4 ms·
It is not your money, it is a tax on income like any other. The Supreme Court established in 1960 (Flemming v Nestor) that contributions to Social Security are
by jandrewrogers 10y ago
It is not your money, it is a tax on income like any other. The Supreme Court established in 1960 (Flemming v Nestor) that contributions to Social Security are not your property and the government has no obligation to ever pay you benefits regardless of contribution. People have had this entitlement revoked in practice, though the targeting tends to be selective for out-groups and not a substantial fraction of the population.
The government strongly encourages belief in the myth that Social Security is something other than a welfare tax with no implied obligation to the taxpayer because that notion makes the tax much more palatable than the reality.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoYes. I wish more people understood this. The other one nobody seems to want to talk about or understand is Medicaid. People think they are getting health insurance (or whatever they want to call it) when, in reality, they are accumulating debt with the government and a debt most states are required, by law, to collect. This is one of the huge problems (outside of costs and lies) I have with Obamacare. The claim is that millions of people now have insurance when, in reality, millions of people were shoved into Medicaid and are accumulating a non-trivial financial obligation with the government. To say this is dishonest is probably cutting it short. https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/eligibility/estate-recovery/index.html https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/eligibility/estate-recover...
- mywittyname 10y agoI'm not sure why you're saying that using Medicaid is equivalent to accumulating debt with the Federal government. Medicaid is health insurance. It's true that Medicaid will seek reimbursement for procedures that should not have been covered, but that's not different much different than what happens when a private insurance company refuses to pay a benefit. The hospital is free to pursue the person directly for the balance they owe.
- greedo 10y agoIf you use Medicaid, you're expected to first deplete almost all of your financial resources to pay. It's not unusual to even have your home become an asset that will be eventually taken by the government.
- mywittyname 10y agoI'm actually quite aware of this (my partner used to do nursing home placements). But if you're going into a nursing home, the implication is that you will never need those assets again. While I don't agree with this process, it's difficult to argue it is without merit. I suppose if survivors wanted to inherit those assets, they could take on the care of their elderly family members. It's also worth noting that, in most of the US, the alternative to medicaid was/is filial support laws, in which the nursing home could take the assets of the children of the patients in their care.
- rebootthesystem 10y agoThe point is that people on Medicaid don't really have health insurance. They have a line of credit with the government. They are accumulating debt. In most -not all- states the law requires the state to collect on the debt. Again, by law. They can and do place liens on your property, etc. This is very, very far removed from the idea of health insurance. Your property becomes the property of the government. With real health insurance nobody places a lien on your home for medical services rendered.
- zaroth 10y agoAfter ACA this is no longer true in Medicaid expansion states. There is no asset test, and there is no paying back benefits if you are under 65 when you took them. Medicaid expansion is quite literally the best insurance that money can't buy. In CA, for example, a family of 4 earning less than $33,500 gets MediCal [1]. If you just want free coverage for the kids, you can earn $64,600. [2] [1] - http://www.dhcs.ca.gov/services/medi-cal/Pages/DoYouQualifyForMedi-Cal.aspx http://www.dhcs.ca.gov/services/medi-cal/Pages/DoYouQualifyF... [2] - http://hbex.coveredca.com/toolkit/renewal-toolkit/downloads/2016-Income-Guidelines.pdf http://hbex.coveredca.com/toolkit/renewal-toolkit/downloads/...
- cmurf 10y agoJust try considering all the old people communists, not deporting them, but also not paying them their benefits (however real or imaginary) and see where this goes. It would be uproar, and thus irrational. The case held that withholding benefits from Nestor wasn't irrational. Broadly doing to a whole population what was done to Nestor would hardly be rational, and certainly would not be smooth sailing.
- tn13 10y agoALL tax money is your money. We cant avoid taxes but that does not change the fact government's right to take our money away from us to do something as personal as retirement planning does not make sense and is morally extremely wrong. If I wanted government to plan my life I would have lived in Cuba not in USA.
- mindcrime 10y agoTaxation is theft.
- hsitz 10y agoI don't think most people understand how social security works. You can read about it here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_(United_States... SS is not quite a pension fund, but it is also certainly _not_ a "tax on income like any other". The funds taken all go to directly to the SSA fund, they aren't available for general use like basic income tax is. For another difference, it is payroll tax, so if you don't have income from wages (e.g., all income is through interest and dividends) there is no SS tax at all. Importantly, although it's possible that the fund could become exhausted if payments aren't reduced (as baby boomers age and the elderly grow to far outnumber the young), the size of payments would be reduced far before that point. Also, since there will always be at least some young people paying into SS, even if the fund itself was basically exhausted there would still be a continuous stream of incoming payments to distribute out to the elderly, just much reduced from the current size of outgoing payments.