7 ms·
I think 4K has ended up being a bit of a whiff in most respects. I just bought a 60" TV for my living room, where we are about 7 feet from it, which is pretty c
by jerf 10y ago
I think 4K has ended up being a bit of a whiff in most respects. I just bought a 60" TV for my living room, where we are about 7 feet from it, which is pretty close (it's the narrow dimension in my rectangular living room), and I can't tell much difference between putatively 4K content and clearly-1080P (from Bluray). It's hard to be sure, because all my putatively-4K content is streaming-based, and there aren't that many sources willing or able to ship enough bits to clearly distinguish between 1080p and 4K.
That is, in a 1080p v. 4K streaming contest, if you dedicate the same larger number of bits to the 1080p content as the 4K content, you'd get a better 1080p signal, too. With lossy compression, pixels aren't directly comparable, they have a quality, and low-quality 1080p pixels v. low-quality 4K pixels makes it hard to tell what differences are the format, and which are just the low quality in general.
(In other news, I consider the idea that streaming is obviously superior to disks to be a bit crazy. What disks have is higher quality pixels, and I expect that to continue to be true for a while. I've seen Bluray 1080p streams that are clearly superior to putatively 4K over-the-internet streams. And I've got DVDs that upscale to a higher quality than putatively 1080p streams of the same content.)
Far more important is the increased color gamut and HDR support, which does provide a noticeable increase in image quality. Even from those aforementioned dubious-quality streaming sources; the higher-gamut HDR images are a visible improvement over the NTSC-sunglasses we were all wearing without realizing it.
- richardboegli 10y agoTry a video game, you will notice the difference instantly.
- cdash 10y agoSure, but that has not much to do with the display resolution but more to do with the rendering resolution. It is the case that usually these are the same but it is not a requirement.
- RubyPinch 10y agomirroring what the other person said, its more useful for anything which isn't video A good example to consider is mobile phones and how sharp and precise the UI can be, with lines almost at hair thickness. Anti-aliasing is almost useless on phones already, and its all due to their pixel densities. (of course, not so useful for 60" screens!)
- minimaxir 10y agoI recently obtained a PS4 Pro which outputs up to 4K on supported games (of which there are very few currently). Even on the games that support >1080p but less than 4K, I notice an incredible difference in quality despite the 50" TV screen being 5 feet away. (Final Fantasy XV is very pretty on a Pro)
- Pxtl 10y agoI do wonder if that could be mimicked by rendering at 4K and antialiasing down to 1080. After all, if we don't notice in live video which is naturally antialiased, it would follow that we wouldn't notice in antialiased games.
- nightski 10y agoPS4 Pro already does this for some games like the last guardian.
- minimaxir 10y agoOn a 1080p TV, the PS4 Pro will downsample supported games, reducing jagginess.
- simcop2387 10y agoI believe that's usually called MSAA, Multi-Sampled AntiAliasing. It generally does work very well for making a pretty image but it's also a lot of samples that'll be redundant. That's why there's some things like CSAA, FXAA that try to only do it on places where there's higher contrast or on edges where it'll be most notable.
- greyskull 10y agoSuperSampling or downsampling (there might be some nuanced differences between the two). AFAIK, MSAA works at the render resolution and you can have it in addition to downsampling, although at a very poor ratio of computation to reward.
- dghughes 10y agoI used to say I couldn't tell 4K from 1080p but after a year I can tell the difference. I went from a 2001 Toshiba 720p flat CRT to 2016 55 inch 4K SUHD HDR. I guess my brain had to get over the shock.
- treve 10y agoI don't think it ever made sense to say it's generally hard to tell 4K from 1080p. It just really depends on the viewing distance and size of the screen. My tiny laptop screen is almost 4K, and the difference is massive from a 1080p screen because I'm so close. Likewise, your 55" inch screen wouldn't need to be 4K if you sit 10 meters away from it.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoNot only that, but the quality of the video feed. For example, highly compressed 4K is indistinguishable from much less compressed 1080p.
