3 ms·
> I would guess that the risk of a nuclear holocaust is 0.1% per year or more > I would guess Based on what? Unless it's based on something similar to where y
by pc86 10y ago
> I would guess that the risk of a nuclear holocaust is 0.1% per year or more
> I would guess
Based on what? Unless it's based on something similar to where you got the 0.1% risk for a tornado it's no more accurate a guess than if you had said 0.01% or 1% or 80%.
- mikeash 10y agoBased on my understanding of the situation, and in particular based on several incidents over the past six decades where it was narrowly averted in situations where a few people having a bad day could have made it happen. I'm not making any claim to accuracy. That's why I used the word "guess." Note that the comment I replied to implies that the risk of a nuclear holocaust is "much lower" than 0.1% per year. Why aren't you hassling them about that claim too? Unlike me, they just stated it as if it were a plain fact.
- peatmoss 10y agoHe's a Bayesian, and his priors are predicated on the belief that the lack of apparent intelligent life in the universe is attributable to self-annihilation. In all seriousness, calculating a probability of death from nuclear calamity isn't going to be possible without a great number of caveats and assumptions. It isn't like a meteor strike, because we at least have some record of that stretching back a long time. It's also not like meteor strikes because I believe the disaster generating process (people with buttons wired to faulty / hackable control systems) to be a giant mess of scary.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoHe didn't say '0.1% risk' he said it's 0.1% or more, with no upper bound. By giving a wide range he wasn't implying any sort of accuracy at all.
- Retric 10y agoBased on several past incidents I would say we had a 50/50 shot of a nuclear holocaust over the last 70 years. That's around 1% per year. However, most of the incidents seem to be fairly old so we can probably drop that to 0.1% per year unless you live in India or Pakistan. EX: "Solar Sunrise" is not that old and the US was seriously considering using nukes as NORAD was having major issues. IMO, large scale nuclear war was still unlikely, but the odds where probably well over 1% that year. PS: Remember, WWI started from a chain of events that also seemed unlikely. But, a lot of stuff happens in any given year making such chains more common than you would think.
- rumcajz 10y agoThink of it this way: You are in a locked room with 9 idiots each holding a granade. What's your life expectancy? Even worse, with even more particle physics, gene engineering, nanotechnology, artificial intelligence etc. you'll be soon locked up in a room with 7 billion idiots each holding a granade, a bazooka and a flame-thrower.
- mikeash 10y agoOn one hand, you've been locked in the room with a slowly growing group of idiots for decades and nobody has started throwing grenades, at least not since John threw a couple of them when he got excited after being the first one in the room. On the other hand, Ivan keeps making strange faces at his grenade, Ali is playing "guess where I hid the grenade" and keeps getting into fistfights with Sanjay, Kim just barged in with a new grenade and keeps shouting at everyone, and John suddenly seems a lot more enthusiastic about blowing shit up real good.