8 ms·
The simulation argument comes from the fact that there a quite a lot of physics effects that are both surprising, and look an awful lot like dirty hacks that a
by stale2002 10y ago
The simulation argument comes from the fact that there a quite a lot of physics effects that are both surprising, and look an awful lot like dirty hacks that a programmer might put it.
Quantum physics looks a lot like lazy evaluation (State doesn't exist until "observed").
The speed of light seems like a hack to prevent an n squared problem of everything in the universe effecting everything at the same time.
- jacoblambda 10y agoReminded me of this. https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/5foq14/if_were_all_living_in_a_computer_simulation_there/damxl3r/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/5foq14/if_were_a...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- woofyman 10y agoI think it's hubris to suggest that just because something is surprising to us that we explain it based on our experience with our own limited technology.
- sashagim 10y agoWell, that's how god was invented.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoOr: the theories we use to explain the nature of reality are metaphors that rest on the technology of the time.
- mjrpes 10y agoIt also seems just as good an argument for the athropic principle.
- Jizzle 10y agoThe appearance that quantum effects might be attributed to 'hacks' probably has more to do with the hackish nature of the Copenhagen interpretation. For instance, there is no stated physical explanation for the collapse of a wavefunction--it is only an extremely convenient way of explaining many experiments. A crude analogy--you can describe the flipping of coins with simple probability, but this is a non-physical yet very convenient explanation.
- laughingman2 10y agoWhat do you think of Bohm's interpretation ?
- Jizzle 10y agoIt's the most obvious counter-interpretation. I think it's become remarkably successful, but also suffers in its embrace of causality. While the Copenhagen interpretation can skirt the issue completely, Bohm's must wrangle with the implications of both relativity and non-locality and no one has been completely successful as such. Also, if it were the leading view, I don't think discussions of a simulated universe would be as popular.
- dghf 10y ago> It's the most obvious counter-interpretation. More obvious than many worlds?
- gpsx 10y agoYes. Many worlds is the single obvious solution. It seems some people don't understand many worlds though. Or maybe there is some other definition I am not aware. I want to describe my understanding here for people's benefit. The idea is that when you make an observation nothing special happens at all. For one, there is no wave function collapse. This is more an idea about how the observer experiences making a measurement. The salient feature is that the observer is not external to the system. He is a part of the system. His belief that the result was heads or tails is coincident in the wave function with the coin being heads or tails. In other words, the user becomes entangled with the system. A toy wave function would look like this (I am leaving off normalization since I can't write a square root of 2): Coin flip result, no observer: |heads> + |tails> Coin flip with observer, "Tom": |heads>|Tom: it was heads> + |tails>|Tom: it was tails> There is no collapse here. However, to Tom it appears as if the world did collapse. For the "version" of him that thinks the coin flip came up heads, his entire world is consistent with the measurement coming up heads. I assumed most people who really understand quantum mechanics believe this (but I may be wrong). And that among them, there is no effort to say "There is no collapse" because indeed the effective result of the measurement is a collapse. I also use the language "wave function collapse" to describe what happens. This not because it is an objective reality of the universe but because it is the way we observe the universe.
- romanhn 10y agoThese are pretty fascinating observations. Are there any books/articles on the concept of "reality = dirty hack"?
- baytrailcat 10y agoSearch for "Digital physics", you will bump into some info.
- xorxornop 10y agoCheck out arXiv:1405.1548v3 The Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Gerard ’t Hooft The author is very far from a crank, too, being one of the most important influences in the Standard Model...
- jayajay 10y agoI haven't heard the 'dirty hack' argument before. Perhaps we only see those things as 'dirty hacks' because of the incompleteness and inelegance of our own theories.
- libraryatnight 10y agoDon't they only seem like hacks through our understanding, though? Once it's starts looking like a hack isn't it just as likely we're missing something that isn't necessarily a simulation issue?
- Retra 10y agoAnd why should nature appear elegant to us?
- tasty_freeze 10y agoThis is the same confident, facile declaration by may technologists who blather on about how we are on the cusp (a decade or two away) of being able to "download" the state of a person's brain and so let them live forever, in a virtual simulation. Such people are entirely ignorant of biology. The analogy to programming, the thing they do know something about, is and irresistible analogy because they don't know enough to see the massive flaws in the analogy. To be more concrete, by using the computerese term of art "hack" you are begging the question.
- jonathanyc 10y agoHis post gave concrete examples of how things look a little like hacks, while yours can literally be summarized as "technologists are ignorant of biology," which is a non-sequitur.
