4 ms·
> How many people do you hear complaining that consumers are bearing the cost of seatbelts and airbags installed in cars? We're willing to pay the few extra dol
by dmix 10y ago
> How many people do you hear complaining that consumers are bearing the cost of seatbelts and airbags installed in cars? We're willing to pay the few extra dollars because we all know how dangerous it is to not have those things.
This is not so black/white. Car safety constantly becomes more advanced over the years and it has become a competitive feature of cars to get "best safety rating". So they still spend a lot of R&D money to stay at the top of the line, regardless of fixed regulation.
Often best practices come baked into frameworks that we use now, such as Rails being relatively "secure by default". Which makes adoption of them easier.
But at the same time cyber security evolves quickly too and software updates quickly underneath it, exposing new threats.
So I believe it will always be an R&D investment that will evolve and change over the course of softwares line span.
The question is about incentives. Car manufacturers have a big incentive to make their cars safe because people know how dangerous cars are and consider that as part of their high-dollar purchase. There is also a big consumer reports style industry around car safety to inform users. Also car manufacturers (and physical products in general) actually kill people increasing the liability of a broken product.
Most software lacks those incentives for a variety of reasons. Such as low cost barrier to entry, lack of understanding of security, lack of tactile differences, low time investment evaluating alternatives, low cost to publishers when hacks do happen, etc.
I'm all for the cyber security industry maturing and software security best standards being taught to every developer. But I don't think we have the costs, consumer understanding, or infrastructure entirely in place or figured out yet to have an optimal effect.
At the same time it's very possible it might remain a constantly moving target and be a larger challenge than most other engineering safety standards, like buildings or vehicles. Something to consider.
- freehunter 10y agoYou're 100% right, which is why "periodic evaluation of industry standards" is such a critical part of any SDLC or best practice. Tech moves faster than other industries of course, but in general technology is just a sped-up clone of basically anything else. We didn't (and couldn't) make a definitive set of best practices the day we invented the computer, we made them up as we went along. Like the car industry, where safety standards were tightened as technology improved. We do have companies already making a stand on security, using it as a competitive advantage. Apple, for one, has staked their name on their security in the past few years. That's their competitive advantage, is how secure TouchID and their secure enclave is. You're right that consumers don't see security as entirely necessary yet, but it took a long time for seat belts and airbags to become standard in cars, and even longer for them to be appreciated. Even today, many people refuse to wear seat belts. But bear in mind, automotive security is a moving target too. Seatbelts, then airbags, then roll cages, then crumble zones, then backup cameras, then backup sensors, then automatic parking, then self-driving. There's very little that's new in the world, it's almost always been done before.
- pjmlp 10y agoTo add up to it, here is one example of companies that validate security in high integrity systems. http://www.ldra.com/en/software-quality-test-tools http://www.ldra.com/en/software-quality-test-tools Namely for C, C++, Java and Ada stacks on the domains of medicine, trains, aviation, automotive, factory automation. This needs to be extended to other business domains.