6 ms·
Online CBT is no more effective than usual GP care for depression
- DanBC 10y agoSubmitting this because some people on HN have said they're building apps to help mental health treatment.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoAs I recall, some influential people in NICE and/or the NHS really wanted this to work because it's vastly cheaper and more available than in-person CBT. This result is consistent with a longstanding but controversial hypothesis that the overall quality of the therapist-client relationship is far more important than the nuts and bolts of whatever theory the therapist follows [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict
- charlieflowers 10y agoI recall something that supports this hypothesis. there is good evidence that merely _reading_ the book "feeling good" by David burns (father of CBT) is as effective as medication. this indicates the relationship matters, because we're talking about people who didn't _act_ on the book, but merely _read_ it.
- garyrob 10y agoA link for that would be appreciated.
- charlieflowers 10y agoWell, this may not have the supporting info you want, but it might help you track it down: http://holisticonline.com/Remedies/Depression/dep_bibliotherapy.htm http://holisticonline.com/Remedies/Depression/dep_bibliother... Here's one relevant quote: "The effectiveness of stand-alone bibliotherapy was evaluated in five published studies by a team of investigators headed by Dr. Forrest Scogin from the University of Alabama. These researchers evaluated the effectiveness of Dr. David Burns' "Feeling Good" as well as Dr. Peter Lewinsohn's "Control Your Depression," as self-administered treatments for depression. The investigators concluded that Feeling Good was as effective as a full course of individual psychotherapy or as treatment with the best antidepressant drugs."
- languagewars 10y agoI played with a free online cbt and got much further than their average participant in this study.. I'm not sure if there is any use to cbt for depression, but I would suspect that it would work better in a preventative fashion. I.e. I did notice that I can let thinking about some social interactions go where they would bother me in the past, but if I was depressed when I played with it, then maybe I would just notice how bad I was at benefiting from CBT at the moment where I should be letting something go.
- df3 10y agoThe study did not seem to separate the results of those who completed online CBT from the majority who did not. An interesting excerpt: "Take-up of computerised CBT was low, despite regular calls to encourage participants to use the programmes. The median number of sessions completed was two out of eight for Beating the Blues and one out of six for MoodGYM. Only 18% of people who started Beating the Blues completed all modules and 16% for MoodGYM." Online CBT definitely is not effective if patients don't complete it despite receiving phone calls. I can imagine that getting the motivation to log in and do it is really difficult when you're already feeling hopeless-- even not-depressed people have enough trouble building and sticking to habits as it is. But I still wonder if online CBT was effective for the small portion of participants who did complete it? What were the characteristics of those who did complete the app? Perhaps we can learn something. CBT app builders should also consider that self-care options for depression have existed for a long time in the form of books. Can an app do a substantially better job than books? The idea of solving medical issues remotely has been tried for decades.
- DanBC 10y ago> But I still wonder if online CBT was effective for the small portion of participants who did complete it? MoodGym and Beating the Blues have some evidence behind them. NICE was recommending Beating the blues because they have some evidence of efficacy for it. Maybe there's a simple fix. Something like Flo to keep people engaged with it, or some kind of gamifaction. http://www.health.org.uk/flo http://www.health.org.uk/flo Or maybe Recovery College combined with online CBT? http://www.health.org.uk/recovery-college http://www.health.org.uk/recovery-college
- WalterSear 10y ago> NICE was recommending Beating the blues because they have some evidence of efficacy for it. You know how 'traditional chinese medicine' came about? Mao needed to invent something to give to the peasants that wasn't expensive as real health care. http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_examiner/2013/10/traditional_chinese_medicine_origins_mao_invented_it_but_didn_t_believe.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_exa...
- tshtf 10y agoCouldn't the headline read: "Online CBT as effective as usual GP care for depression"?
- rrmm 10y agoThe online stuff was in addition to GP care, not in lieu of it.
- phkahler 10y ago>>The online stuff was in addition to GP care, not in lieu of it. And it made no difference. From the article: >> There was no significant difference between usual GP care, Beating the Blues plus usual care, or MoodGYM plus usual care at four, 12 or 24 months. So I would say there was no indication that the online CBT was of any benefit whatsoever.
