4 ms·
Apple didn't need to wait for Kaby Lake to be able to add more RAM, other laptops have 32GB. Lower power consumption wouldn't mean a lot when most peoples lapt
by TheSpiceIsLife 10y ago
Apple didn't need to wait for Kaby Lake to be able to add more RAM, other laptops have 32GB.
Lower power consumption wouldn't mean a lot when most peoples laptops are idle, or doing very little work, most of the time anyway.
I guess these are some of the trade-offs Apple chose to roll with.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoOops, that was pretty wrong.
- izacus 10y agoThe chipsets for the Skylake generation in current MacBooks top out at 16GB. They would have to use a more power-hungry version of them or wait for Kaby Lake. They decided to limit memory instead.
- mpweiher 10y ago> Lower power consumption wouldn't mean a lot > when most peoples laptops are idle Er...RAM eats power even when the machine is idle.
- morsch 10y agoThat's a given. The question is: how much? As one data point, Tom's Hardware measured¹ 12W for 32 GB DDR4 in 2014, scaling linearly. According to some random guy on the Internet², the MBP's LPDDR3 power usage is similar to DDR4 when active, and much lower - 10% - in standby. I'm not sure if standby is limited to system-wide standby, or if the computer can selectively standby portions of the system RAM (that would seem desirable). For what it's worth, this³ is the tech ref of the Samsung memory used in the 2016 MBP (according to the iFixit teardown). So we have a range of 1.2 to 12W for 32 GB (and 0.6 to 6W for 16 GB), if LPDDR3 is comparable to DDR4 and depending on active or standby usage of the memory. ¹ www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-core-i7-5960x-haswell-e-cpu,3918-13.html ² With references, it's a good post/thread https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/5dimal/lpddr3_vs_ddr4_power_usage/ https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/5dimal/lpddr3_vs_... ³ https://memorylink.samsung.com/ecomobile/mem/ecomobile/product/productDetail.do?topMenu=A&subMenu=tablets&appNo=tablets&appLabel=Tablets&partNo=K4E6E304EB-EGCE&partSetNo=LPDDR3 https://memorylink.samsung.com/ecomobile/mem/ecomobile/produ...