10 ms·
Don’t Get Trampled: The Puzzle for “Unicorn” Employees
- dilemma 10y agoYou never know who the unicorn employees are until it's too late - they're working for someone else and either don't want to leave or know what their market value is so they are no longer a "deal" to hire. If you want to find talent, you must find a way to develop it in-house.
- mathattack 10y agoIf you want to find talent, you must find a way to develop it in-house. This is a great sentiment, but doesn't scale at hypergrowth. P&G and McKinsey can do this, because they're growing slowly. If you're growing at 100+% a year (or even 50+%) you just don't have time to grow all your own talent. It's a very challenging problem. Great leaders rely on bringing people in that they've worked with before, but there's limits to how much this can scale. Overall the OP is spot on for what he says.
- sathackr 10y agoDid you read the article? It's about employees of "Unicorn" companies, not "Unicorn" employees.
- Kinnard 10y agoI'd love to see information on the latter.
- eschutte2 10y agoI much preferred the brief moment in time when "unicorn" was used to mean "someone who does both code and design really well," because it made sense: something rumored to exist but nobody's seen it, hard to capture, has magical powers to make things better. The only thing VC companies and unicorns have in common are: fairy tale, extinction? Is it really just "something rare?" Not a very deep metaphor.
- Kinnard 10y agoHmmm, I've developed both skills in tandem . . . maybe I should start calling myself a unicorn . . .
- dilemma 10y agoI opened the link and was about to get started reading but came up with an idea for what I wanted to say based on how I interpreted the headline and went back and wrote the above. So you're right, I didn't read it but I will now.
- birken 10y agoTowards the end he makes the comment: "Can you please let me know how much money I’d make from my options if the company were to sell or IPO for $100m, 200m, 300m, 400m, etc?" Here is a simple open-source site (FD: which I wrote) which handles this for you: https://friendlyoptions.org/ https://friendlyoptions.org/ Give the site to your prospective employer, ask them to fill it out with the details of your stock option grant and then share the link with you (all the information is stored in the URL so no data leaks to the site --- or just run it locally if you are paranoid). The site asks for the minimum amount of information possible for you to start valuing your stock options so if they can't fill it out, you essentially have no way to value your options. ---- With that advertisement out of the way, I disagree with this article a little bit. I think questions about the past/present are all completely fair game and should be asked and answered: * How much money have you raised and at what terms? * What is the current stock option plan and what are the details of my stock option grant? * Have their been any secondary sale transactions in the past? Who participated? But once you get into the future, prepare to be sold a very optimistic vision of the future that may or may not coincide with reality. And this isn't necessarily anybody doing anything wrong, generally the people who run these types of companies are very optimistic people who believe that what they are saying is true. However, this doesn't mean it is likely to happen. I'm not saying you shouldn't ask, get all the information you can, but a company will never tell you a pessimistic view of the future (and nor should they). They may say they'd never take debt and are shooting for an IPO in 2 years, but I guarantee you if something changes in a year those plans might all go out of the window.
- econner 10y agoIs a secondary sale good or bad? Why ask this question?
- hkmurakami 10y agoSome scenarios: 1) If there has been one in the past, you may reasonably expect another one in the future. They may even reveal that they have secondary sales at regular intervals. This derisks your equity illiquidity somewhat. 2) If there was a secondary sale where only part of the "leadership" participated, then that's at least a yellow flag for management's attitudes towards its workforce.
