7 ms·
> You begin by implying that discrimination and disadvantage for women is equivalent to men The reason you say 'imply' is because I didn't actually say this.
by Chris2048 10y ago
> You begin by implying that discrimination and disadvantage for women is equivalent to men
The reason you say 'imply' is because I didn't actually say this.
You said they aren't equivalent, and I asked for qualification. The difference is the burden is on you, not me; You can't flip it around and say "Well, prove it isn't".
Demonstrating anything is hard, especially something this broadly stated, which is why I never made any such claims in the first place, and if I had I'd make it a less broad.
But yes, I strongly suspect men and women are equal in many places, but not world wide, or even in all localities, which is again why I don't want to have to prove your generalisation; If I feel I can demonstrate something, I'll narrow down the claim as appropriate.
> There are a ton of studies showing
If you gave a citation, I might be able to get some context from it, e.g country, culture etc. I'm not keen on assuming a universal form of feminism, nor do I assume you need to be a feminist to fight gender inequality (much like you don't need to be religious to be good - "Without [religion], you'd have good people doing good things, and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion").
Tell me social calculus you are using to determine that "abortion legislation affects women more than men". Seems to me you need to decide on a very specific definition of "affect".
> If you move beyond the most developed countries
There is little feminism. It's nice to chalk all women's' rights progress up to feminism, more "feminism by the dictionary"; but that's not the same as "feminism the ideology" - that feminism is a very specific culture of beliefs and discourse that isn't necessary or sufficient for the improvement of women's rights. The lack of distinction is on purpose, to make it seem like there is only only set of beliefs compatible with the development of women's rights.
> that doesn't make focusing on women's issues wrong any more than the Prevent Cancer Foundation is evil for not tackling Alzheimer's
That's true, unless "focusing on women's issue" also involves promoting ideologies.
In cases where that ideology is harmful to men, it's more akin to a christian organisation refusing funding for men with HIV.
> why is it suddenly limited to law
The context here is when people say "what about men". in the context of any subject, this is not done to change the topic, but the change the focus of the topic.
"what about men" in the context of rape, is in the context of rape law, and how it also affects men.
However, it could also be in the context of prison rape. Maybe that is a worthy topic, but I'd also argue that it is a different topic (prisoners rights/care, and the disproportionate number of men in prison).
> that doesn't somehow make the women's issues unimportant.
Agreed, but I didn't say this. you brought up disproportionate effect.
> It is viewed differently by society (she asked for it).
which society? Can you demonstrate this is a common opinion in modern western countries. I hear this all the time, but have met few people that don't aggressively disagree, or at least have a more nuanced opinion.
> In some places the law is burdensome on the victim to nearly impossible levels.
Which places, in relative to burden on 'perpetrator'. There are other places where an accusation of rape can be devastating without any burden of proof.
Maybe we should be talking specifics?
> making out that it's sexist in reverse to be a feminist.
Can you quote me on that? I have a broad view of what constitutes "feminism" (pretty much anything), and a different view on how feminist discourse is often practiced.
> If they do, they are wrong to do so.
No one will yank their feminist credentials though, and people will still equate feminism with good; "it can't be bad, it's feminist".
If no one denies harmful groups the feminist label, it can no longer be assumed that feminist groups aren't harmful.
> but you shouldn't be rejected because you are a woman
Can I be a surrogate then? Or the legal mother of my child? (I'm male, obv)
> There was a time when women were literally property
Not anymore, and not during my lifetime - so what has this got to do with anything?
"there must be some subconscious influence from the past" - or something like that?
> Just as racism is better, but not solved
again, tell me what you mean by "solved".
> Clearly the wage gap is caused by multiple factors that are hard to split
yet the soundbite is repeated, again and again, by respected feminists without any nuance. other feminists do not call out this behavior.
It took a lot of effort, by many risking reputation and ridicule, to establish that it was more complicated. Maybe we see different sides of the feminist sphere?
> A nonsense example
Maybe I misinterpreted the following:
> We are not at a point of gender equality yet, so to imply that feminism is wrong when it tries to push for more rights for women is misleading.
--
When I have the time, I think I might break some of this down. The linear nature of HN isn't ideal for long threads...
- Latty 10y agoYour post is essentially a giant attempt to redefine things until you are right. Anything good feminism does isn't really feminism. Anything bad anyone does is. Talking about feminism is therefore bad because it's bad. Not to mention the circular logic - feminism is bad because she's written an article about encouraging her kids to be feminists which is bad because feminism is bad. You are picking out little bits of my post and arguing against them, but ignoring the actual points I made. I'm not going to argue back on each little point because it's irrelevant to the point I'm trying to make - just noise leading off. I made a post saying the site was bad because it is portraying feminism incorrectly - this article, and moreso the article linked are designed to make men feel persecuted by extremists feminists when that doesn't reflect the situation. You argue that the article/site are reasonable, because feminism is now largely an extremist movement now, and it is anti-men enough to be a problem, not simply pro-women. That, I argue, is complete rubbish. Discrimination against women still happens. The article I linked is not anti-man at all, and your arguments that it is don't hold water, and are essentially circular reasoning and 'that's how I see it'. Please, don't dissect my post and cherry-pick bits to strawman. Stay on topic to the core point.
- Chris2048 10y ago> giant attempt to redefine things until you are right. That would be the no true scotsman I guess, but actually you invoked this with your "crazy" feminism. I'm the one that said there isn't really any such thing as a singular feminism. > Not to mention the circular logic No, the circular logic is in your poor interpretation. > which is bad because feminism is bad. This is a consistent argument, about which I say more. It's only circular in the strict way you stated it, which is a purposeful misrepresentation in order to portray it as circular. > ignoring the actual points I made which are the important ones I ignored? You say a lot that doesn't follow strictly from the points I made, and don't expand on them. If I responded to everything you write I'd be doing a lot of the work; for example, you throw out a load of ungrounded accusations, which I generally ignore. > made a post saying the site was bad because it is portraying feminism incorrectly > Stay on topic to the core point. If you want the thread to stay on topic, then stay on topic yourself. I've generally just responded. > You argue that the article/site are reasonable, because feminism is now largely an extremist movement now, and it is anti-men enough to be a problem, not simply pro-women. Some feminism. And if you can't see the distinction, then probably your feminism. > Discrimination against women still happens This is a low bar. What does it mean? I've stated enough times a need for specific standards for what constitutes "unequal", so what exactly do you mean by this? > cherry-pick bits to strawman I can only "cherry-pick to strawman" if I misrepresent your arguments (as a strawman), which did I misrepresent?