3 ms·
Is buying real estate or a business an investment? You're not creating economic value, just putting money into the pocket of the previous owner.
by kgwgk 10y ago
Is buying real estate or a business an investment? You're not creating economic value, just putting money into the pocket of the previous owner.
- ryandrake 10y agoI guess it depends on your definition of "creating economic value". If I buy something for $110 from someone who paid $100 for it, I guess you could argue that either you or I just "created" $10 of economic value. I don't subscribe to that. Value is only created when you improve something. Buy a lump of gold for $100 and turn it into a $110 bracelet -> value created. Buy a lump of gold for $100 and sell it to someone 1 second later for $110 -> no value created.
- kgwgk 10y agoI didn't mention gold. I asked about two cash-flow generating assets that would be considered investments by most people (but of course you can have your own definition of investment).
- ryandrake 10y agoI'm more debating the definition of "value creation" rather than "investment". But admittedly I did conflate the two terms in an earlier response. I'd offer: not all investments, even the ones that provide monetary returns, do so by creating value.
- kgwgk 10y agoHow do a business provide monetary return if not by creating value? A house also provides value (in the form of housing), why would anyone want to pay rents otherwise?