4 ms·
So the computer won't know what to do and you're going to dump it on someone in a cubicle a thousand miles away? Here, make a decision in at most a second and
by rmason 10y ago
So the computer won't know what to do and you're going to dump it on someone in a cubicle a thousand miles away? Here, make a decision in at most a second and a half or you crash? That's going to work ;<).
If the computer is confused I want to be the one to make the decision. I am perfectly happy having a system right now that works 95% of the time in good weather.
I think it will be at least 2025 before it can handle a Michigan winter, maybe longer. Still want a limited system ASAP.
- elmar 10y agoAnd Self-Driving cars teleoperation will open the door for remote hacking, it simply creates more problems than it solves.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> If the computer is confused I want to be the one to make the decision. I am perfectly happy having a system right now that works 95% of the time in good weather. Sounds like a Tesla Model 3 reservation is in your future! ;)
- rmason 10y agoMuch as I like Tesla's there are two problems: 1. Thanks to the car dealer lobby here in Michigan you can't buy one in the state 2. No local charging options. Nearest supercharger is 70 miles away in either Ann Arbor or Grand Rapids I'm not very far from my local Ford dealer and the rumor is they're getting a charging station so that is probably how I will go.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoYou can still buy a Tesla in Michigan; you buy it on tesla.com, and the sale officially takes place in California. The vehicle is delivered to your home (or you could pick it up from a gallery/service center over the border in OH). Can you not charge at home with a 240V outlet? You might also check out PlugShare.com for local charging options. If you're in a condo or apartment, several states have legislation now mandating reasonable accommodation (at the EV owner's cost) of EV charging stations. I do not know if Michigan has such legislation though.
- XorNot 10y agoIt occurs to me Tesla's self drive should eventually mean the car just drives itself to your door.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoElon has said as much on Twitter. But until level 4 autonomy, have to go pick it up or be outside for delivery like a peasant.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's a common misconception that states like Michigan ban Tesla sales entirely. They can't do that, as it's interstate commerce and the Feds have exclusive powers over that. All the states can do is regulate how businesses operate within the state. So they can prevent Tesla from opening stores or service centers within the state, but they can't prevent people from buying the cars.
- slededit 10y agoI would assume the computer would still be responsible for getting the car into a fail safe situation until a human could take over. Much as how mars rovers are driven semi-autonomously. This makes a lot more sense for a fleet of self driving vehicles. Not for personal transportation in your own car.
- freehunter 10y agoMost drivers can't handle a Michigan winter. I just drove from Lansing to Grand Rapids in this weather we had today, and there were four cars off the road in the span of a dozen miles. Front-wheel drive cars on straight roads, too. They didn't just spin out, those drivers had to seriously mis-handle their vehicle to wind up in the ditch. That being said, the "self driving" part of my car (cruise control) turns itself off when the wheels slip already, so I agree that I could handle a car that drove itself in good weather but punted back to me in the snow. Vision-imparing snowfall is actually a more rare event than people might think. Normally the roads are quickly cleared.
- grzm 10y agoMost drivers can't handle a Michigan winter. I just drove from Lansing to Grand Rapids in this weather we had today, and there were four cars off the road in the span of a dozen miles. A lot of drivers have problems driving in winter conditions. But most? Over 50%? That's a pretty strong claim.
- kobeya 10y agoMost drivers are in India, southern China, the equatorial belt, etc. I don't think they have much experience with Michigan winters.
- grzm 10y agoI believe it's understood that the drivers under discussion are Michigan drivers, are they not? If not, I'm not sure how interesting the statement is. Drivers in India, southern China, or the equatorial belt won't have need of a car that can handle Michigan winters, either.
- kobeya 10y agoI don't think that was clear from context at all, no. However unlike a human driver, people will expect a car to continue working and working safely in non typical thriving conditions.
- thesagan 10y agoAbsolutely. In Michigan winters, and in most other circumstances, I definitely want to be the one driving if I'm the one that's at risk of [and has great incentive to minimize] crashing my automobile. I really don't want to outsource that yet to a remote staffing center.
- sk5t 10y agoAre you really interested in a system that does the right thing 95% of the time, and the wrong thing for three seconds out of every minute? That sounds absolutely nerve-wracking to me.
- mortehu 10y ago> Here, make a decision in at most a second and a half or you crash This is not the kind of system they're talking about at all. From the article: > Nissan’s cubicle-based drivers aren’t emergency backups. If the car hits black ice, it’s in charge of staying on the road. There’s no feasible way to get the human into the loop in time to act. [When encountering an unusual scenario, a] human operator would look around using the car’s cameras and other sensors and issue new instructions—direct control would pose latency issues. Like: When it’s safe, cross the double yellow and get back to the right side after 20 yards.