- mirimir 10y agoWell, we had hacksaws long before we had computers ;)
- rtpg 10y agoKind of ironic that the non-local behavior of quantum mechanics would defeat the purpose of the speed of light hack
- gus_massa 10y ago> Quantum physics looks a lot like lazy evaluation (State doesn't exist until "observed"). This is a common misconception (¿among programmers?). Let's think about the double slit experiment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment In a classical word, you must simulate only one path. In a quantum word, you must simulate both. You don´t need some magical conscious observer to force the collapse of the wave function. A CCD detector of a camera or a simple wall is enough to force that the "wave" collapse into a "particle" and the detector or wall gets a small spot where the "particle" hits it. A similar experiment is possible with spin, and you can use that to get a qbit. In a classical word, a qbit is simply a bit and you only have to chose between the 0 or 1 state and simulate it. In a quantum word, you must simulate both. But it's worst with many qbits. Let's say you have a 10 qbits computer. In a classical word you pick a value for each of them and simulate each one, so the total computation is ~10. In a quantum word, you can combine any of the states of the 10 qbits and you must simulate the 1024 states. So the idea that a quantum computers is better than the classical computer is opposed to the idea that quantum physics is some hack to reduce computational resources. I think that the main problem is the quantum mechanics is weird, use a lot of linear algebra, but the calculations are somewhat straightforward and well defined. But the popularization explanations try to avoid the algebra and make some simplifications, so the explanation only keeps the weird part.
- CuriouslyC 10y ago> In a classical word, you must simulate only one path. In a quantum word, you must simulate both. You don´t need some magical conscious observer to force the collapse of the wave function. A CCD detector of a camera or a simple wall is enough to force that the "wave" collapse into a "particle" and the detector or wall gets a small spot where the "particle" hits it. While the alternative seems a little too far out to be true, I have to ask, how do you know? > So the idea that a quantum computers is better than the classical computer is opposed to the idea that quantum physics is some hack to reduce computational resources. Keep in mind, not all operations in a computer take the same amount of time. If those qubits are entangled, you are going to get the state of all of them from a single "operation". Finally, we assume deterministic and stochastic computation take the same time, but that's only true for us because we perform stochastic computations deterministically - I'm pretty sure we could squeeze a lot more performance out of our silicon if we relaxed our accuracy constraints. Additionally, if the universe is a computing system, the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics may be a way to work around paradoxes, i.e. Godel's incompleteness theorem.
- Tenoke 10y ago>The simulation argument comes from the fact that there a quite a lot of physics effects that are both surprising, and look an awful lot like dirty hacks that a programmer might put it. Err, while this might be used to support the hypothesis, the popularized and most discussed version of the simulation argument doesn't even really mention this [0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulation_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulation_hypothesis
- dingbat 10y agoyeah i thought the simulation hypothesis is mainly coming from a probabilistic argument
- tomphoolery 10y agoTo me, it seems like evolution. Because when you get down "to the metal" of the universe, it's really just a bunch of dirty hacks that are thrown together and give off the illusion of uniformity and grace. The way things work at a macroscopic level seem so grand and ultimate, but on the microscopic level of all that it's utter chaos. Random acts of chemical bonding happened to create the life forms we interact with every day, including each other. The universe is a giant hack job, and I think it evolved that way. I'm a big believer in the "multiple nested universes" theory that our universe began as an offshoot of another, parent universe, and that some of the larger/heavier black holes in our universe could be gateways to other child universes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andrepd 10y agoI'm curious, how can you be a "big believer" in something that is entirely made up with absolutely no evidence of any sort to back it up? And how do you mean, dirty hacks. Our fundamental physics nowadays is quite elegant, I'd say, and still we have many questions still to be answered and much deeper to delve till we hit the "bare metal". We've only been in the universe-figuring-out business for real for about 200 years after all!
- alphydan 10y ago> I'm curious, how can you be a "big believer" in something that is entirely made up with absolutely no evidence of any sort to back it up? 7,100,000,000 people seem to find it quite easy [0] (although I'm not one of them) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_religious_populations
- demolish 10y ago> I'm a big believer in the "multiple nested universes" theory that our universe began as an offshoot of another, parent universe, and that some of the larger/heavier black holes in our universe could be gateways to other child universes. but then there's the question of what came before the universe(s) ours originated from and what came before that and so on, since, following our current understanding, everything has an origin even if we were to argue our universe is a simulation, who/what's running the simulation and where did that originate from? how did it come about?
- devoply 10y agoThe simulation argument comes from the fact that our brains are a simulation of our environment. And since they are a simulation we seem to feel as if this world is not real. The world is out there, but our world is in here. Some other people below get down to some of this stuff. We want things to be like this. But they are out there not in here.
- Koshkin 10y agoWe do not observe states, we observe (measure) "observables"; both exist independently from any observers; while state evolves deterministically, an observable, when measured, takes a value, subject to a probability distribution on a set of values, which depends on both the state and the observable in question. (That's basically QM in a nutshell.)