5 ms·
Like others I don't shed a lot of tears when an exec makes only 89% of their multi-million dollar target bonus :-) I asked an exec at Oracle once about how it w
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Like others I don't shed a lot of tears when an exec makes only 89% of their multi-million dollar target bonus :-) I asked an exec at Oracle once about how it was even motivating. For much of my career I've had some sort of bonus associated with my salary, at Sun, NetApp, Google all had bonus programs (with different tweaks). And for an engineer it could be a huge thing. At Google with all the multipliers in place you could get your entire salary paid again in just bonus money if you were a superstar. For an engineer that can be hugely motivating because they need their salary to live on, so bonus money is "extra".
But when you're an executive and the different in bonus is $8M vs $5M? Sure its a huge number that you didn't get an extra three million dollars but what can you do differently with $8M that you can't do with $5M? So my question to the Oracle exec was "Does it really motivate you to work harder, smarter, etc if the difference between hitting it out of the park and not doing so has no impact on your lifestyle?" And his answer was that most of the people that he worked with were "score" motivated, it wasn't the money it was that they had a bigger score than their competitive exec.
I'm not sure I really believe that. I mean could Oracle just have Brownie Points as their bonus metric and still get the same performance effort? But it really did surprise me that the number was important even though the effect of the number on their lifestyle was probably not noticeable.
I think Tim needs to avoid being painted like Steve Ballmer, an exec that led Microsoft to higher growth, profit, and sales, and into the swamp. And for that reason, not the size of his bonus this year, he needs to pay attention to the changing forces in the market.
- Skunkleton 10y ago> I'm not sure I really believe that. I mean could Oracle just have Brownie Points as their bonus metric and still get the same performance effort? No, because brownie points are not backed by the full faith of the US government.
- karyon 10y agoThis sounds a bit like "my income is normal, and everyone above that is rich"-thinking that a lot of people have.(if there's a word for that i'd appreciate any hints :) ) i'd definitely consider engineers at google to be rich and don't see how another 200k makes that much of a difference. you think these execs are rich and don't see how another million makes a difference. and the execs consider billionaires to be rich and don't see how another billion makes a difference. it's just different scales, but who's actually right? i think it's important to realise that the scale of income has an extreme range and we are already on the upper end and definitely rich by global standards. my personal opinion is that a majority of people living in the western world is actually rich and any complaints on salaries by these are just first world problems. on a more constructive note, i think i've seen a study that said that higher salary actually does motivate more, but hits the point of diminishing returns at about (i think) 80k or 100k. I don't remember which country and whether it was $ or €, but that should give a sense of the rough order of magnitude.
- zackkrida 10y agoThis would be true except that there are fixed costs of living. Say Tim Cook was making three million less -- is he going to have to make lifestyle changes to spend 3 million less a year? No way. A person making 60k a year losing 15% of their income? There's likely to be significant lifestyle changes.
- karyon 10y agoI'm pretty sure that there are lifestyles that burn several millions per year, and my guess would be there are people living a happy life with less than 60k. but of course it's true that the further you go up the scale, the more absurd it becomes to talk about serious comfort losses, and there's a point on the lower end where we're talking about actual poverty.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoYou might be hard pressed to construct one without getting a bit crazy. Most of the cost is going to be salaries of staff. At the extremes you have the Royal Family of England[1] ($43M) and Warren Buffet[2] (<.5M$). [1] http://home.bt.com/lifestyle/money/mortgages-bills/how-much-does-the-royal-family-cost-11363982445194 http://home.bt.com/lifestyle/money/mortgages-bills/how-much-... [2] (warning self starting video) http://www.investopedia.com/articles/financialcareers/10/buffett-frugal.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/financialcareers/10/buf...
- hyperpape 10y agoThe killer for entertainers and sports figures who blow through tons of money is keeping an entourage. There are probably tech figures who have one, but I don't know who they are.
- OJFord 10y agoWhether or not it necessitates a 'lifestyle change' depends on what you spend as a proportion of your income; not your income alone. Furthermore, I think any financial advisor would advise that your 'lifestyle' not depend on one year's bonus!
