3 ms·
I don't think definitions of "middle class" which refer solely to proportion of income derived from capital have ever really been more mainstream or useful than
by notahacker 10y ago
I don't think definitions of "middle class" which refer solely to proportion of income derived from capital have ever really been more mainstream or useful than "white-collar"/"blue-collar" or salary-range based distinctions. Even Marxists whose entire economic philosophy is based on capital relations are usually happy to bracket wage-compensated managers alongside smallholders in the petit-bourgeoisie on the basis that they represent the interests of capital as opposed to because they actually own any.
The relevance of class distinctions which place Uber drivers - whose income is derived from applying labour to their own capital - in a higher economic class than doctors or SV programmers [who haven't exercised their options] is pretty minimal, and it isn't a capitalist conspiracy that other definitions of "middle class" are generally preferred.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The relevance of class distinctions which place Uber drivers (whose income is derived from applying labour to their own capital) in a higher economic class than doctors or SV programmers (who haven't exercised their options) is pretty minimal The classical economic classes are misleading when viewed as an inherent heirarchy (in pure capitalism, they might be -- at least, capitalists are definitively at the top -- but that is a feature for which pure capitalism has been criticized.) The classes, instead, represent commonality of interest from common manner of relating to the economy (income level is also a source of potential common interest, but it is distinct from, though correlated with, class.) And I think there is plenty of room to debate whether Uber drivers are genuinely primarily applying labor to their own capital, or whether the key, predominant, a d essential capital is that provided by Uber.