6 ms·
Hmm...sure puts all the criticism Apple got for not waiting for Kaby Lake for its MacBook Pros into perspective. We are in an effective post-Moore's law world,
by mpweiher 10y ago
Hmm...sure puts all the criticism Apple got for not waiting for Kaby Lake for its MacBook Pros into perspective.
We are in an effective post-Moore's law world, and have been for a couple of years. Yes, we can still put more transistors on the chip, but we are pretty much done with single core performance, at least until some really big breakthrough.
On the other hand, as another poster pointed out, we really don't need all that much more performance, as most of the performance of current chips isn't actually put to good use, but instead squandered[1]. (My 1991 NeXT Cube with 25 MHz '40 was pretty much as good for word processing as anything I can get now, and you could easily go back further).
Most of the things that go into squandering CPU don't parallelize well, so removing the bloat is actually starting to become cheaper again than trying to combat it with more silicon. And no, I am not just saying that to promote my upcoming book[2], I've actually been saying the same thing since before I started writing it.
Interesting times.
[1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/spending-moores-dividend/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/spendin...
[2] https://www.amazon.com/MACOS-PERFORMANCE-TUNING-Developers-Library/dp/0321842847 https://www.amazon.com/MACOS-PERFORMANCE-TUNING-Developers-L...
- izacus 10y agoWhat do you mean by putting it into perspective? Those are desktop CPUs, which are separate from laptop CPUs. On laptops, Kaby Lake would give them the ability to add more RAM and IIRC even lower power consumption.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoApple didn't need to wait for Kaby Lake to be able to add more RAM, other laptops have 32GB. Lower power consumption wouldn't mean a lot when most peoples laptops are idle, or doing very little work, most of the time anyway. I guess these are some of the trade-offs Apple chose to roll with.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoOops, that was pretty wrong.
- izacus 10y agoThe chipsets for the Skylake generation in current MacBooks top out at 16GB. They would have to use a more power-hungry version of them or wait for Kaby Lake. They decided to limit memory instead.
- mpweiher 10y ago> Lower power consumption wouldn't mean a lot > when most peoples laptops are idle Er...RAM eats power even when the machine is idle.
- morsch 10y agoThat's a given. The question is: how much? As one data point, Tom's Hardware measured¹ 12W for 32 GB DDR4 in 2014, scaling linearly. According to some random guy on the Internet², the MBP's LPDDR3 power usage is similar to DDR4 when active, and much lower - 10% - in standby. I'm not sure if standby is limited to system-wide standby, or if the computer can selectively standby portions of the system RAM (that would seem desirable). For what it's worth, this³ is the tech ref of the Samsung memory used in the 2016 MBP (according to the iFixit teardown). So we have a range of 1.2 to 12W for 32 GB (and 0.6 to 6W for 16 GB), if LPDDR3 is comparable to DDR4 and depending on active or standby usage of the memory. ¹ www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-core-i7-5960x-haswell-e-cpu,3918-13.html ² With references, it's a good post/thread https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/5dimal/lpddr3_vs_ddr4_power_usage/ https://www.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/5dimal/lpddr3_vs_... ³ https://memorylink.samsung.com/ecomobile/mem/ecomobile/product/productDetail.do?topMenu=A&subMenu=tablets&appNo=tablets&appLabel=Tablets&partNo=K4E6E304EB-EGCE&partSetNo=LPDDR3 https://memorylink.samsung.com/ecomobile/mem/ecomobile/produ...
- olegkikin 10y ago> we really don't need all that much more performance That's a ridiculous thing to say, especially on HN. There are many tasks that would benefit from higher performance. Not everyone limits themselves to text processing. We're also CPU-bound for many tasks at the moment - consumer SSDs got to 2-3GB/s, RAM to 40-60GB/s. Not many useful computations can be performed on a single core at such speeds (hardware-accelerated encryption is one exception I can think of). Yes, we need more cores, but you can scale linearly only that far - production gets expensive, electrical consumption gets expensive, cooling gets expensive, you run out of space.
- astrodust 10y agoDevelopers need more performance. Video editors need more performance. CGI artists need more performance. Servers need more performance. Phones need more performance. In contrast, desktop computers for general-purpose needs are already adequate. Word processing, YouTube, Facebook, and non-enthusiast gaming has pretty modest needs that are easily met by a mid-range i5. The only thing that will put pressure on that is entirely new applications that are much more demanding. VR could be one of those things, but I don't see it as a significant market maker inside of a decade. The same goes for AI.
- mpweiher 10y ago> Developers need more performance. But do we need more hardware performance or more software performance? My main point was that things are slow mostly not because the hardware is inadequate, but instead because the software is inadequate, and the software is inadequate because developers have become lazy, because the hardware used to bail us out for free.
