5 ms·
> I profoundly believe that believing in God is by definition non-analytical. Why by definition? There are many people who purport to believe in God because t
by lisper 10y ago
> I profoundly believe that believing in God is by definition non-analytical.
Why by definition? There are many people who purport to believe in God because they claim there is evidence that God exists. That claim may be false, but it doesn't seem to me to be logically incoherent.
> For example, I think most people can agree that it's trivially morally bad to cause pain for no good reason.
Sure, but that just begs the question: what is a "good reason"? The Inquisitors thought that they were saving people from eternal hellfire by torturing them. Does that constitute a "good reason"?
- Koshkin 10y ago>> I profoundly believe that believing in God is by definition non-analytical. > Why by definition? Well, the parent said "I profoundly believe...". That is the proof.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dvt 10y ago> There are many people who purport to believe in God because they claim there is evidence that God exists. I think faith is the antithesis of proof. I believe God asks us for faith. As opposed to my logic courses, which asked me for proofs :) > Sure, but that just begs the question: what is a "good reason"? The Inquisitors thought that they were saving people from eternal hellfire by torturing them. Does that constitute a "good reason"? I'm using a very typical run-of-the-mill "good reason". E.g. it's a "good reason" to hurt someone if they need to get an arm amputated to prevent a cancer from spreading but it's not a "good reason" to crush a baby kitten's skull just because you feel like it.
- lisper 10y ago> I believe God asks us for faith. OK, fair enough, but then how do you know it's Jesus and not Allah (or some other deity) asking for your faith? (That's a serious question, BTW. I'd really like to know your answer.) > it's not a "good reason" to crush a baby kitten's skull just because you feel like it. Yes, well, there's a reason I didn't choose that as my example. Is scientific research a "good reason"? It is moral to vivisect a kitten for research? What about a mouse?
- dvt 10y ago> OK, fair enough, but then how do you know it's Jesus and not Allah (or some other deity) asking for your faith? (That's a serious question, BTW. I'd really like to know your answer.) This is a great question and I'll answer like I answered another HN user: this is a very nuanced question that can't really be answered on a forum (and I'm not even sure if I'm equipped to answer it). With that said, William Lane Craig (a famous Christian apologist) has tons of debates (vs. Muslims, atheists, Hindus, etc.) on Youtube and I kind of like his arguments. Most of these are pretty long (1hr+) so they require a bit of investment, but his debates are always fun and interesting to watch. Alvin Plantinga (famous philosopher, Notre Dame professor, Christian apologist) also has a few noteworthy speeches and debates. > Is scientific research a "good reason"? It is moral to vivisect a kitten for research? What about a mouse? There's a lot of grey area here. I used very clear and intuitive examples on purpose. Is it morally right to euthanize? Is abortion moral? Etc, etc. I'm honestly not sure (but I love a good debate!). Maybe some of these are in the same computational class as the halting problem: undecidable (for us) :) But the fact that the line is fuzzy doesn't mean there's no line at all.
- lisper 10y ago> the fact that the line is fuzzy doesn't mean there's no line at all Certainly true, but the fact that the line is fuzzy seems to me an indication that it wasn't drawn by God. Fuzziness is more characteristic of nature. > I love a good debate! Then you should read this: http://blog.rongarret.info/2008/05/can-morality-exist-without-god.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2008/05/can-morality-exist-withou...
- dvt 10y ago> Certainly true, but the fact that the line is fuzzy seems to me an indication that it wasn't drawn by God. Fuzziness is more characteristic of nature. That seems like quite a leap to me, but even if we agree that there's an objective good and an objective bad, then there must be some standard for the good. I think that standard is God. This isn't meant to be a proof (and it's very hand-wavy), but that's my intuition. > Then you should read this... Seems to be in the same vein and Dawkins, et al.: that we somehow evolved this moral intuition. I think that's a faulty position because of a simple thought experiment. Consider a universe where nothing evolved. For whatever reason, there was no Big Bang, and things just popped into existence. Would there be no morality in such a universe (because we didn't evolve it)? I find that very hard to believe.
- westoncb 10y agoWhile still not religious personally, I think I can see now why it makes sense to side with certain things that fundamentally can't have rational justifications. Concepts can be broken down into a finite set of parts (e.g. relations and types) which form an infinite set--but still don't cover everything (I'm assuming you're already aware of the different classes of infinite sets, some of which are larger than others). Given that, human conceptualizing must be admitted to be limited in the same way that, e.g., human smell is. In that case, it only makes sense to retain an openness, or at least uncertainty, regarding subjects which may fall outside the ken of the human conceptualizing faculty.