5 ms·
I agree that people should ask questions, but my advice remains for employees which is to consider shares, or rights to shares, held for a private company to ha
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I agree that people should ask questions, but my advice remains for employees which is to consider shares, or rights to shares, held for a private company to have zero value.
If you are going to get enough out of working for a company then great, go for it. Conversely if your only motivation for working for the company is that they have offered you a lot of shares then you should take a step back and think long and hard about that.
That flips of course for a publicly traded company, those shares have recognizable value right from the start and you can use Black-Sholes or other future value estimators to get a handle on how much you should be swayed by those shares.
As the article points out, it is particular corrosive around the c-suite (CEO, CTO, Cx0 what ever) of people who founded the company. They will often hold a solid number of shares already and even though they shouldn't, will often do the math that if they had sold their shares in this round rather than generating new shares they would be multi-millionaires. Sometimes protecting that illusion becomes more important than making good decisions.
- hkmurakami 10y agoI tend to give people the same advice, especially for early stage companies. But what advice would you give someone who has an offer from Uber/Airbnb/Dropbox/Pinterest/Palantir? They're derisked to the point where the RSUs/options should have some value, and their offers to employees definitely reflects this. In addition, many of these very late stage companies' employment offers are very heavy on the equity side. Would you still just tell someone who has an Airbnb offer who's weighing it against say, one from Microsoft, to consider the options to be worth $0? I had a friend who was in a similar predicament and the friend didn't seem to want to believe the steep discounts I told him he needs to apply to the RSUs/Options. At the very least 5%/year compound discounting for the illiquidity premium, as well as a steep 20-30%+ discount for uncertainty for actual exit. Not just business metrics, but macro market conditions as well as the random whims of the board. I personally value liquidity a lot, and made a strong case that a comparable offer from a publicly traded tech firm to blow a late stage startup's equity heavy package out of the water.
- tbrownaw 10y agoBut what advice would you give someone who has an offer from Uber/Airbnb/Dropbox/Pinterest/Palantir? They're derisked to the point where the RSUs/options should have some value, and their offers to employees definitely reflects this. Wasn't there a post here recently about one of those companies having restrictions that made it more-or-less impossible to cash out your equity if you ever left?
- pyb 10y agoUber
- linkregister 10y agoFor options employees; RSU employees don't have the 90-day expiration. It is pretty egregious that options employees are in that predicament. Edit: please correct my fact or otherwise respond. If I am incorrect I'd like to know; the drive-by downvote doesn't help.
- hkmurakami 10y agoIs the options employees vs RSU employees distinction simply dependant on their join date? (before and after the company switched from options to RSUs) This is fascinating because at other companies, you can easily have the opposite: A company goes from having option with an extended option exercise period (say 2, 7, 10 years) to RSUs. The RSUs, whether they are on a delayed vesting with handoff when employee leaves, or outright confiscation upon departure, are both worse than the options scenario.
- linkregister 10y agoI'm guessing it's dependent on join date. I'll ask my friends. The scheme with Uber is the options can be exercised up to 90 days after departure, but the RSUs are held until IPO, at which the employee/former employee takes possession of them and is responsible for paying taxes on the income. Secondary share sales are essentially prohibited, only being authorized if the board approves them. Illiquid until IPO.
- kelnos 10y ago> If you are going to get enough out of working for a company then great, go for it. Conversely if your only motivation for working for the company is that they have offered you a lot of shares then you should take a step back and think long and hard about that. That seems to be a bit of a false dichotomy, though. I'd assume it'd be vanishingly rare to find someone whose only motivation to work for a company is their illiquid equity comp. I hear a lot of people who suggest that equity in a private company is worth $0, and I even preached that as well, but I think it's counterproductive to do so. Sure, it's difficult to properly value such equity, but I think discounting it down to $0 is nearly as bad as assuming it's worth a lot more than it's possible to be worth. Let's say that you're lucky enough that comp isn't your #1 motivation for working at a company; maybe it's down at #4 or #5, after working on cool projects, autonomy, working with smart people, etc. Comp is important, but it's not the most important thing. If you're really convinced that a particular private company's options could be worth something someday, and you're able to negotiate a reasonable cash salary, looking at the equity comp as a differentiating factor as compared to another company that has a less attractive equity package is perfectly reasonable. Assuming that the equity packages of both companies is $0 throws away useful information. I think of the "value it at $0" strategy as a knee-jerk reaction to overzealous fresh college grads thinking a big number of options automatically means they're going to be rich. It's a useful phrase to throw at someone who has limited ability to do a risk assessment, but is a bit patronizing to someone who does.
- ap22213 10y agoIf you're in a position to negotiate the terms of the option contract, then sure, you're right. But, someone with that kind of negotiation position isn't the article's target audience anyway. Unusual options contracts usually have to be presented to, sold to, and approved by the board. So, unless you're extra special, you're going to get the boiler plate contract. And, the boiler plate contract has gotten much less attractive over the years - filled with enough clauses to make the options effectively worthless. If you can assume that your CEO, the board, the acquiring company, and the lawyers are generous, and that the company will be unusually successful, then maybe it's worth it for the average employee to take options into consideration. But, that is a lot of assuming.
- ec109685 10y agoYou are taking the agency out of employees with this stance. If they strongly believe in the product, the team and the company's mission, it absolutely does not make sense to consider the shares granted to be worthless. Otherwise, they could easily pass up on a very valuable oppprtinity.
- gopalv 10y ago> it absolutely does not make sense to consider the shares granted to be worthless That is very true. The specific situation of a Unicorn is somewhat value growth (+ dilution) without direct market corrections for an extended period of time. For a Unicorn the possibility of being able to encash the value in real money needs to be considered. In general, the value needs to be multiplied by one of two factors. Possibility of an 83(B) + your ability to buy yourself out of the golden hand-cuffs against the potential length of your tenure, even in the last months of a pre-IPO hold-out situation within the company. Those are realistic factors to consider, with the latter being the biggest toss-up bet there.
- acjohnson55 10y agoThat's true, but it's incredibly difficult to predict all the factors that would need to happen for a given employee at a new company to end up with a significant windfall. Even if you believe in the product with all your heart, you probably don't have the transparency to make a proper valuation, and there are a whole bunch of factors completely out of your control (performance of other employees, terms of later rounds, timing of exit, competitive landscape, macroeconomic conditions, ad infinitum). It's a big gamble. That delta between your market rate and your cash comp at FancyStartup.com is the money you're taking into the casino in your pocket. Be okay with coming back out with zero of it. Take the chance on a startup because you love the product & team, because it's the right role for you in your career development, and because you can afford to allocate some of your lifetime earning potential to taking a chance on it. Okay, so you're still going to do it. Be smart about it. You're an investor: observe the company from an holistic standpoint. Ask the tough questions to give yourself as much transparency as you can get. Reevaluate your decision periodically to make sure it still makes sense. Advocate for your own interests. And be prepared to cut your losses, if need be.
- fnl 10y ago> I agree that people should ask questions, but my advice remains for employees which is to consider shares, or rights to shares, held for a private company to have zero value. That matches pretty exactly what three independent US (Californian & one NY) lawyers advised me: Only consider shares from startups if all else is equal.