- astrodust 10y agoThis is the laziest argument ever made. Hardware is continuing to improve in performance, it's just that the gains are focused on things like power efficiency rather than brute force. Likewise, software continues to improve in performance: JavaScript engines, to use but one example, are consistently getting faster. If you want to live in some grim world where everything is shit and nothing will ever get fixed, knock yourself out, but the truth of the matter is there's relentless and significant improvements being made across the board.
- jpalomaki 10y agoWhat we really need is not the performance increase, but a good excuse to spend some money on new toys. It would be interesting to know how many of those who really feel strongly about this kind of things are actually buying based on their computing needs and how many have some other reasons (like getting some tangible reward for having worked hard - money on bank account is abstract, new PC is quite concrete).
- spuz 10y agoKaby Lake offers significant reductions in power consumption which is important for longer batter life on laptops and definitely something Apple should be concerned about. Laptops that have had upgrades from Skylake to Kaby lake reported significant increases in battery life: http://www.itworld.com/article/3154243/computers/12-things-youll-get-in-pcs-with-intels-new-kaby-lake-chips.html http://www.itworld.com/article/3154243/computers/12-things-y... http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/3001791/lenovo-thinkpad-x1-carbon-upgrade-packs-kaby-lake-usb-c-and-a-15-hour-battery-life http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/3001791/lenovo-thin... http://www.pcworld.com/article/3127250/hardware/intel-kaby-lake-review-what-optimization-can-do-for-a-14nm-cpu.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/3127250/hardware/intel-kaby-l... http://uk.pcmag.com/new-razer-blade-stealth-late-2016 http://uk.pcmag.com/new-razer-blade-stealth-late-2016
- post_break 10y agoExcept it seems like any time there is a nice drop in power consumption Apple says "oh look at how much thinner we can make it by shipping it with a smaller battery!"
- haswell 10y agoThat may be so, but it doesn't invalidate the point made by the parent comment. What Apple chooses to do with that improvement in power consumption may be up for discussion, but the fact that there is fair criticism about the fact that they didn't wait is not.
- mulmen 10y agoYes and then they will make the battery thinner than the CPU cooler and instead of solving that one foot will sit slightly lower than the other three and the whole laptop will wobble on a desk. The iPhone6(s)/7 camera lens is such shockingly bad design I still can't understand how Apple justified it to themselves.
- scarlac 10y agoA physically smaller battery usually translates into a weight reduction. I'd even argue that it's the point of laptops: A mobile/light computer. But how you balance the two is a matter of opinion. If you look at the amount of battery-saving features they have been working on, it's obvious that they focus on lowering consumption instead of engaging the spec numbers game.
- hyperpallium 10y agoOvershooting mainstream performance needs is what drove netbooks... and phones. Now, phones have overshot. So (eg) iPhone 5s and Samsung Galaxy S5 are still selling well. Mainstream doesn't need the fat trimmed. eg Vulkan/Metal, which halve the CPU load (not GPU) of graphics sit idle.
- pcwalton 10y ago> Most of the things that go into squandering CPU don't parallelize well That's not true. We just aren't trying very hard to parallelize our code. I work on parallelizing browsers and there's a lot that can be done. For example, libpng leaves 2x potential performance on the table by not pipelining the Huffman decode with the defiltering. That said, I do agree that a better use of our time in most cases would be to improve the sequential performance of our software, because usually you shouldn't start parallelizing until you've exhausted the potential sequential improvements.
- byuu 10y ago> On the other hand, as another poster pointed out, we really don't need all that much more performance, as most of the performance of current chips isn't actually put to good use, but instead squandered The real benefit, in my view, is to emulation. It's extremely CPU intensive. And the more accurate you want the emulation, the more the resource demands go up. Today's CPUs are only just powerful enough for very good reproduction of a poorly optimized 16-bit gaming system emulator, or a greatly optimized 32-bit system emulator. But for PS2 and beyond, we don't have the power for highly accurate simulation yet. It's also nice for "wasting" power by writing in higher-level abstractions that are not as efficient, but are safer and easier to understand (think always bounds-checking a vector, instead of dropping down to raw pointer arithmetic.) Something that applies to all application development, including for emulators.
- ianai 10y agoSo was this article just nothing? http://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/devices/intel-finds-moores-laws-next-step-at-10-nanometers http://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/devices/intel-finds-... "Sometime in 2017, Intel will ship the first processors built using the company’s new, 10-nanometer chip-manufacturing technology. Intel says transistors produced in this way will be cheaper than those that came before, continuing the decades-long trend at the heart of Moore’s Law—and contradicting widespread talk that transistor-production costs have already sunk as low as they will go"
- swsieber 10y agoWell, the comment your replying to is sort of confusing - Moore's law does talk about transistors, yet his point was that even with more transistors, performance doesn't improve. That's also what your article mentions.
- neverminder 10y agoDoes it always have to be about the speed? How about native USB 3.1 support (which would make a lot of sense since they went all in with USB Type-C)? New 200 series chipset (Union Point) anyone? This is not an exhaustive list of new features, just the ones that I care about.