3 ms·
The sum are greater than the parts. Problems with US elections, in rank order: * Gerrymandering (unfair redistricting) * First Past the Post * Restrictive v
by specialist 10y ago
The sum are greater than the parts.
Problems with US elections, in rank order:
* Gerrymandering (unfair redistricting)
* First Past the Post
* Restrictive voting rules
* Expensive campaigns
Very briefly...
REDMAP worked too well, gave us the Tea Party, enabled unprecedented obstructionism. Both the GOP and the Dems have an interest in undoing REDMAP. Maybe with Iowa style redistricting.
Problems with FPTP are widely documented. Fix is Approval Voting for executive races and senators, Proportional Voting for assemblies. One side effect will be reduced campaign expenses and mudslinging, because Approval Voting makes the candidates play nice (mostly).
Adopt universal voting, re-enfranchise felons. This will prevent caging, purging. Sadly, it does not increase voter turnout.
Campaigns costs are currently being driven by ballot chasing (enabled by switch to postal ballots) and advertising. Everyone knows its past the point of diminishing returns, but no one can "disarm" unilaterally. So the madness continues. Switching back to (mostly) poll site based voting and restoring the Fairness Doctrine would mostly fix this problem. Another solution is publicly financed campaigns, which would be more palatable once costs come back down.
I could go on and on. But that's the thumbnail of the most important.
Source: Election integrity activist (voting machines, HAVA) for years, ran for office.
PS- While popular vote for US President is inevitable, absolutely support it, it's not my personal highest priority.
- rhino369 10y agoHow many seats are actually gerrymandered? From the sources I can find, it's around a net 5 seat advantage for the republicans (out of 435). If that is the biggest issue in American politics, then the rest can't be that bad.
- specialist 10y ago"If [gerrymandering] is the biggest issue... then the rest can't be that bad." Gerrymandering segregates like with like, increasing partisanship. Favoring the most extreme candidate. Meaning seats are won during low turnout primaries vs general elections. Meaning voters have no meaningful choice. Gerrymandering is incumbency protection. If you support term limits, you'd logically also support more competitive redistricting. "From the sources I can find, it's around a net 5..." Look harder.
- eli_gottlieb 10y ago>Meaning seats are won during low turnout primaries vs general elections. Meaning voters have no meaningful choice. And at that point, we might as well institute California-style jungle primaries everywhere, which at least ensures that a real "general election" takes place (albeit at an awkward time) followed by a runoff for the "lesser evils".
- specialist 10y agoYa. My fantasy notion is that Approval Voting would moot the primaries. This would save (the tax payers) money. Having fewer elections would help reduce voter fatigue. It'd also moot the spoiler effect, so third parties can be granted access to the ballot, with little downside, leading to more voter choice. My only (hypothetical) concern with Approval Voting is having too many choices (per race), the paradox of choice leading to indecision. But that's just an intuition; I have no data.
- dangoor 10y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that state governments in the US also wield a lot of power and the gerrymandering at that level can be unbelievable (see "North Carolina is no longer a democracy" recent stories). The state governments control how voting works in the state, which can lead to distortions at the federal level.
- ClayShentrup 10y agoScore Voting and Approval Voting are good. There's no solid evidence that Proportional Representation is better than good single-winner methods for legislatures. http://ScoreVoting.net/PropRep.html http://ScoreVoting.net/PropRep.html