4 ms·
Something I'm confused about, and I do RF/microwave engineering work... There's a lot of debate about whether the "thrust" produced is real or is an artifact o
by walrus01 10y ago
Something I'm confused about, and I do RF/microwave engineering work... There's a lot of debate about whether the "thrust" produced is real or is an artifact of the test environment.
But they're only testing at relatively low power levels like 40W, 60W, 80W. There are lots of commercially available sources for Klystron and TWT type amplifiers rated up to 3000W (used for C, Ku and Ka-band satellite earth station Tx applications). If the question is whether it's real, would it not make sense to build a HUGE FUCKING HIGH POWERED test rig with >1500W input?
If we're measuring possible "thurst" in micronewtons, and the claim of the original research is that the thrust will scale somewhat proportionally with the power level applied, does it not make sense to develop an unambiguous result by building a very high powered test rig?
In a theoretical scenario where a high powered test rig produces real measurable thrust that is far too great to be a measurement error, it would be an amount in millinewtons that is far too great to be explained by a non-thrust variable such as thermal expansion/contraction in the power cables, etc.
If the claim is 260 micronewtons at 60W, use COTS klystron and/or TWTA technology to build a 3000W test rig. Question answered.
here are some examples of high powered units for satcom purposes: http://www.cpii.com/product.cfm/4/13 http://www.cpii.com/product.cfm/4/13
edit: The thing is described as a "resonant cavity" and operates at 1.9 GHz: http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120 http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120
Looks damn near identical to a weird feed horn to me. The test article looks like a cone or horn antenna with a feed horn stuck onto the back of it. High power capable waveguides and feed horns for big-ass satellite telecom things (like an 11 meter sized C-band Tx/Rx earth station) are a well known science. You can buy them from a myriad of COTS sources.
- ridgeguy 10y agoFrom following EmDrive work a little, my impression is that nobody has the budget to do a high power setup right. Budget was a major limitation in the published NASA work. Also, some artifact sources (e.g. power lead/B field artifacts) would scale up along with power.
- flukus 10y agoYet there are a couple of separate plans to send it into space for testing. I would of thought more terrestrial testing would be much cheaper than sending something to space.
- ridgeguy 10y agoI agree. I think it would be less expensive (but not cheap) to build definitive test equipment on Earth than in space. Space operations also might cause new types of artifacts. One such might be forces from induced currents due to spacecraft motion relative to the Earth's magnetic field. I think it's just expensive to do a really definitive physical demo in this domain, given that the effect (if there is one) is so small and sources of artifacts so numerous.
- yread 10y agoIf it works because of Earth's magnetic field it could still be useful to keep satellites in decaying orbits
- kobeya 10y agoActually cube sats can be pretty damn cheap. A cube sat test rig with off the shelf components could be cheaper than a custom ground experiment.
- walrus01 10y agoSufficient watt hours per day to prove this are not available from the PV cells you can mount on a cubesat.
- euyyn 10y agoPlus you have to pay for launch, even if you piggyback.
- andygates 10y agoThere aren't even published controls -- the test rig with a non-resonant horn, for example -- so we're way ahead of flight testing.
- madengr 10y agoSounds plausible, though could be tough to handle the mismatch at those power levels. Then again, don't the use cavity resonators driven at MW levels for particle beam accelerators? The paper says the thrust is somewhat non-linear with respect to drive. It does nothing, then comes on quickly.