4 ms·
The biggest problem in Finnish welfare is pensions[1]. They are too high for babyboomer generation. Basic income would allow creation of something similar to mi
by nabla9 10y ago
The biggest problem in Finnish welfare is pensions[1]. They are too high for babyboomer generation. Basic income would allow creation of something similar to mini-jobs in Germany but still giving people a choice.
---
1: Yes. Pensions in Finland are welfare. Pension fund savings cover only tiny percentage of pension. Young working people are paying sums much bigger than basic income to old people.
- notahacker 10y agoTraditional BI as opposed to this experiment essentially is a state pension - a fixed monthly payment benchmarked to livable income - but paid to working age people. So if the biggest problem in Finnish welfare is spending too much on its 1.5million pensioners (and 250k unemployed) you probably don't want to subsidise another 1.4 million working age people who aren't working or looking for work, especially if you have to reclaim those costs by taxing the mere 2.7m people in employment. Ultimately, if BI had the incredibly desirable (and unlikely) effect of encouraging every one of Finland's 250k unemployed people to start part time work and pay tax on those earnings, the state would still be much worse off than before from paying all these economically inactive people a subsidy they probably don't need.