3 ms·
Not sure what you're implying. The US and UK have low levels of corruption; France, Germany, Benelux have high levels of corruption? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Lets first have
by Fnoord 10y ago
Not sure what you're implying. The US and UK have low levels of corruption; France, Germany, Benelux have high levels of corruption? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Lets first have a look where Common Law exists [1]. OK, that's pretty easy: It is FVEY plus some islands.
Now lets have a look at the Corruption Perception Index [2] (alternatively, just check the picture at [3]). The UK and US are at place 12 and 17 respectively. The top 10 is comprised of: Denmark, Finland, Sweden, New Zealand, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, Singapore, Canada, Germany. I count 2 common law (New Zealand, Canada), and at least 7 Civil Law (I'm not including Singapore because I don't know what kind of law system they have; the list is including that pesky Germany who according to your source have high corruption). I fail to see your pattern.
[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/92/Map_of_the_Legal_systems_of_the_world_%28en%29.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/92/Map_of_t...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index
[3] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b4/Transparency_international_2015.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b4/Transpar...
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Not sure what you're implying London bankers' skills are unlikely to efficiently translate to Paris. Moreover, Paris can support less financial activity for having a bank-based economy--banks can't process at the throughputs markets can. > I fail to see your pattern The paper considers more than ten European countries. I included the postscript because I found it interesting, not because it's particularly germane to the article topic.
- vidarh 10y agoParis has plenty of trading desks. The physical location of the trading desks relative to the markets matters little.
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Paris has plenty of trading desks I'm not saying Paris isn't a financial centre. It's just in a different league compared to London, NYC, Singapore, Hong Kong or Tokyo. > The physical location of the trading desks relative to the markets matters little Making markets requires plugging into financial and political power structures. Due to home-country effects, buyers and sellers of a security tend to congregate around the issuer. A Singapore desk will hand off to New York to execute an order by a Singaporean buyer and American seller. Note: we're not talking about hedge funds. We're talking about investment bankers, sales-traders and market makers--relationship-driven businesses.
- vidarh 10y ago> I'm not saying Paris isn't a financial centre. It's just in a different league compared to London, NYC, Singapore, Hong Kong or Tokyo. That's true. But the point here is that a lot of London's banking depends on unfettered access to the EU markets, and so the question is not "which city", but "which city in the EU" will take over once the UK exits the EU. > Making markets requires plugging into financial and political power structures. Due to home-country effects, buyers and sellers of a security tend to congregate around the issuer. That matters for some roles, but certainly not all. But this same arguments also is part of the exact reason why the UK faces an onslaught post-Brexit.
- Fnoord 10y ago> I included the postscript because I found it interesting I replied because I saw your quote contained a possible inaccuracy. When I investigated that specific part, I found contradicting proof of a causal relationship between French Civil Law tradition and corruption. Which is what your quote was implying. I didn't attempt to verify anything else, but I'm highly skeptical. Either that, or I read wrong and what is being implied with: > Countries with a French Civil Law tradition, poor protection of shareholder and creditor rights, poor contract enforcement, high levels of corruption, poor accounting standards, restrictive banking regulations, and high inflation tend to have underdeveloped financial systems. (Emphasis mine.) is that these are all requirements due to and. Which further is suggested by the quote hereunder that countries with high income such as France, Germany, and Benelux (all of which are original members of the EEC/EC) are not meant to be included in the list you mentioned. > In higher income countries, stock markets become more active and efficient relative to banks. There is some tendency for national financial systems to become more market oriented, as they become richer. But hey, if you want to prove your point feel free to prove -with sources- France, Germany, and Benelux each have: * Poor protection of shareholder and creditor rights * Poor contract enforcement * Poor accounting standards * Restrictive banking regulations * High inflation
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> countries with high income such as France, Germany, and Benelux...are not meant to be included in the list you mentioned The paper divides economies into three buckets: market-based, bank-based and underdeveloped. It does this by looking at economic factors. It then looks at what other factors, Y, are similar between countries in each bucket. This doesn't work going backwards. By analogy, suppose I have circles, squares and triangles in blue, green and orange. It is meaningful to group by shape. It may also be meaningful to observe that 90% of the triangles are blue. It does not follow that a random blue shape is a triangle.
- Fnoord 10y ago> The paper divides economies into three buckets: market-based, bank-based and underdeveloped. It does this by looking at economic factors. It then looks at what other factors, Y, are similar between countries in each bucket. This doesn't work going backwards. I know it doesn't because the paper is linking certain properties it observes without proving the causation, and then tries mention them as if they're relevant while in reality there's no relevance shown. (For example, an alternative plausible explanation could be a relation between corruption and wealth.) > By analogy, suppose I have circles, squares and triangles in blue, green and orange. It is meaningful to group by shape. It may also be meaningful to observe that 90% of the triangles are blue. It does not follow that a random blue shape is a triangle. Imagine shapes and colours can change, and there's no proof the change is related to the shapes or colours. Imagine the conclusion for the 'blue' is 'beautiful'. Does it then matter to mention that the blue ones happen to be 'beautiful' and 'mostly triangles'? Is it a relevant conclusion that the 'non-beautiful' are 'mostly not triangles' or 'that they are not beautiful because they're mostly not triangles'? The latter is what your quote implied, and its merely suggestive. You have no proof. Because correlation is not causation. So why does the paper mention it? If you're not willing to prove the missing point, why do you quote it?