- ditonal 10y agoI've always been baffled that asking these questions are not incredibly obvious to anyone. I could not agree more that not knowing the outstanding shares, the liquidiation preference, etc with the "it's like getting paid without knowing the currency." What's interesting, at my first startup job I had the CEO push back when I asked how many outstanding shares there were, amazingly, even though otherwise it makes the stock compensation literally a meaningless number. The second place I work that gave me options gave me a bit more info, but there was still so much uncertainty compared to a company that just paid public RSUs or cash, especially because I had no insight into the financials like burn rate. Both of these places ended up having worthless options, and in both cases I couldn't even "wait and see" because by leaving I was forced to choose to exercise. Not only are options often worth less then you think, you get all the tax complications, all the exercise window complications - how do people not discount their value even more? I think a company like Uber should just offer cash. They are not a rocket ship, they are already in space but haven't IPOed for weird reasons. They raised enough money to just pay cash. If the financiers want to play financial games, they should play them amongst themselves, not with employees livelihood. All of this advice pops up, "Get an (expensive) lawyer to review it", "Take this online seminar" etc. It's like writing a job offer in a foreign language and suggesting someone take a few Duolingo classes so they can read it and make sure it doesn't screw them. And if you need a lawyer to review it, reimbursing an independent one should be part of the job offer, full stop. Nowadays people are saying don't join startups for money. But it seems that the founders and VCs are very interested in money. It seems they think _you_ are the only one who shouldn't be worried about money. Work yourself to the bone because "we're a startup", don't expect to get paid because you're "changing the world", but excuse me while I drive off in my ferrari I bought. Yes, the startup will "change the world", almost always in the sense that every company changes the world by offering goods and services. But if you want to work for charity, work for a non-profit, why do people think it makes sense to sacrifice their own income so some rich VC can get richer? The tune has changed recently as well. Because pg used to say startups were the way to get rich, by compressing your work years. Zach Holman used to say the same thing. Nowadays you do the compressing your working years in terms of work output, just not in terms of compensation. And Zach Holman is now writing every other blog post on how startups don't pay out and they "move fast and break people." With the crappy salaries startups offer, it's almost impossible to buy a house in the Bay Area, yet somehow you get looped into the anti-tech villinization. If I'm going to be the big bad evil rich bogeyman, might as well actually try to get paid like one. Startups were romanticized. These billion dollar companies that are clearly not startups tried to retain the startup "brand". And even the early-stage startups are really just product areas of the VC firm. You are still working for a big company. The VCs call the shot, your "CEO" is the PM. But it's great for the VCs since they can screw you over, screw the customer over, screw the public over, and it doesn't matter because each one of these dinky startups is their own brand you can shut down tomorrow. They rode the waves of a lot of romanticism from pg essays, the Social Network, Airbnb/Uber/Snapchat, but now bigger companies are paying more, too many engineers have gotten screwed by equity grants, and I think we're seeing a general trend away from startups. Maybe it will eventually restart, but VC companies will not be appealing until VCs fix these issues.
- grobbles 10y agoSpeaking of unicorns, here's what one of the best programmers I've ever worked with has fallen to- https://dennisforbes.ca/index.php/seeking-a-well-capitalized-partner/ https://dennisforbes.ca/index.php/seeking-a-well-capitalized... This is pretty dire for me as someone who was in the shadows. On the flip side I moved to a very low cost region so I feel like I'm in a better position. As an aside, I realize this will be a deceased post, but make it still for the edification of the few who have showdead on.
- pfarnsworth 10y ago> You’d be shocked to learn how many companies raising money at a billion-dollar valuation are doing so with financials that have never been checked/audited by a third-party. I would love to hear examples. Otherwise I'm calling bullshit on this one.
- venantius 10y agoIndeed. A 409A valuation should be being done by an independent auditor at each fundraising step, and most investors will only invest if they know the auditor is independent.
- flylib 10y agohe was a GP at a top 3 VC firm in the world (Benchmark) recently and is an advisor to Uber and a lot of other companies...
- epa 10y agoA billion may be a stretch but 500M for sure. You'd be surprised and obviously examples are confidential.
