13 ms·
Some immediate thoughts: 1. 6000 lux is a _lot_ of light. 2. The LEDs tested are not the "warm white" (1500-2500K) commonly used as replacements for incande
by hprotagonist 10y ago
Some immediate thoughts:
1. 6000 lux is a _lot_ of light.
2. The LEDs tested are not the "warm white" (1500-2500K) commonly used as replacements for incandescent bulbs in the US. They're the "blue white" (>4000K) ones, or pure blue or pure green at specific wavelengths.
With those constraints, it's an interesting result. It does not mean you need to run home and rip all the lights out, though.
- robert_tweed 10y agoCan't see the full paper, just the abstract, but another thing I wondered if they took into account is the effect of strobing. They didn't include a control that doesn't strobe (such as halogen), since CFLs strobe in the kHz range. LEDs may or may not strobe depending on how they are driven and that isn't stated in the abstract. It does however, seem much more likely that this is to do with extra energy in the UV end of the spectrum, which IIRC WW LEDs cut a lot more of (as well as the additional, visible blue light that makes CW seem so much brighter).
- sandworm101 10y agoIf the issue is confined to the uv, it's a dead-simple to fix. A uv-absorbant filter (ie like on all eyewear since the 80s) should eliminate the problem. Costs would be next to nothing. Conversely, anyone worried could don any eyeware, even swimming goggles have such coatings.
- nine_k 10y agoI can tell when LEDs are strobed at the (double) mains frequency; e.g. Christmas LED lights that likely blink at 120 Hz, since they don't have any electronics beside the LEDs. These do give me a slight nausea. Compared to these, I can conclude that my home LED lights likely strobe in kHz range or above, or maybe not at all.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- waqf 10y agoCheap Christmas LEDs with no electronics look so awful because they strobe at 60Hz and are completely off for a full half-cycle (while the LEDs are reverse-biased). I can't speak for you but I find the full-wave rectified ones not to be a problem. Of course the difference isn't just the doubled frequency, it's also a much higher duty cycle.
- Tharkun 10y agoOh wow, thanks for pointing that out. I thought I was having a migraine aura when I noticed vaguely flickering christmas lights out of the corner of my eye.
- kristofferR 10y ago> Can't see the full paper, just the abstract http://www.sciencedirect.com.sci-hub.ac/science/article/pii/S0306452216305243 http://www.sciencedirect.com.sci-hub.ac/science/article/pii/...
- cynwoody 10y agoThanks! I didn't know about this mysterious sci-hub, but now I do. More info on sci-hub: http://bitesizebio.com/28268/access-science-free/ http://bitesizebio.com/28268/access-science-free/
- wlesieutre 10y agoFor comparison, typical artificial light levels in an office are more like 300 lux. IES recommended illuminance for a professional indoor basketball court is 1000 lux. Daylight ranges up to 120,000 lux, so 6000 is several times the lighting in most spaces, but still nowhere near bright sunlight. That said, from the abstract (I don't have journal access), it sounds like they found a result in both 24H high intensity, and in on/off "domestic levels". Is the 6000 lux you mentioned their value for high intensity, or is that what they considered as domestic levels?
- vmarsy 10y agomultiple experiments were made, one at 6000 as the GP mentions, but also one at 500 lux. There's more information here but in French[1][2]: On the other hand, by exposing the same animals to a luminous intensity similar to that usually used in dwellings (500 lux) for 24 hours, only the LEDs appeared harmful [1] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.inserm.fr%2Factualites%2Frubriques%2Factualites-recherche%2Fles-led-pas-si-inoffensives-que-ca&edit-text= https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&js=y&prev... [2] http://www.inserm.fr/actualites/rubriques/actualites-recherche/les-led-pas-si-inoffensives-que-ca http://www.inserm.fr/actualites/rubriques/actualites-recherc...
- Zak 10y ago500 lux is also much greater than what reaches your eyes in a typical household lighting scenario. If you stare in to a 100W incandescent light bulb from one meter, you're getting about 100 lux to your eyes. We don't usually stare at light sources; we use them to illuminate objects. A 100W incandescent from 1 meter on to reading material or other work is considered fairly brightly lit, and that's not getting the full 100 lux back to your eyes - only what the surface reflects. Daylight is far brighter, but most of us have been warned from early childhood about the danger of staring at the sun. 100,000 lux may be present, but we're not directing it in to our eyes.
- phasetransition 10y agoI don't have access behind the paywall, but I do run engineering for a luminaire manufacturer. Do you have access to the full details of the illuminance source and output?
