5 ms·
> The most docile 60 year olds I know become positively vitriolic at the idea of even the age of benefit payout being changed by 5 years. I guess I'm afraid of
by monocasa 10y ago
> The most docile 60 year olds I know become positively vitriolic at the idea of even the age of benefit payout being changed by 5 years.
I guess I'm afraid of a slow rollout. ie. everyone who's 40 and older gets normal social security, if you're ~35 now, you'll have to wait a few years more. It's exactly the kind of "we got ours" BS that the boomers are so known for.
- RestlessMind 10y agoHonestly, I don't think its such a bad idea. Life expectancy in 1935 was 62. Today its 79. So if we want the program to be solvent, we have to adopt one or more of the following solutions: keep increasing the SS-eligibility age in tandem with life expectancy, increase the FICA tax, cut benefits
- monocasa 10y agoI mean, the FICA taxes were increased in 1983 in part as preparation for the Boomer's retirement. When that bubble is past us, we shouldn't need to increase again for a couple generations, even accounting for increased average lifespan.
- jellicle 10y agoYou could also choose what the U.S. is choosing now, which is to reduce U.S. life expectancy.
- hx87 10y agoGrandfathering would be unjust though.
- crdoconnor 10y agoDependency ratios (the number of workers compared to the number of people dependent on workers) may actually be lower than they were in the 60s simply because fewer people are having children. Even if that weren't true, the idea that we have to keep putting the age up is predicated upon productivity remaining static. Productivity has gone up consistently and will likely continue to go up. Curiously some people are breathlessly optimistic about automation when it's a convenient scapegoat for high unemployment but immediately lose all faith in it when it comes to social security projections. These people probably don't have our best interests at heart.
- anigbrowl 10y agoYou left out adding more people into the system, although that's usually considered in the context of demography rather than mortality. One accounting reason to consider it from this perspective, though, is that adult immigrants have typically been raised and educated at some other country's expense so their productive entry to the US workforce is free of any debt overhang, ie no public monies were spent by the US on educating so they're basically coming to help out with the national debt for free. Of course the flip side of this is a brain drain for countries that see too many people leave.
- cmurf 10y agoThis is already the case, since 1983. Also note that there's a huge difference in the payout depending on whether you go for early or full benefit age. https://www.nasi.org/learn/socialsecurity/retirement-age https://www.nasi.org/learn/socialsecurity/retirement-age
- brandonmenc 10y ago> It's exactly the kind of "we got ours" BS that the boomers are so known for. The boomers are just recipients of an anomalous post-war economic order that heavily benefitted the US for a couple decades. The average 60-year old had no role in pulling the rug out from millennials.
- logfromblammo 10y agoRight. The average Boomer had nothing to do with it. To be fair, the Boomer politicians and business managers didn't screw the Millennials, either. Not directly. They pulled the rug out from the Gen-Xers, and let the domino effect take out the Millennials, too. Yeah, as a generation, we still exist, even though nobody talks about us. The Boomers were the beneficiaries of post-war prosperity, but they also decided to steal money from the future to finance their generational party/gravy train. The Greatests gave them a gift of some free money, but then they also decided to smash open their own childrens' and grandchildrens' piggy banks and fill them full of promissory notes. Except they aren't IOUs that are promises from the parents to pay their kids back. They are UOMEs that obligate the kids to pay their parents more money, if they ever actually get some. I'm biased by anecdote, because I'm old enough to have seen typical (late) Boomer lifestyles and compare them to typical Gen X lifestyles in the same age range. In other words, I'm old enough now to compare my own life with that of my parents when they were the age I am now.
- brandonmenc 10y ago> The Boomers were the beneficiaries of post-war prosperity, but they also decided to steal money from the future to finance their generational party/gravy train. I hear this a lot, but what exactly do you mean? The real reason we don't have the same great lifestyles our (let's be honest - mostly white, male) parents and grandparents did is because no one can get a good paying factory job right out of high school anymore - an inevitable, global, structural change that no one could've prevented.
- hx87 10y agoIt's also because they consistently cut taxes and public investment in infrastructure while passing legislation to inflate the costs of basic life necessities such as housing.