- grkvlt 10y agoYes, that seems like a much more useful takeaway (at least, assuming that the usual standard of GP care is better than a sugar-pill placebo twice daily; shouting things at a brick wall; playing with kittens; and even 'folk' remedies like pouring a mixture of garlic, powdered chilli, raw eggs and old yoghurt down your trousers.) If so, then it seems like you could replace expensive (for the NHS, and therefore the taxpayer) one-to-one consultation sessions with visiting a website on your phone/tablet/whatever. It frees up doctor time for other patients, or just allows them to pursue other parallel avenues of treatment with the same patient. In fact it would probably also have the side benefit that, because there is none of the stigma or awkwardness associated with going to a doctor for mental health problems, more people are likely to try and get their problems sorted out. Generally a win all round? EDIT OK, I read the article after seeing the sibling comment, and the online CBT is in addition to the usual GPs treatment; sadly not the amazing win that I thought ;( I should trust the headline writers more, but unfortunately buzzfeed and their click-baity ilk have trained me to have a certain wariness and skepticism these days!
- gumby 10y agoto echo df3's point: this study showed that online CBT wasn't that helpful but didn't couldn't tell if it was a compliance issue or a modality issue. This is a classic problem in drug trials as well: you get data on how the drug works in a controlled setting (when the patients are monitored) but in the real world: do people take their meds reliably? It may be that many people suffering depression benefit from the (not specifically trained -- this is the point) GP talking to them as a forcing function. The diet companies know this well.
- chx 10y agoThe original title is "Online cognitive behavioural therapy is no more effective than usual GP care for people with depression" which by no means is the same as the title here because CBT, ahem, has other meanings. Sorry.
- benevol 10y agoI can recommend: 1. Mindful meditation [free] -> Daily practice (30+ minutes) John Kabat-Zinn [0] masters the link between science and meditation and has published very valuable books (including guided/audio meditation exercises) [1]. There are a couple of scientific studies which prove effectiveness [2] [3]. 2. LSD [$5-10/dose + $25/multi-use test kit] -> One-time experience (every 6 months max.) Benefits (mid- and long-term) are similar to those of meditation. It however requires one to literally read/understand/know everything about the substance before applying it (minimum literature: "The psychedelic explorer's guide" by Fadiman). Also, order a test kit and test before you ingest. Certain "edge cases"/people should not try it. In addition, you may be able to access your spiritual dimension, which increases quality of life even further (it is less immediate with meditation). You may combine micro-dosing LSD with meditation for accessing the meditative state easier (it's quite a challenge for depressed people). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Kabat-Zinn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Kabat-Zinn [1] https://thepiratebay.org/torrent/4180277/Mindful_Way_Through_Depression_-_Guided_Meditation_Practices https://thepiratebay.org/torrent/4180277/Mindful_Way_Through... [2] http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to-a-better-brain http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2011/01/eight-weeks-to... [3] http://www.vox.com/2015/8/27/9214697/meditation-brain-neuroscience http://www.vox.com/2015/8/27/9214697/meditation-brain-neuros...
- DanBC 10y agoHow dropping acid saved my life https://www.theguardian.com/global/2017/jan/08/how-dropping-acid-saved-my-life-ayelet-waldman-books-depression?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other https://www.theguardian.com/global/2017/jan/08/how-dropping-...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- droithomme 10y ago"is no more effective than usual" Hm, interesting phrasing. Is this another way of saying "was found to be just as effective as the more expensive standard treatment"? > There was no significant difference between usual GP care, Beating the Blues plus usual care, or MoodGYM plus usual care at four, 12 or 24 months. No significant difference, so it's every bit as good. > CBT delivered online or via a computer was thought to offer a potential low-cost alternative. And it costs less. So yes, they found it is less expensive and works just as well as the standard treatment, but choose to phrase it in a way to indicate the study had failed by saying "is no more effective" which misleadingly implies it might be less effective, rather than the more accurate "is just as effective", which is more clear and accurate given that there was "no significant difference".
- michaelchisari 10y agoI think you're misreading the results. > There was no significant difference between usual GP care, Beating the Blues plus usual care, or MoodGYM plus usual care at four, 12 or 24 months. So if "usual GP care" is the baseline, online CBT doesn't add to that baseline.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lloydde 10y agoThe title is confusing. The article describes that the addition of CBT to the usual care did not improve the outcomes. I would suspect that for these types of illnessss it would be unethical not to prescribe regular care.
- gleenn 10y agoFor those of us who don't know: CBT - Cognitive Behavioral Therapy GP - General practitioner (normal doctor?)
- EvilTerran 10y agoYeah, "general practitioner" in the UK = "primary care physician" or "family doctor" in other countries, more-or-less.
- walrus01 10y agoIf one is familiar with acronyms used in BDSM it is really hard to read CBT and interpret it as its non obscene version...
- Steeeve 10y agoIf the GP care was ineffective, of course the CBT modeled after that care was equally ineffective. To expect any different is just silly. I would be interested to see a study of obvious alternatives - perhaps an online interactive exercise program, something that provided a positive social interaction, or how the use of a sleep tracker could affect depression.