8 ms·
Jimbo Wales exiles 'porn' from Wikiland
- ugh 17y agoThe big problem with any centralized deletion of porn is that there is no standard definition of porn. Commons should strive to only exclude images which can lead to legal problems and leave the decision which of the remaining images to use up to the different language Wikipedias. Maybe that’s what they plan to do and I would have no problem with that. I would have a problem if they went above and beyond that.
- buro9 17y agoEven that would be a problem... legal problems according to what legal domain? What is acceptable in some US States is wildly different from what is acceptable in some EU countries. The concern I have is greater than the definition of what is or is not pornographic, but it is the underlying notion that some entity feels that I should not see something, that a puritanical approach has come in at the top. To me this is the greater problem. If we stick to legal definitions then we're in a much better position, even though the lack of a global legal system introduces technical issues about what is stored where, and what is available to whom (according to where they are) and the maintenance of that legal knowledge (that in one region the laws are X, Y and Z and that in another the laws are B, C and D).
- ErrantX 17y agoThat Sanger thing was just him trolling; I'm surprised it got the rise it has done... (there is no way those "etchings" would ever have been considered CP by a criminal prosecutor)
- jacquesm 17y agoThey might not have been in the best taste though.
- goatforce5 17y agoFWIW, the UK police often get confused between art and child porn: http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2007/sep/25/artnews.art http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2007/sep/25/artnews.art
- ErrantX 17y agoThere is a distinct difference between a "created" image and a photograph (which the suggestion in your link is). The wood carvings are probably fine; you have to take a pragmatic approach at some point. Artistic (non-abusive) photography is also usually fine - I'm not sure what the outcome of that specific case was but I expect nothing came of it. The point is to capture those abusing - or encouraging the abuse of - children. So you will find occasional contradictions and difficult distinctions.
- goatforce5 17y agoMy point was it's probably not wise to assume what the authorities may or may not find actionable.
- ErrantX 17y agoAh, I see. Well I work in investigating computer pedophilia (among other things). Obviously there is still a caveat of "within my experience" but I am quite confident that nothing will come of this particular complaint to the FBI.
- pyre 17y agoI think that what may happen in a lot of these cases is that the authorities subscribe to the, "if there's smoke, there's fire," train of thought. If they see that someone has art of small children (or just 'under age' children), they'll probably bust down their door hoping to find actual child porn. If they don't, then they'll try to make 'child porn' charges stick using just the art because the authorities involved at this point either don't like the person or just don't want to admit that they were wrong (and spent a bunch of wasted time for nothing).
- goodside 17y agoThe biggest criticism of this purge seems to be that the definition of pornography might have been slightly too restrictive. Some good images were lost that might not have been legally required to be removed. So what? The Wikimedia Foundation can't be expected to toe the line, deciding for itself exactly what pornography will result in criminal prosecution and just keeping their fingers crossed that the State of Florida will agree with them. The laws on obscenity are complex and inconsistent. American citizens have been convicted of criminal obscenity for possessing drawings of children engaging in sex acts, whose production did not involve any actual child. Perfect discrimination between legal and illegal images is not possible, and they've decided that an error of unnecessarily deleting "good" pornography is preferable to an error of distributing illegal images of minors. I've been a Wikipedia editor since 2004, and I can say from experience that child pornography is not some mythical boogieman. It does exist on WP, and it can go undetected for a surprisingly long time. The most recent example I can think of is an article on a medical condition that involves as a symptom the swelling of the breasts in pre-pubescent girls. A photograph was added showing a very young girl standing topless with her eyes edited from the photo, showing the camera her prematurely large breasts. The image caption was a brief description saying that the girl was 13 years old, had the relevant medical condition, and that the uploader, whose username began with "Dr", took the photo himself in Brazil. Uploading this image was the user's only contribution, and he hasn't been seen since. It was literally months before any editor looked closely enough at the situation to realize that this might not be fully kosher. This isn't because editors are lazy or naive. Wikipedia is a big place, and catching these things happens almost entirely by happenstance. Once the issue was raised on Media for Deletion, consensus was quick that it had to go. But while the image is gone from WP, it's more popular than ever elsewhere. A Google image search for the title of the article will reveal the image re-hosted across dozens of web sites, which is why I'm being so scarce on the details here. The Foundation has to make a decision on whether preventing incidents like this is worth the downside of forbidding some pornography, the only redeeming feature of which is often that it isn't illegal, should be hosted on Wikimedia servers, exposing the Wales and the Board to the possibility of severe criminal penalties. We have no moral ground from which to accuse them of shirking their responsibilities if they decline.
- AgileCyborg 17y ago
- aw3c2 17y agoA somehow distributed (to resist censorship) and encrypt (against problems with varying local legislation) wikipedia would not have problems like this.
- kragen 17y agoWe can hope. It might also turn out that censors, irritated by the resistance, would criminalize participation in it.