6 ms·
Apple seems to hate their own developers. This story, others, and my own experiences tell me that Apple makes everything more difficult than need be to put toge
by pavlov 10y ago
Apple seems to hate their own developers. This story, others, and my own experiences tell me that Apple makes everything more difficult than need be to put together a program, small or large, that actually runs on their platform.
To Apple's credit, they are occasionally way ahead of the curve on developer convenience, and have reaped huge benefits from that.
I tried making smartphone apps in 2003-07 for Symbian, Java ME and the very first Android beta (the one that had a traditional keypad phone emulator). The experience was always disheartening. Horrible IDEs that sometimes cost money, awful device feature fragmentation with no standard ways to handle it, inconvenient APIs designed in the style of '90s embedded platform expectations.
If you managed to get a working app together, distributing it was a mystery. On Symbian, you'd have to pay something on the order of $1000+ for certification from a "special Symbian partner", and even after that there was no central app store. There were websites offering downloads (and paid listings), but users would not stumble on those. It was a terrible offering all around.
The native iPhone SDK in 2008 changed all that. Suddenly there was a smartphone with a desktop-class IDE experience and desktop-derived APIs, with easy access to fascinating new multitouch UI possibilities... And there was an integrated Apple-curated store where you could publish any number of apps for only $99 / year! That was an amazing deal compared to anything that came before in this space. Some occasional hassles with Xcode bugs and certificate weirdness was nothing compared to the nightmare of the Symbian/JavaME style mobile dev experience.
Even before that, Apple had done well by its Mac OS X developers by offering the NeXT-originated Cocoa tools for free. Back in 2001, that wasn't the expectation yet. It was a good API, battle-hardened at NeXT already, and much better than anything Microsoft was pushing in that Windows XP timeframe. Apple's efforts to support OS X development had two major benefits: the Mac's resurgence was helped by increasing availability of good 3rd party software created by dedicated developers, and the iPhone global launch was greatly helped by the fact that those same OS X developers were able to easily move to the iPhone.
- bhldr 10y agoI think past-apple did do a really decent job and set the stage for many other vendors to follow. Everybody has caught up and surpassed it though.
- sb8244 10y agoThere was a car commerical which sums up my feelings here pretty well. What do you do when you get a room full of trophies? You think about how to get more. Apple seems to have gotten their trophies here (no doubt) and then stared at them rather than figured out how to get more.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat they did with the iPhone really makes me sad. They had a unique opportunity to completely open up mobile devices. Instead, they stuck with the walled garden approach, but done better. There was huge outcry about this from developers used to PCs, but Apple didn't budge and developers put up with it since, as you say, it was a lot better than other mobile platforms.
- kabdib 10y agoIf it hadn't been a walled garden, the market would have sucked horribly inside of a year. It would be a steaming cesspool of malware and trickery and junkware. Consumer trust would have been eroded, and the market would have failed. I think that Apple did absolutely the right thing for a young marketplace. It was bad enough as it was (remember the $1000 app that did nothing? And the game with a $100 in-game purchase of ammo?)
- mikeash 10y agoThe Mac wasn't a steaming cesspool despite having none of these restrictions. I don't think your examples at the end support your point at all. It seems to me that a $1,000 app that does nothing and $100 in-game ammo purchases are only enabled by something like the App Store. The App Store is pretty anti-consumer, really. For example, the freemium craze was partly driven by the fact that Apple forbids free trials, so developers had to come up with other, worse ways to monetize without requiring people to pay up-front for something they didn't know the worth of.
- cwisecarver 10y agoThe iOS marketshare is a orders of magnitude larger than that of macOS so the target vector is larger. Malware and the like would be hugely more profitable on iOS than macOS.
- mikeash 10y agoIt is now, but it wasn't when the App Store was introduced. In any case, malware is best prevented by strong sandboxing. Forcing everyone to go through the store does approximately nothing to fight malware.