts of things that "PCs" couldn't do that real computers could and they were still commercially successful (and eventually caught up to "real" computers for the most part). I could imagine that someone could come up with signage which self driving cars would understand and act on. Basically put up a QR code that links to the government approved way self driving cars should navigate the hazard, and of course a programming language that could communicate that to the car.
Of course you would not want just anyone to set up overrides or you would have pranksters sending cars off into corn fields or worse.
The part that Nissan appeared to miss is that if you can make them work in 99.9% of the cases, then you can hack around that last .1% and the cars will still be a net win in terms of better road behavior.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ebbv 10y agoThe difference is when a PC couldn't do something a mainframe couldn't nobody got killed. I'm not trying to be hyperbolic here, those really are the stakes with self driving cars. The problem is that when consumers think they are getting a self driving car they will very quickly resort to bad behavior (see the terribly sad Tesla fatality from last year.) We really need to be careful about how these features are marketed and implemented.
- kobeya 10y agoSelf driving cars don't have to be 100% equal to humans in all circumstances. Some of these edge cases are things like construction workers or traffic cops guiding traffic. That's a damn hard thing to get right. But you could instead just give the traffic cop a radio clicker. The edge cases are not going to be adverse driving conditions, which machines actually handle better with superior reaction times and finer control.
- dogma1138 10y agoThey do because people need to have more confidence in them than in human drivers. People still feel that "it won't happen to them" because they have agency and can drive safer than others, it isn't neccrary true but you give up on this agency when you let a computer drive. You can drive in a way which will reduce you likelihood of being in a fatal accident if all autonomous cars have say a 2.5% fail rate on decisions it becomes just a matter of time.
- naasking 10y ago> Short version is that the road is full of things at the 99th percentile that won't be programmable so the car will either fail, bail, or simply stop. Autonomous cars aren't programmed, they're trained, like humans. So I don't think this reasoning applies. If they behave poorly in some circumstances, they'll just create new training simulations covering those cases with better outcomes and push an update out. The cars will learn better and faster than humans.
- dilemma 10y agoThat training is a different method of programming the system. It will never be able to handle unique and novel cases because it cannot think. "AI" isn't intelligent, it is a dumb bureaucrat executing instructions.
- naasking 10y agoI think you're overestimating the difficulty of novel cases. Handling them better than humans doesn't require much intelligence.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 10y agoOne thing that humans have going for them is that they have an understanding of what is going on around them, including in the minds of other people. I don't think this is fatal to your argument, but it is something to consider. I am in the apparently unusual position of believing that autonomy is both feasible and desirable, while thinking that the capabilities of current implementations are being oversold.
- naasking 10y ago> One thing that humans have going for them is that they have an understanding of what is going on around them, including in the minds of other people. I hear this argument often, but I see no evidence for it. It just sounds like yet another flawed attempt to make humans more special than they really are. I guess we'll see over the next 5 years as autonomous vehicles become deployed.