- msoad 10y agoBigger unicorns like Uber, Airbnb, Dropbox and Lyft stopped giving options are giving RSUs like public companies. The employee know how much each RSU worth based on last round. Total number of shares are known. Of course it's all confidential.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hkmurakami 10y agoFWIW Palantir is still on options, and they're valued at $20B or whatever. So being super late stage is no guarantee for your equity being in RSUs.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI agree that people should ask questions, but my advice remains for employees which is to consider shares, or rights to shares, held for a private company to have zero value. If you are going to get enough out of working for a company then great, go for it. Conversely if your only motivation for working for the company is that they have offered you a lot of shares then you should take a step back and think long and hard about that. That flips of course for a publicly traded company, those shares have recognizable value right from the start and you can use Black-Sholes or other future value estimators to get a handle on how much you should be swayed by those shares. As the article points out, it is particular corrosive around the c-suite (CEO, CTO, Cx0 what ever) of people who founded the company. They will often hold a solid number of shares already and even though they shouldn't, will often do the math that if they had sold their shares in this round rather than generating new shares they would be multi-millionaires. Sometimes protecting that illusion becomes more important than making good decisions.
- hkmurakami 10y agoI tend to give people the same advice, especially for early stage companies. But what advice would you give someone who has an offer from Uber/Airbnb/Dropbox/Pinterest/Palantir? They're derisked to the point where the RSUs/options should have some value, and their offers to employees definitely reflects this. In addition, many of these very late stage companies' employment offers are very heavy on the equity side. Would you still just tell someone who has an Airbnb offer who's weighing it against say, one from Microsoft, to consider the options to be worth $0? I had a friend who was in a similar predicament and the friend didn't seem to want to believe the steep discounts I told him he needs to apply to the RSUs/Options. At the very least 5%/year compound discounting for the illiquidity premium, as well as a steep 20-30%+ discount for uncertainty for actual exit. Not just business metrics, but macro market conditions as well as the random whims of the board. I personally value liquidity a lot, and made a strong case that a comparable offer from a publicly traded tech firm to blow a late stage startup's equity heavy package out of the water.
- tbrownaw 10y agoBut what advice would you give someone who has an offer from Uber/Airbnb/Dropbox/Pinterest/Palantir? They're derisked to the point where the RSUs/options should have some value, and their offers to employees definitely reflects this. Wasn't there a post here recently about one of those companies having restrictions that made it more-or-less impossible to cash out your equity if you ever left?
- jorblumesea 10y agoIf you are working for any startup you will inevitably be disappointed when you're not some rich uber millionaire. The last people to get paid out are the workers. Investors, CEOs all get their cut first. My pay is about equal to Big 4/Corporate goonshop, and I do way more interesting work. That's enough for me :) If I get paid out, realistically it may be only 100k, perhaps even less. Maybe nothing. Maybe more.
- hilbertseries 10y agoI've talked to people at Facebook building their own NoSQL databases for large scale internal use at facebook, working on HHVM, GRAPHQL, working on stuff like their location services that serve billions of queries per second. I'm curious, what is it that you've managed to find that's way more interesting than the type of problems only the big four companies have.
- gaius 10y agoBig 4 in this context is Accenture, PwC, Deloitte and KPMG.
- jorblumesea 10y agoI wouldn't consider FB a big 4 but you bring up a good point, that is confusing terminology.
- somic 10y agoGood article. Bottom line is employees need to be aware what can happen and how future rounds of financing, among other things, could affect their equity comp. The more articles and blog posts about it, the better. There is no one-size-fits-all recommendation though. Everybody is different, and everybody's situation is different. What works for me won't necessarily work for you. Equity comp, especially in non-publicly-traded companies, indeed is closer to a lottery than a lot of people think, and articles like this are helpful because they are educating people about it. I also once wrote a blog post about this topic - http://www.somic.org/2015/12/28/on-employees-investing-in-their-startups/ http://www.somic.org/2015/12/28/on-employees-investing-in-th...
- option_skeptic 10y agoLet's put down some actual numbers here. Too many people get screwed by information assymetry. If you are capable of getting offers at the top public companies, I would not work for a unicorn unless they are offering 500k+ in options (which has expected value similar to 200k-500k of public company RSUs). And to be clear, unicorns actually do sometimes make offers like this.