- wflynny 10y ago> Light sources > We used two types of lighting devices. For exposure to white LED, commercial cold white LED panel generating 2300 lumens during 24 h was used. The LED panel was placed above 8 transparent cages, placed on white surfaces, leaving enough space for air circulation and constant temperature maintenance at 21 °C. The illuminance measured at the rats’ eyes position was 6000 lux (Photometre DT-8809A, CEM, China). > For long-term exposure, specific devices were built and characterized by Statice, France (Fig. 1A). Metallic boxes contained rows of LED with a diffuser in order to improve the directional uniformity of the radiation and avoid punctate sources. Alternatively, CCFL or CFL were uniformly distributed around the metal cages. Each cage was placed in a metallic device that was then placed in a ventilated cupboard allowing for a constant 21 °C temperature control (Fig. 1A). The light intensity was controllable and the distribution of light in the cage was homogenous whatever the rat position. Different types of LEDs were used: cold-white LED (pure white 6300 K), blue LED (royal blue 455–465 nm), and green LED (520–35 nm) (Z-power LED, Seoul Semiconductor, Korea). Exposure intensity was spectrophotometrically measured by Statice. > Exposure protocols > Acute exposure: LE and W rats were maintained in a cyclic light/dark (250 lux, 12 h/12 h) environment for 21 days. The day before light exposure, rats were dark-adapted for 16 h. The next day, pupils were dilated with 1% atropine (Alcon, Norvartis, Rueil Malmaison, France) under dim light, and rats were isolated in separate cages containing enough food for one day. After 24 h of exposure, rats were placed again in a cyclic light/dark (250 lux, 12 h/12 h) environment for 7 days and sacrificed for histology and immunofluorescence analysis. Control rats were submitted to the same pre conditioning protocol but not exposed to light. Different types of light sources and light intensities were used as detailed in Fig. 1B. For cold-white LED, different light intensities were tested from 6000 lux, to 1500, 1000 and 500 lux. Blue and green LEDs were used at 500 lux which is the domestic classic light intensity. CFL was used at 6000 lux and 500 lux, CCFL at 6000 lux. Illuminance was measured at the level of the rat eye. > Long-term exposures: Rats (LE and W) were maintained in a cyclic light/dark (250 lux, 12 h/12 h) environment for 21 days, then placed in specific cages for chronic cyclic exposure to different types of light at 500 lux: CFL, white, green and blue LEDs. Animals were sacrificed right after 8 or 28 days of exposure. For the long-term protocol and in order to be as close to domestic light as possible, rat pupils were not dilated. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2016.10.015 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2016.10.015
- ajross 10y agoYeah. The hypothesis seems to be that the blue end of the spectrum is the danger here, LEDs being relatively bluer than incandescents or common fluorescent phosphors. But even so, the high energy spectral content of indoor LED lighting is much, much less than what you see from direct sunlight. If LEDs are really a vision risk to the modern office worker, they're significantly less so than the same risk of agricultural or other outdoor workers.
- NickM 10y agoI agree with you that this is probably overblown. But, just to play devil's advocate, it seems plausible that sunlight might activate some kind of defense mechanism in the eye that protects it from the effects of the higher energy part of the spectrum. If nothing else, the overall brightness levels would cause your pupil to shrink more in sunlight than under LED lighting.
- jessriedel 10y agoIt's definitely a good point. Dark sunglasses that don't block UV light can actually increase damage to your eyes, because your pupil dilates in response to visible light only. http://healthland.time.com/2009/08/04/can-cheap-sunglasses-be-bad-for-your-eyes/ http://healthland.time.com/2009/08/04/can-cheap-sunglasses-b... However, the ganglion cells that influence dilation and melatonin happen to be mostly sensitive to blue light (~470 nm), so in theory this would only be a problem for LEDs largely concentrated at even shorter wavelength. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intrinsically_photosensitive_retinal_ganglion_cells https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intrinsically_photosensitive_r...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 10y agoOne group of people who could potentially be affected: people who use anti-SAD lighting (especially people building souped-up DIY rigs: https://meaningness.com/metablog/sad-light-led-lux https://meaningness.com/metablog/sad-light-led-lux). Those use LEDs and are specifically meant to be very bright and very blue. Hopefully this turns out not to be a big deal. Having to choose between depression and retina damage would sure suck :/
- WalterSear 10y agoThere has to be a happy medium. If we aren't built for stupid amounts of blue light, then it seems counter-intuitive that some people might need that.
- r00fus 10y agoIt could be that we're not built for specular (tight-beam) intensity with lower intensity all around (ie, high contrast).
- GenerocUsername 10y agoAlso, those lights are suggested for skin exposure, not for staring directly into or for illuminating your space... still though, proximity would encourage more harmful interactions.
- mordechai9000 10y agoThey are not intended strictly for skin exposure. They are marketed and used as a way to expose your eye (brain) to the high light levels that (may be) needed to regulate diurnal activity.
- jsjohnst 10y agoThe Phillips light specifically has warnings about not looking directly at it, but rather having it in your peripheral vision. It calls out that eye damage can happen if staring directly at the light for prolonged periods.