- roymurdock 10y agoSince it is impossible to give a precise estimate of each manager's contribution to the firm's output, it is inevitable that this process yields decisions that are largely arbitrary and dependent on hierarchical relationships and on the relative bargaining power of the individuals involved. It is only reasonable to assume that people in a position to set their own salaries have a natural incentive to treat themselves generously, or at the very least to be rather optimistic in gauging their marginal productivity. To behave in this way is only human, especially since the necessary information is, in objective terms, highly imperfect. It may be excessive to accuse senior executives of having their "hands in the till," but the metaphor is probably more apt than Adam Smith's metaphor of the market's "invisible hand." In practice, the invisible hand does not exist, any more than "pure and perfect" competition does, and the market is always embodied in specific institutions such as corporate hierarchies and compensation committees. Piketty, Capital in the Twenty First Century
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI largely disagree with Piketty in this case. There are metrics which are available to management which provide the specific insights needed to drive compensation to the most appropriate individuals. I do not disagree that there management systems which ignore those metrics and base their compensation on relationships. I agree with the basic thesis that as the productivity of workers (as measured by $ generated per worker hour of labor) has gone up tremendously in the silicon age, and that the fruits of that gain have been disproportionately allocated to management. But as the root of that gain has been the transition for goods economies to information economies, and information economies are particularly susceptible to price correction through antagonistic action[1] Given the challenges of creating barriers to entry, the information economics will (in my opinion of course) eventually force capital to the creators away from management. [1] In the goods economy if the price of a car is too high you substitute other goods (like bikes or motorcycles) but in an information economy if your price is too high people simply pirate the content and take the capital out by force. cite: Netflix vs Napster vs MPAA.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 10y agoIf you were a competitive person, you'd understand. Bigger is better. As simple as that.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI think ultimately this is the correct answer for me.
- paulddraper 10y ago> Sure its a huge number that you didn't get an extra three million dollars but what can you do differently with $8M that you can't do with $5M? You can do a heck of a lot more with $3m than $13k. I know you're thinking proportionally, but that's not necessarily correct. And you can always find things you really need the money for. Want a mega-yacht? Better start saving, because $13M ain't gonna cut it.
- ecdavis 10y ago"The only difference between $10 million and $50 million is an astounding $40 million." - Dave Chappelle
- saurik 10y agoThe issue is not that he is making 15% less salary, the issue is that we all know that he was punished: that must feel devastating. That the punishment may or may not be something you consider harsh or not doesn't matter: the real punishment is that CNN just wrote an article about how Apple is having issues and important people are blaming Tim Cook, and reducing a CEO's salary at a publicly traded company is a "forced public" punishment.
- femto113 10y agoThis article and its headline are misleading. No one is being "punished" and no one's pay is being "cut". All that happened is that 2015 was a blowout year and 2016 was (by comparison) not, so the exec team got a lower percentage of their target bonuses. From the actual filing 2016 net sales and operating income were 96.4% and 99.5% of the respective target goals set by the Compensation Committee. This performance resulted in a combined payout at 89.5% of target for each named executive officer ... the 2016 payouts to our named executive officers were significantly less than the annual cash incentive payouts for 2015, reflecting strong pay-for-performance alignment. The Compensation Committee determined that no downward adjustments to the payouts would be made, based on Apple’s 2016 performance and the individual contributions of our named executive officers.
- Maascamp 10y ago> I'm not sure I really believe that. I can believe it. I once worked at an investment bank where, during bonus time, I needed to deal with an issue at a trading desk. While there I had the following conversation with a particularly angry fixed income trader. Me: Hey Trader, what's got you so pissed off? Trader: Just got my bonus. I got 13MM, but Trader2 got 16MM! Can you believe it?! I made way more money than Trader2 this year!!! Me: ... His anger had nothing to do with total dollar amounts. It was only that someone he rates himself against made more. Nice problems to have.