- mathattack 10y agoOf course - it's a matter of seniority, outstanding shares (the denominator) and how much cash they're planning on paying. 500K+ in options could carry a value of 200K, which is equivalent to 50K per year which you may (or may not!) give up in salary.
- lostboys67 10y agoYou really need 4 or 5x the options/rsu's you would get at a FTSE 100 to allow for a risk premium even more if you are taking a pay cut to join them.
- abalone 10y ago> Another interesting idea to reduce complexity for employees came from Brian Neider at Lead Edge Capital, who suggested a single question for employees to ask management: “Can you please let me know how much money I’d make from my options if the company were to sell or IPO for $100m, 200m, 300m, 400m, etc?” Is that really the best single question to ask? It's actually a complex question as it depends on subsequent funding rounds and terms such as dilution and liquidation prefs. You should not need to run a simulator to figure out if you're getting a decent grant. If the goal is to compare grant sizes to other offers, how about a simple objective metric like percentage ownership? That will give you a general sense of how sizable a chunk you are getting. It will of course vary by growth stage, but within stages it's closer to apples-to-apples than anything I can think of (even FMV).
- mifeng 10y agoStartup equity is just an at-the-money call option. Worth something but not a ton on day 1. Due to tax guidelines, companies are highly incentivized to grant employees options struck at the last 409A valuation price. For companies who have raised multiple institutional rounds, this is usually the last round's post money valuation. This number is essentially the market valuation for the company, so an employee option is just a security with a strike price at fair market value. It has value due to optionality but only due to that.
- hueving 10y ago>Startup equity is just an at-the-money call option. Worth something but not a ton on day 1. It's very different from an option that you can sell on the open market though. I would take an at the money call option (with an expiration years in the future) for any publicly traded company over a startup.
- traviscj 10y agoMaybe the stock market just needs to introduce a new "Martian Stock Option" (along with American and European) that has an expiration date of the company's choosing, to be decided at a future date, with a penalty for or prohibition against selling the option before some other future date. Then we can just let the day traders play this game for us, and see if they can make any sense of it.
- pmorici 10y agoIsn't the fundamental problem here that companies just don't provide the information to prospective employees that would be required to fully understand the value of the equity component of their offer? Sure they try to turn it around and say that the employees aren't "asking the right questions". In reality, companies don't want to give that info out because it's to their advantage not to since w/o it you will almost certainly over value their offer unless you subscribe to the it's probably worth zero mantra.
- zenlikethat 10y agoThat's why you shouldn't ever buy into rhetoric that the company has your best interests at heart or it's a "family". It's a business transaction, one which they probably do a lot of, and they have a million problems on their plate probably more important than educating you on this. Not saying that's great, but it's the way it is.
- logicallee 10y ago"You know why they call them Unicorns, don't they?" "Cuz' they're really, really, really, really GREAT?" (looks at employee; doesn't have the heart to tell them.) "Uh, yeah. That's exactly why." Mumbles to himself: 'poor kid.'
- logicallee 10y agoyou guys didn't get my joke :) It's because they're mythical; they don't exist. So since they're originally mythical, if you see an actual Unicorn - well, there's a good chance it's a horse with a cone taped to its forehead... It doesn't originally just mean very great: it originally means basically mythical.
- suchitpuri 10y agoA good article indeed, i see that a lot of employees are confused about their stock options specially in emerging markets like India, where we have seen quite a few unicorns come up in last 3-5 years. I also really like the advice about privately held companies, who want to remain private. Things get very tricky there and on top of that mostly no one understands what to do with the stock options. Unless you are able to do a secondary sale of the stock options they dont carry any value and i don't think a lot of privately help companies allow that. Not to ignore the tax you have to pay when you want to buy stocks, even though you cannot sell it.
- dbg31415 10y agoThis is a dupe. Original - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13305066 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13305066 Best - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13313550 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13313550