5 ms·
I'm not a fan of the expansion of the concept of "fake news" to include any story a subject thinks was not fair. There are stories that were completely made up
by snowwrestler 10y ago
I'm not a fan of the expansion of the concept of "fake news" to include any story a subject thinks was not fair.
There are stories that were completely made up by Estonian teenagers, with no connection to facts at all, which were widely republished and shared. That's the "fake news" problem.
The problem of journalists misrepresenting a company (either by mistake or on purpose) is as old as the hills. It was as true back when the media was widely trusted, as it is now.
- dlss 10y ago> The problem of journalists misrepresenting a company (either by mistake or on purpose) is as old as the hills. It was as true back when the media was widely trusted, as it is now. Perhaps what's happening is that established bad practices are becoming more noticeable as technology advances (in this case, the subjects of stories can post at little or no cost a widely read rebuttal) > There are stories that were completely made up by Estonian teenagers, with no connection to facts at all, which were widely republished and shared It sounds like we agree that factual inaccuracies, both on the detail and summary level are harmful. However, in my view, connection with the facts of the matter is only important in that it represents a commitment on the part of the journalist to educate the public on a specific topic. Education toward a more accurate position is the key here. For example, it was recently pointed out that flossing has no RCTs to support it. This is to not say that flossing has no supporting evidence. Flossing has a tremendous amount of longitudinal evidence to support it. There is also little to no evidence of any kind to discourage flossing. Despite this, the New York Times reported the story as "maybe there's no need [to floss]"[1]. That's a very misleading representation of expert opinion, presumably done to increase readership. I fail to see how the NYTimes' version of the story is somehow preferable to a hypothetical fact free version written (as in your example) by an Estonian teenager. At least the fact free version is easier to discard as rubbish. One can only wonder how many dental problems the NYTimes' spinned version of the story will cause. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/health/flossing-teeth-cavities.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/health/flossing-teeth-cavi...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 10y ago"Fake news" seems to have become a dead duck term almost immediately, because nobody can really agree what it means. As you say, there's explicitly fake news from organizations that never pretended to be news organizations and were simply web sites spun up to fool the unwary. But there's also a real problem with "real" news orgs publishing highly suspect claims in sensationalist ways. Then there's hyper-partisanship in the news, where allegations against one side are overhyped and allegations against the other downplayed or ignored.
- jyriand 10y agoCan you please link your source to "stories made up by Estonian teenagers". I'm estonian and never heard of any teenagers making fake news.
- fudgie 10y agoI'm guessing he was referring to the Macedonian teenagers from https://www.buzzfeed.com/craigsilverman/how-macedonia-became-a-global-hub-for-pro-trump-misinfo https://www.buzzfeed.com/craigsilverman/how-macedonia-became...
- jyriand 10y agoWouldn't be the first time Estonia is associated with Balkans, probably because it's actually in Baltics.
- thick18cm 10y agoWell, I too confuse the words Baltics and Balkans while trying to recall one or the other, but on the basis of their sound, nothing to do with geopolitics, so I can easily see confusing Macestonia and Esdonia in memory also based on sound, rather than category confusion. It's not like Estonian teens wouldn't be capable of setting up a money making scam site, or any other type of teens for that matter.
- snowwrestler 10y agoYes--thank you. I wrote from memory and screwed up the attribution, thereby fulfilling the stereotype of the typical American who can't tell European nations apart from one another. This tiny little episode shows how easy it can be for wrong info to spread. I should have looked up the Buzzfeed story to confirm the country, but I winged it, and got it wrong. So was my comment "fake news"? I don't think so, of course. I didn't set out to fool anybody, it was just a mistake. But it did push out a false fact to everyone who saw my comment.