- jerf 10y agoWell, as I think I may have said poorly, I don't really know if I can tell 4K from 1080p reliably, because a 4K stream that contains such high quality pixels in it that it qualitatively different than an upscaled 1080p stream is very hard to come by right now. According to the charts, I'm right on the outer edge of where it may make a difference, so it's at least physically possible I could tell, if I got a truly 4K stream.
- deckar01 10y agoThe upscaling process on some televisions is astounding. Upscaling a 1080p@24 source to 4K@120 display brings out so much detail and gives the content an entirely different feel.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoHow can it bring out more detail, surely it can only smooth a graduation from one colour to another?
- fsloth 10y ago"I can't tell much difference between putatively 4K content and clearly-1080P" I presume the TV does upscaling? Not an expert, but theoretically a kick-ass algorithm should be able to gleam more resolution out of a temporally changing signal than the native resolution - thus actually providing more than 1080 pixels worth of resolution out of the 1080p stream. When I bought a HD TV either the Blu-Ray player or my TV (can't recall anymore) upscaled my old DVD:s with surpising quality - I can only presume the same applies for the current generation (haven't had the chance to do detailed analysis). Experts please revise.
- jamiek88 10y agoHow can an algorithm create more resolution (i.e. information) from less information? Do you mean a wavering 4k sream outputted as 1080p?
- LeoPanthera 10y agoIt's using information from adjacent frames to add extra detail.
- Pharaoh2 10y agohttps://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=neural+network+video+upscaling https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=neural+network+video+up...
- nitrogen 10y agoThe general term is "video super-resolution". There's software available off the shelf to do it, IIRC.
- kimburgess 10y agoVideo Upscaling via Spatio-Temporal Self-Similarity: http://vision.ucla.edu/papers/ayvaciJLCS12.pdf http://vision.ucla.edu/papers/ayvaciJLCS12.pdf The Freedman and Fattal paper they mention can be found here: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/7df0/39049948d54fd1f4d75526743f315cf4865f.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/7df0/39049948d54fd1f4d75526...
- 10y ago
- at-fates-hands 10y ago>> I think 4K has ended up being a bit of a whiff in most respects. And some unintended consequences as well. Buddy on my hockey team got a notice from Comcast that since he continually went over his 100GB data limit every month, they were raising his rates. Incredulous, I asked him, "What on earth on you doing where you're blowing through 100GB of bandwidth every month?!" His response? "I have to stream all my Netflix movies in 4K."
- nitrogen 10y ago100GB?? That's barely enough to buy a couple of video games. Where do they have that limit?
- spiderfarmer 10y ago15 years ago in The Netherlands.
- petemill 10y agoYour 60" TV is not big enough for 4k at 7' away. You need > 75" of screen[0] [0] http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/by-size/size-to-distance-relationship http://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/by-size/size-to-distance-re...
- pslam 10y agoVideo output and its perception, is not at all like audio output and its perception. We can make blunt statements about the limits of audio, because output devices behave (largely) linearly and band-limited, and because human perception can be modeled accurately and is also band-limited. You can't say the same about video. The output is an array of points, not even perfectly square or smooth, it is picked up by another array of receptors, and is non-linear. The limit being 1/60th degree is too blunt a rule of thumb. That's picking an arbitrary point on a curve showing how much better than guesswork a viewer is. The screen isn't a perfect output source, and the viewer isn't a perfect receiver, and the combined effect is you can easily observe the difference of 2K vs 4K images at distances those graphs say you wouldn't. I can easily observe the difference where it says I shouldn't be able to, and I'm nowhere near perfect vision. I would say pretty much everything in those graphs is off by a factor of 2.
- newman314 10y agoMy TV is quite a bit further away so that's why I'm still quite happy with 1080p and lower content. The only reason for me to go to a newer TV at this point is for HDR.
