4 ms·
>“Basically,” he said, “if you’re a jerk in real life, you’re going to be a jerk in any kind of social setting, and if you’re not, you’re not.” That somehow un
by shmerl 10y ago
>“Basically,” he said, “if you’re a jerk in real life, you’re going to be a jerk in any kind of social setting, and if you’re not, you’re not.”
That somehow undermines the point of roleplaying. Would he also suggest, that actors who play questionable or evil characters are supposed to be evil in real life? That's like some extreme form of Stanislavski's system in reverse.
> They found that video games that allowed players to play out their “ideal selves” (embodying roles that allow them to be, for example, braver, fairer, more generous, or more glorious) were not only the most intrinsically rewarding, but also had the greatest influence on our emotions.
And that's also considered the worst form of roleplaying. A classical Mary Sue is based on reflecting too much of your own image into the character while at the same time idealizing it.
So it's surely not the only reason to play games. Some actually like more elaborate roleplaying than creating Mary Sues.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI think role playing and acting are two different things. Acting is about your audience, role playing is about yourself. So while Mary Sue roles may not be the most enjoyable to watch (though I never had an issue with them myself), that doesn't necessarily apply to games in which you want to play as a better person than you can be in real life.
- shmerl 10y agoThere are differences, but there are similarities as well. In single player experience, yes. You roleplay for yourself. Still, it doesn't mean the motivation of that roleplaying is supposed to be self idealization. In multiplayer roleplaying game, you don't just roleplay for yourself. It's a shared experience of several players (and possibly someone like GM). So, from their perspective, your acting is close to the common role of an actor in other arts. Except it's interactive. And the quality of your acting affects that shared experience.
- piptastic 10y ago> “Basically,” he said, “if you’re a jerk in real life, you’re going to be a jerk in any kind of social setting, and if you’re not, you’re not.” I have anecdotal evidence that this isn't the case. I can be an extreme jerk in games: textually abusive, team-killing just for fun, etc. But I can also be super nice: lead clans, go out of my way to be helpful to everyone, etc. Not sure what triggers my behavior one way or the other. Perhaps it has to do with consistent worlds (MMO) vs team deathmatch (FPS). Once it's manifested itself for a particular game, it stays that way. In real life I'm a pretty nice guy. But I still go home at night and kill people while simultaneously insulting them.
- wccrawford 10y agoSo you somehow think that it's okay to be abusive online, but that you're perfectly squeaky clean face-to-face? I have my doubts. I'm sure you come off as a lot nicer, but I suspect you're doing subtle things constantly that you might not even be aware of, or that you write off as normal and therefore perfectly fine. My ethics and morals don't stop at my router. I don't attack people online any more than I attack them in person. People's feeling matter, no matter the medium.
- shmerl 10y agoI think this also shouldn't conflate IC and OOC behavior. Some are just jerks in OOC fashion, and that's not OK. If IC behavior dictates certain actions story wise, it can be different. Mixing up IC and OOC behaviors is the first major mistake that should be corrected by any roleplayer.
- emerongi 10y agoTeamkilling in an FPS is not roleplaying. It's called being a dickhead. The user above enjoys ruining other people's fun.
- shmerl 10y agoOriginal discussion was about roleplaying though. Non roleplaying games is a different category.
- Terr_ 10y agoI think the key is that any game with "in character" modes almost always has explicit game mechanics about how to be a jerk and what kinds of repercussions may occur. Edit: To be more explicit, when those mechanics don't exist anybody saying "I'm just role-playing a jerk" is full of crap.
- shmerl 10y agoYes, usually there are various rules / guidelines about it. Unacceptable behavior is supposed to be handled by GMs, which is critical for good multiplayer RPGs. Without some moderation things can degrade pretty quickly. It's also one of the reasons why it's so challenging to make a good RPG of that sort - it's hard to scale. With bigger player base, you need more GMs, and most ignore it in attempt to commercialize the "massive" aspect of things. Quality plummets in result.