4 ms·
I get this a lot from dedicated ebook readers: "I don't care about formatting and design in ebooks!" I think this is a peculiar kind of brain damage or mental
by patio11 17y ago
I get this a lot from dedicated ebook readers: "I don't care about formatting and design in ebooks!"
I think this is a peculiar kind of brain damage or mental scarring...
As someone who shares this "brain damage", these lines puts me in the mood of a designer who, seeing objective statistical evidence that his redesign was outperformed by the older, uglier website, dismisses the metrics and rants about art for a few hours.
- petercooper 17y agoExcept, the most significant layout and typography issues involved in book design and usability have been studied. A basic example would be in the use of fully justified text versus ragged right: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1286700 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1286700 .. that topic not scream "design" to you, but it's all part of producing a high quality book. So are choosing the right typeface(s), the right text size(s), page layout, and more. Authors and book designers who have high production values aren't all arty-farty designers who just want things to look cool. To many, just getting it right objectively (versus the subjectiveness of design as "art") is important, and there are ways and means of doing that. For example, the average Edward Tufte book shows a high level of attention to detail in matters of underlying design and usability, rather than pure aesthetics. Readers should care about book formatting and design at a basic usability and readability level. You might not want pompously "designed" books, sure, but having easily read type in a usable layout is paramount (in the sense that a Web surfer wouldn't like to read beige text on a yellow background). Sadly, it seems not to be as big an issue as it could be as the jaw-droppingly bad typography on the Kindle demonstrates: http://redubllc.com/2009/01/a-typographic-critique-of-the-kindle/ http://redubllc.com/2009/01/a-typographic-critique-of-the-ki... - http://qwan.org/2009/05/17/kindle-typography-goes-craptacular/ http://qwan.org/2009/05/17/kindle-typography-goes-craptacula... - http://www.teleread.org/2009/05/05/kindle-page-layout-and-typography/ http://www.teleread.org/2009/05/05/kindle-page-layout-and-ty... (and oh so many more)
- ptomato 17y agoBecause performance metrics are the only things that matter.
- RevRal 17y agoMostly because I can just throw them onto my portable device, I'll almost always prefer a plain text file over a pdf.
- ahoyhere 17y agoDefined "outperform." I love your writing, so I know you know better than that. What if you get more signups for your email newsletter - but fewer conversions to customers down the line? What if you make more sales, but they incur more support over the 12 mos? Or are simply more stupid/more annoying/more rude? What if you make more sales, but they don't USE the product? Or use it effectively, to its fullest extent? (Whether or not they bug you about it.) What if you just, flat out, get customers who don't support your values/the direction you want to take your business? Science never stops. More is not better, necessarily - call no man happy until he is dead, and call no additional customer good until the relationship is at its complete and utter end. And just because people say they don't care about book design, doesn't mean that's actually how they behave. And just because they behave a certain way now, doesn't mean they wouldn't behave differently, offered a superior solution. And just because they think they there's no difference, doesn't mean they don't actually experience the book better given (as another commentor said) a provably superior product in terms of readability. Simplifying it as artsy fartsy prissiness, and wielding just-one-step "science" as a weapon, is doing everyone, and everything, a disfavor.