The headline here is an unfair summary of the actual question asked. The question asked lays out a very specific proposal and quite some comments indicate that

The headline here is an unfair summary of the actual question asked. The question asked lays out a very specific proposal and quite some comments indicate that the person disagrees because the sum proposed does not adequately cover the services cut - which is quite contrary to a disagreement with UBI in principle. (e.g.: Eric Maskin: "A minimum income makes sense, but not at the cost of eliminating Social Security and Meidcare.")