3 ms·
Sounds reasonable. A patent is supposed to represent actual existing technology, right? So by patenting it, Apple claims to already have this technology. So the
by mcv 10y ago
Sounds reasonable. A patent is supposed to represent actual existing technology, right? So by patenting it, Apple claims to already have this technology. So the assumption that they could do this but chose not to, seems fairly reasonable.
I'm not sure if I actually like blaming this sort of accident on technology, rather than on the people being stupid with technology, but if this will discourage patent trolls from holding patents they're not using, hoping to catch someone else infringing on it, then it could be a net positive. At the same time, I'm hesitant about what other side-effects this kind of precedent might end up having.
- zimpenfish 10y ago> A patent is supposed to represent actual existing technology, right? But they don't imply any kind of pragmatic or cost-effective use of such outside the confines of a lab or test bed, do they?
- simonh 10y ago> Sounds reasonable. Not at all. Patenting something just means it's possible, not that it works well, or that it has no disadvantages which might make things worse, or that it's always reliable, or that there are no better alternatives. Just that it can be done. The logical extension of this argument would be that every car sold in america, and every single product usable in a car, must have every single possible automotive-relevant safety feature they can even think of implemented in it regardless of cost. After all, implementing such a feature in the phone would incur a cost, so if Apple can be compelled to include the feature then that argument should apply to every other company.
- mcv 10y ago> Patenting something just means it's possible, It means a bit more than that. You don't patent the laws of nature, you patent real inventions. I'm aware that patent offices have gotten very loose with their criteria, but as far as I know, a patent was originally supposed to mean that you developed the thing you patented. Maybe there are disadvantages to it, but it has to be more than just possible.