- dawnerd 10y agoThose size charts carry a lot of assumptions. I have a 65" and can tell the difference just fine at 8 feet away. The real benefit from 4k is actually HDR and the MUCH higher bitrate for video. The majority of streaming 4k is really low quality when compared to a normal bluray. Just because the resolution is big doesn't mean the picture quality is any better. Also a lot of 4k content is actually upscaled from 2k sources. http://realorfake4k.com/ http://realorfake4k.com/
- petemill 10y ago
- wazoox 10y agoAmen. Like about 50% of the population, I wear glasses. I absolutely can't make any noticeable difference between 2K and 4K at normal viewing distance. Most cinemas nowadays are 2K only, and nobody cares. Because most people older than 40 simply can't see. Heck, for 10 years I've seen people watching 4:3 TV on 16:9 screens, horribly stretched. People are almost blind, seriously. They'd tolerate about anything. HFR and HDR on the other hand, are great. I've seen HDR/HFR demos in 2K at Amsterdam IBC and it looks much better (much more realistic) than standard 4K. 8K? The NHK makes 8K demos, and they can only show almost still images, else you only have extremely detailed motion blur at ordinary framerates. They even give you a magnifying glass to look at their 8K screen. That's impressive, but I don't plan watching movies through big lenses to catch the details, anyway. What's the point, apart from planned obsolescence?
- StavrosK 10y agoOh man, the 4:3 stretching. Whenever I reach for the remote to correct it, people go "stop messing with the TV! It's fine!" and then go "it's stretched now, it was fine before!" when I fix the aspect ratio.
- 9point6 10y agoThat and "smooth motion" frame interpolation. I don't know how people can stand it.
- yladiz 10y agoOh, when I was visiting my father for Christmas, he had a new TV with Live Football Mode, which is just a fancy name for upping the contrast, saturation, and making it look 'smoother' doing what you mentioned. During sports it's actually fine, but he turned it on during a different tv show or movie and it looked horrible, like it was turning the tv show into a soap opera. It has its place, but in general I trust the designers of these shows, networks, manufacturers, and everyone in between to know what they're doing more than me and besides changing a dull looking picture due to something like a different colored light (contrast, warmth/coolness, saturation settings) I wouldn't mess with other settings.
- Taek 10y agoIf you want a good test try doing text editing on 1080p vs. 4k at whatever distance on whatever TV. For me, text is always easily visibly nicer on the 4K. Your PC is not doing any video compression, so you can be sure that everything is pixel perfect in both resolutions, and truly a fair comparison.
- shostack 10y agoI recently bought a gaming laptop and decided to go with a 1080 screen because it had gsync for smoother graphics versus a 3k screen. My main monitor and work machine are retina displays. Definitely had a bit of shock reading text on the 1080 screen. My eyes had forgotten how painful it was by comparison.
- rconti 10y agoI've got a top-end Sony 4k TV (x940d with full-array local dimming) and some of the first content I watched on it was the Rio Olympics in over-the-air 1080i. The quality was simply stunning. As you can imagine, the Olympics broadcasts would have used some of the best cameras available. Upscaled 1080 content is absolutely superb, and I often have a difficult time determining 4k from 1080p at ANY distance. That said, I'm not sad I went 4k because the set really IS that much better than a 1080 set, especially a low-end one. Sony upscaling and motion processing really is where it's at.
- seanp2k2 10y agoYeah, that's the thing too...high-end sets are still better than cheap sets. TL;DR you get what you pay for. If you get a 50" 4K TV for $500, I wouldn't expect it to be very good. Vizio's 2016 P series is decent, but they more or less lie about the ability to render proper 4:4:4 chroma at 4K resolution. Not great for a $1200 TV (which I use as a monitor, upon which a single-pixel-wide red line is very blurry). The equivalent Samsung which can do real 4:4:4 at 4k@60hz is close to $2k, ditto the Sony, and the Sony has input lag issues while the Vizio will do 120hz@1080p with ~10ms input delay, which is great for gaming. The Samsung is OK for input lag (~30ms IIRC) but more expensive and I just don't like giving Samsung money.
- Auzy 10y agoThe funny thing about 4K is that I do home AV installs, and its almost impossible not to have compatibility issues still. To this day, I don't think we've had a single installation with 4K projector / Receiver / player working together of different brands without some kind of serious issue. ARC is another disaster that we STILL are having trouble with, and thats been out for years. I really hope that more has been done in the way of standardisation to help iron out these issues
- Avernar 10y agoI had to use an optical cable between my TV and AVR to get audio. The only thin ARC did was allow me to control the AVR volume control using thr TV's remote. Not very useful when no audio is coming back.