4 ms·
I agree ignoring it isn't a responsible approach, but if the paper is flawed and the 'measurements' are below a meaningful level, what that means is we still do
by simonh 10y ago
I agree ignoring it isn't a responsible approach, but if the paper is flawed and the 'measurements' are below a meaningful level, what that means is we still don't yet even know if there is any effect at all.
- dpark 10y agoFor sure, we don't know if there is any effect. I'm guessing there isn't. There also weren't any faster-than-light neutrinos but investigating the anomalous measurements from OPERA until they were understood was the scientifically sound choice.
- euyyn 10y agoBecause those scientists: 1) Were looking for the error in their method, not trying to get press and/or budget using a claim of FTL particles. 2) Had already done their darnest to not be fooled by their experimental setup. And this was a huge lot of phycisists having looked. Neither 1 nor 2 hold here; and so these people are wasting other people's time.
- dpark 10y agoHaven't multiple independent scientists now replicated the results? It's no longer just the original proponents. It's multiple scientists trying to understand what is causing the measurement.