3 ms·
Capital is not abstract, capital is a production input (not sure the correct English name for this), the same as iron, concrete, flour, etc. You don't find any
by kfk 10y ago
Capital is not abstract, capital is a production input (not sure the correct English name for this), the same as iron, concrete, flour, etc. You don't find any problems in paying for flour, do you? Then why is it a problem to pay for capital?
Another thing. State "capital" has been done, it's called communism (or heavy socialism), it doesn't work. Why not? Because the people making decisions on State "capital" do not get any of the downsides. You burn 50% of State owned capital? Who cares, it's not yours anyway.
And final one - managing capital is work! Knowing where to put your cash is work and it has a huge impact. Think how much of an impact can have somebody investing billions in space exploration (Musk?), or aging, or cancer. There are plenty of big trends worth investing that will give humanity as whole immense benefits (just look at the past 100 years).
Capitalism is not perfect, post-scarcity is a real threat, but the author is making the wrong arguments. The real problem is what people will do once we reach post-scarcity? What religions will they believe? What philosophies? How will they spend their time? Can they bear a life with 0 problems (I am not so sure I could)?
- John23832 10y ago> And final one - managing capital is work! Knowing where to put your cash is work and it has a huge impact. Think how much of an impact can have somebody investing billions in space exploration (Musk?), or aging, or cancer. There are plenty of big trends worth investing that will give humanity as whole immense benefits (just look at the past 100 years). Musky investing a billion dollars into a company the produces things isn't the issue. Musk would be taking a risk to build something that can reasonably fail. The issue is that (with our largely service based economy) many large capital holders simply charge rent and rent seeker have negligible risk compared to the owners of physical capital.
- kfk 10y agoYou can't charge rent if you don't invest into something. If you know how to get rent with 0 investments and risks, please tell me, I'll pay you for some consulting.