3 ms·
>Uh... No? If I pay you, it's because you have something I need. So you value it more. It has more utility to you. You are better off with it than with the mon
by simonh 10y ago
>Uh... No? If I pay you, it's because you have something I need.
So you value it more. It has more utility to you. You are better off with it than with the money.
- Chris2048 10y agoUnless it is tied into some kind of mandatory tax, or government subsidy.
- bdhess 10y agoI find utility in staying out of jail, so I pay my mandatory taxes.
- Chris2048 10y agoExactly :-) If the government can "manufacture" utility like this, it isn't utility.
- simonh 10y agoTherefore government services have no value? Driven or been driven on any roads lately? Bought any goods transported on public infrastructure? Etc. I'm lost. I've no idea what you're really arguing at this point.
- Chris2048 10y agoI don't think I argued that. Perhaps that's why you're confused.
- bdhess 10y agoThat's not at all true. In a democracy, "the government" is a reflection of the will of society, however imperfectly expressed. Paying taxes is as social obligation with known consequences for failure to comply (in this case, the threat of confinement). As a parallel example, perhaps I have a housemate who gets upset when he finds dirty dishes in the sink. So I take care to clean dishes when I use them-- perhaps not because I particularly care if there are dirty dishes in the sink, but because it upsets my housemate. Again, to prevent myself from accruing the negative utility that comes from failing to meet a social obligation.
- gech 10y agoPayment level is coerced. I'd pay less for everything, I don't have the ability to negotiate price like bigger players do.
- pikzen 10y agoExcept I didn't start with money. I'm not working to get money, I'm working to be able to afford things. Money is just a convenient exchange tool. It doesn't have any utility to me aside from being pretty much the only way to trade. It has the exact same utility to me. Unless somebody is running an operation to get total control of what I'm looking to buy, I'm pretty guaranteed to be able to get it if I have the money. It is nothing more than an convenient way of exchange