3 ms·
Long lived unicorns are especially troublesome. Businesses are like camp fires, camp fires need heat, fuel, and oxygen to burn, if you run out of any one of th
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Long lived unicorns are especially troublesome.
Businesses are like camp fires, camp fires need heat, fuel, and oxygen to burn, if you run out of any one of those three things they go out. By the act of burning, the camp fire can warm the air above it, forcing it to rise which pulls in new oxygen from the surrounding air. They can increase in size which allows them to reach fuel "on their own", and the heat they generate can dry otherwise wet an unsuitable wood and turn it into fuel.
Startups burn cash which as their "fuel", their "heat" is goods and services with which they can change the way a market operates which pulls in more customers giving them more "oxygen" to work with.
As a result, startups and camp fires, share an interesting similarity. The longer you have to work to keep them going the less likely it is that then can survive on their own.
From what is available to the public, it seems that any one of Uber/Airbnb/Dropbox/Pinterest/Palantir would be sold for scrap if they were unable to raise money from private (or public) placement. The key is that they are all losing money so their fires are not self sufficient.
So a really good question is, why not go public?
My experience is that risk is a big factor here. And a number of unicorns have huge risk factors, whether it is bad labor judgments against Uber or sweeping hospitality laws against AirBnB, they have some unresolved 'nut' in their operation which prevents them from showing a risk tolerance that the public would be able to look past. So to evaluate a company that has been around for a while but hasn't shown it can be a profitable business, you have to find the unresolved systemic change that is keeping them unprofitable, and then you have to evaluate whether or not the odds are in favor of that issue being resolved in the company's favor. Which, given their longevity, suggests it is not going so well.
- rrdharan 10y ago> The key is that they are all losing money so their fires are not self sufficient. Can't speak for the others but Dropbox is not losing money. (To be clear they are free cash-flow positive but not profitable, however the point is they can survive indefinitely without raising more money.) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-14/dropbox-ceo-pushes-toward-profitability-in-a-post-unicorn-era https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-14/dropbox-c...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is awesome. It puts them back in control of their destiny. Their larger investors could still screw them but at least they have some leverage. I would guess if they can put together 3 quarters in a row with positive growth and cash flow they will drop an S-1 to allow their major investors to liquidate their holdings.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAnd a lot of people are speculating they will IPO this year, see https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603204/dropbox-could-have-one-of-2017s-most-interesting-ipos/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603204/dropbox-could-have...
- swyman 10y agoI have a really hard time putting much stock in metaphors that have so many components and work backwards from the metaphor to the real world. Too easy for the truth and usefulness of the advice to get stretched out to make the comment as a whole flow properly. Uber/Airbnb/et al aren't still private just because there's some uncomfortable risk they're afraid will push away public investors. There's a whole host of reasons to stay private (lawyers, executive time/energy, SEC compliance, public investors are generally more myopic than private ones, etc, etc, etc). The "nut" you mention might be an inconvenience, but it's surely not even close to the most important reason to stay private.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI certainly agree that reasoning by analogy can only go so far in conveying the complexity of the situation. Startups do not exist in a vacuum. That said, while I agree with you that there are lots of reasons a perfectly functioning, operationally cash flow positive company might choose to stay private. None of those reasons apply to companies that are diluting themselves with additional investment in order to stay in business. The money gets more and more expensive from investors, and more and more people get screwed, and then all that's left is to write the amazing journey blog entry.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoWait. What? Uber and AirBnB are _the_ examples of companies with an uncomfortable skeleton in their closet! Aren't they both founded on the principle of flounting the law?!
- afarrell 10y agoYes, but that is no secret, so how is it a skeleton?
- droopyEyelids 10y agoIt's a material risk to investors?