4 ms·
many times what person A considers to be harassment, the person that is harassing them does not consider it to be harassment at all. To expand on that: "I disa
by tremon 10y ago
many times what person A considers to be harassment, the person that is harassing them does not consider it to be harassment at all.
To expand on that: "I disagree" is not and should not be a valid defense when someone is accusing you of harassment. Harassment is a violation of personal space and only one person gets to define the limits of that personal space; it is not the aggressor that sets the limits.
In a way, it is the same discussion as with privacy: the only authority on what personal information to share with whom is the person themselves.
Yes, this premise is easily abused, and yes, in US' adversarial society a discussion on this topic carries a lot more weight (because legal) than it probably should, but the fundamental premise is still the same: personal stuff is personal.
As for the false dichotomy between free speech and censorship: that is the same as arguing that freedom can only exist in anarchy; they both rely on a very narrow definition of freedom: that each person exists foremost as a singular entity, and that every interpersonal exchange is governed by mutual negotiation. I think that's a very myopic view, because it implies that every relationship starts adversarial.
- syshum 10y ago>To expand on that: "I disagree" is not and should not be a valid defense when someone is accusing you of harassment. Harassment is a violation of personal space and only one person gets to define the limits of that personal space; it is not the aggressor that sets the limits. I disagree completely on this. Using this definition of harassment, in combination with a prohibition on said harassment is ripe for abuse. I have seen many many many people claim others are "harassing" them simply because the other person expressed a dissenting opinion from their own. Harassment must have an objective definition, not a subjective one. At-least if it is going to enforced as a part of over all rules for a platform like Twitter. Further under this definition of Harassment no one can be harassed online, since you can not violate a persons PERSONAL space if you have no physical proximity to the person >>they both rely on a very narrow definition of freedom: that each person exists foremost as a singular entity, and that every interpersonal exchange is governed by mutual negotiation. I think that's a very myopic view, because it implies that every relationship starts adversarial. What is your definition of freedom then. I do believe every person is a singular entity, with self agency, and that every interaction with other people is a mutual negotiation where by both parties should voluntary agree to interact and at any time for any reason either party can choose to end the interaction. With out the ability to chose whom you interact with, and for what reason you can not have freedom. That is far from myopic
- DanBC 10y ago> Further under this definition of Harassment no one can be harassed online, since you can not violate a persons PERSONAL space if you have no physical proximity to the person If I falsely and maliciously accuse you of being a paedophile that can cause you to undergo intrusive investigation, possibly leading to you losing work; it can cause people to physically assault you, perhaps even kill you. I have no physical proximity to you, but I have intruded on your personal space. But even if none of that happens: it will affect you. These types of actions cause actual, measurable, harm.
- marknutter 10y agoYou've just identified a form of harassment that is objective, and probably would be agreed upon by the wider community. That's ok because it doesn't rely on a single person's definition of harassment.
- DanBC 10y agoThere are plenty of people on HN who are horrified by the UK definition of harassment. See, for example, how people react when they read the sentencing remarks or Mr Justice Spencer in Regina vs Joshua Bonehill-Paine https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/judgments/sentencing-remarks-of-mr-justice-spencer-r-v-joshua-bonehill-paine-harassment-of-luciana-berger-mp/ https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/judgments/sentencing-remarks-of... There are people who'll try to deny that this was antisemitism; that it was actually harassment; that she wasn't harmed by it etc.
- Chris2048 10y ago> See, for example, how people react Where? How do they react?
- syshum 10y ago>>I have no physical proximity to you, but I have intruded on your personal space. I disagree, you have caused other people to violate my personal space, but you did not. >But even if none of that happens: it will affect you. These types of actions cause actual, measurable, harm. This is true, that does not make it a violation of "personal space" nor does it have to be a violation of person space to have liability for actions attached to it