- stuckagain 10y agoThis level of illumination is 20x or more what you'd expect in a household situation.
- profalseidol 10y agoPropaganda then?
- tedunangst 10y agoAlthough if you want to measure an effect in a reasonable time frame, you'd up the concentration. You won't measure much damage from a "reasonable" amount of lead in a short time frame, either, but over longer time scales you'll probably conclude that you want to rescale reasonable downwards.
- y7 10y agoYou missed the important bit. From the abstract: > The data suggest that the blue component of the white-LED may cause retinal toxicity at occupational domestic illuminance and not only in extreme experimental conditions, as previously reported. The domestic illuminance they used was only 500 lux, which they describe as the "domestic classic light intensity".
- upofadown 10y agoThey got damage at 6000 lux with pretty much all the light sources. The interesting result is that they got significantly more damage with the white LED source than with other sources at 500 lux. Someone else was nice enough to post a link to the paper: * http://www.sciencedirect.com.sci-hub.ac/science/article/pii/S0306452216305243 http://www.sciencedirect.com.sci-hub.ac/science/article/pii/...
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y agoImportant to note that this was done with dilated pupils, so the difference is seen in a condition not normally encountered. Overall, I think the focus should be on light spectrum, not LEDs per se. Warmer LEDs has far less direct emission, with most of the light being re-emitted from the phosphor.
- hackuser 10y ago> It does not mean you need to run home and rip all the lights out, though. From the article: we investigate, in albinos and pigmented rats, the effects of different exposure protocols It's much too soon to rip out the lights in any event.
- thro1237 10y agoI prefer daylight bulbs (>4000K). Am I at higher risk?
- simonster 10y agoAnother relevant caveat (from http://www.nature.com/eye/journal/v25/n1/full/eye2010149a.html http://www.nature.com/eye/journal/v25/n1/full/eye2010149a.ht...) is that "Mice and rats have been shown to have lower thresholds for photic injury than do primates."
- null000 10y agoYeah, I looked and this and thought "well of course they can't handle as much light as humans, they're supposed to spend most of their time inside walls et al". Not terribly scientific, but pretty relevant when transferring this knowledge to humans.
- null000 10y agoYeah, I looked and this and thought "well of course they can't handle as much light as humans, they're supposed to spend most of their time inside walls et al". Not terribly scientific, but pretty relevant when transferring this knowledge to humans.
- Zak 10y agoNot to take away from your fundamental point, but to add information to anyone shopping for lighting: 4000K isn't "blue white" or even what's usually called "cool white". It's warmer (that is, more weighted toward the yellow-red end of the spectrum) than sunlight at midday (5000K-ish) and much warmer than LED and fluorescent sources that are noticeably blue (6000K+). Beyond that, sources with a flatter or fuller spectrum (most commonly measured as color rendering index, or CRI) will have less of a blue peak even at cooler color temperatures. And yes, 6000 lux is a lot of light. Staring at a 100W incandescent light bulb from 1 meter away will put about 100 lux on your eyes, by way of comparison.
- hvidgaard 10y ago> And yes, 6000 lux is a lot of light. Staring at a 100W incandescent light bulb from 1 meter away will put about 100 lux on your eyes, by way of comparison. That puts 6000 lux firmly in the "my eyes hurt, this cannot be good" category.
- Zak 10y agoTake a high-powered flashlight - the kind the police use. Hold it at arm's length. Point it straight in to your eyes. That's about 6000 lux. They had also dilated the rats' pupils with atropine, making the acute exposure test equivalent to, or perhaps worse than staring at the midday sun for 24 hours straight. Even the lower-level chronic exposure test used 500 lux with light from all directions so there's no way to look away. We don't use light that way in reality, and while I'm sure the intent was to accelerate the test, I can't help but suspect it's the equivalent of testing whether bathing in warm water might be harmful by boiling rats alive.
- drjasonharrison 10y ago6000 lux of BLUE light is a _ton_ of photons. The light meter they used applies the human sensitivity curves to the photo frequencies. The sensitivity of the human retina to blue light is very very poor. Most of the time you see graphs of sensitivity vs wavelength the curves have been normalized. Here is one graph where the blue channel has only been inflated by 10x: http://www-i6.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/web/Misc/Coding/365/li/material/notes/Chap3/Chap3.3/Topic3.fig_18.gif http://www-i6.informatik.rwth-aachen.de/web/Misc/Coding/365/... So 6000 lux of blue is approximately 30x as many green photons. For blue LED plus yellow phosphor that 30x "yellow" will be the signal that you will use to decide "that's enough light to perform work." The rat's eyes were definitely cooked by all of the blue. Imagine if they had used near UV or near infrared LEDs and the same meter to calibrate the intensity. Cooked rats.
- marze 10y agoCertainly something to investigate further, perhaps before putting LED bulbs into all light fixtures in the world.