5 ms·
Close Look at Recent EmDrive Paper
- Analemma_ 10y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13286160 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13286160
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sethbannon 10y agoAll quite interesting but the important bit is in the conclusion: "In addition to mechanical and related considerations, the authors’ methods of analysis of sensor data to derive thrusts rests on untenable grounds... Therefore, until more control tests are performed allowing a more accurate method for estimation of thrusts, no faith can be placed in the thrust magnitudes reported in the paper."
- Zikes 10y agoCan somebody just put one of these in space already? We're seeing a post every week refuting the previous week's posts. http://i.imgur.com/W6CyRnB.gif http://i.imgur.com/W6CyRnB.gif
- superkuh 10y agoThat'd just add more uncontrolled variables. What they need to do is stop assuming they can disassociate effects from a superposition with a trend fitted by eye.
- stale2002 10y agoNot really. You put it in space, turn on the engine, and see if it STAYS in space. If it crashes to earth after a year, then it clearly doesn't work. If it steadily starts to escape earth's orbit, then it DOES work.
- cjensen 10y agoThe forces they are claiming are not sufficient to stay in space. Also, some sources of error would provide actual boosts in orbit without being useful as spacecraft engines.
- walrus01 10y agoA little bit more complicated than that, the very tiny thrust of the 60W to 80W units reported so far is not enough to keep a medium sized LEO satellite from deorbiting due to atmospheric drag. Now if you were to put it in a MEO orbit where the atmospheric effects would have negligible impact on perigee and periapsis over even a 1000 year time period, and then turn on the "thruster" 24x7 while aimed in a prograde direction, you could observe if the satellite gradually gained a few km apogee over the period of measurement. If it works you would see a gain of dozens of km apogee over a several month time scale.
- powera 10y agoHah. Not even the people who think it does work think it works that well.
- superkuh 10y agoNope. In space there would be even more thermal effects (due to varying amounts of sunlight). Then there's also photon pressure, uncontrolled outgassing, the variable ram pressure of the upper atmosphere due to it's changing height with the EUV output of the sun. As of right now the claimed effect is smaller than the thermal effects even in the lab. You put it in space and it'd be impossible to untangle the tiny real effect, if it exists, from all the other forces superimposed upon it that are much larger and literally impossible to predict the time variation of.
- saycheese 10y agoEmDrive: China claims success with this 'reactionless' engine for space travel https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249730
- Pfhreak 10y agoSomeone is: http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a22678/em-drive-cannae-cubesat-reactionless/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a22678/em-dri...
- madengr 10y agoI'm still curious to know if it could be rectified DC currents in the cavity as I posted here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13249730 One of the comments in this threads story, was to place the apparatus is a faraday cage. That does not shield against static magnetic fields. For that you need chambers of multiple layers of high permeability materials, separated by air.
- sandworm101 10y agoDoesnt a vac chamber already make for a reasonable faraday cage?
- madengr 10y agoYes, though not up to standards of a room for RF testing. Though, classic faraday cage does not shield static magnetic fields, like the Earths field.
- powera 10y agoArticle summary - the science and the experiment behind the EmDrive claims are flawed. My take - the people pushing this are charlatans and should be ignored completely.
- dpark 10y agoI don't see why they should be ignored. Right now what we have is an unexpected and unexplained effect. The scientific thing to do is to understand what is happening. The fact that the initial claims may be from charlatans is irrelevant. "We don't understand it and the explanation is likely boring, so let's ignore it" might be a decent engineering tradeoff, but it comes from a goal of cost savings, not from a goal of improving our knowledge of physics. Science is about improving our knowledge and understanding.
- simonh 10y agoI agree ignoring it isn't a responsible approach, but if the paper is flawed and the 'measurements' are below a meaningful level, what that means is we still don't yet even know if there is any effect at all.
- dpark 10y agoFor sure, we don't know if there is any effect. I'm guessing there isn't. There also weren't any faster-than-light neutrinos but investigating the anomalous measurements from OPERA until they were understood was the scientifically sound choice.
- euyyn 10y agoBecause those scientists: 1) Were looking for the error in their method, not trying to get press and/or budget using a claim of FTL particles. 2) Had already done their darnest to not be fooled by their experimental setup. And this was a huge lot of phycisists having looked. Neither 1 nor 2 hold here; and so these people are wasting other people's time.
- walrus01 10y agoSomething I'm confused about, and I do RF/microwave engineering work... There's a lot of debate about whether the "thrust" produced is real or is an artifact of the test environment. But they're only testing at relatively low power levels like 40W, 60W, 80W. There are lots of commercially available sources for Klystron and TWT type amplifiers rated up to 3000W (used for C, Ku and Ka-band satellite earth station Tx applications). If the question is whether it's real, would it not make sense to build a HUGE FUCKING HIGH POWERED test rig with >1500W input? If we're measuring possible "thurst" in micronewtons, and the claim of the original research is that the thrust will scale somewhat proportionally with the power level applied, does it not make sense to develop an unambiguous result by building a very high powered test rig? In a theoretical scenario where a high powered test rig produces real measurable thrust that is far too great to be a measurement error, it would be an amount in millinewtons that is far too great to be explained by a non-thrust variable such as thermal expansion/contraction in the power cables, etc. If the claim is 260 micronewtons at 60W, use COTS klystron and/or TWTA technology to build a 3000W test rig. Question answered. here are some examples of high powered units for satcom purposes: http://www.cpii.com/product.cfm/4/13 http://www.cpii.com/product.cfm/4/13 edit: The thing is described as a "resonant cavity" and operates at 1.9 GHz: http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120 http://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.B36120 Looks damn near identical to a weird feed horn to me. The test article looks like a cone or horn antenna with a feed horn stuck onto the back of it. High power capable waveguides and feed horns for big-ass satellite telecom things (like an 11 meter sized C-band Tx/Rx earth station) are a well known science. You can buy them from a myriad of COTS sources.
- ridgeguy 10y agoFrom following EmDrive work a little, my impression is that nobody has the budget to do a high power setup right. Budget was a major limitation in the published NASA work. Also, some artifact sources (e.g. power lead/B field artifacts) would scale up along with power.
- flukus 10y agoYet there are a couple of separate plans to send it into space for testing. I would of thought more terrestrial testing would be much cheaper than sending something to space.