4 ms·
I'm supposed to feel bad for an employer who claims to care about his employees—but not so much that he's willing to pay them a living wage? And is willing to
by mcphage 10y ago
I'm supposed to feel bad for an employer who claims to care about his employees—but not so much that he's willing to pay them a living wage? And is willing to incur the cost of moving out of state to avoid paying a rate that won't go into effect until 2021? How much business has he lost? Well... none. But he would. Really. Just like VCRs were the "Boston strangler" of the film industry.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hueving 10y agoBy the time minimum wage hits $15, he will be operating at a $200k loss. Are you implying that he is lying about that? Or are you just suggesting that some of the employees would be better off unemployed while the remaining that he could afford pick up the slack? Or would you rather the business fold entirely and all of them become unemployed including the owner?
- youdontknowtho 10y agoThat would only be the case if this one business were the entire economy of California. The added demand caused by employees with more money to spend will generate more production.
- twoodfin 10y agoIf you're sure about this, what's the point at which raising the minimum wage would be a net loss for aggregate demand?
- youdontknowtho 10y agoI'm not an economist, so consider me soundly put in my place.
- cmdrfred 10y agoProbably around the natural wage floor that is artificially low due to government subsidies (food stamps, housing assistance, welfare, Medicaid, etc). The unsubsidised wage floor is likely around the cost of living (In California that number is or will be above 15 an hour by the time the law is in place). A minimum wage increase isn't a gift to workers as much as it is a demand that the taxpayer no longer subsidize these businesses.
- twoodfin 10y agoThat argument still doesn't seem coherent me. What "subsidy" is Walmart receiving that the Costco across the street is not? Walmart, after all, is paying workers who otherwise would receive even more government benefits. Costco is paying those same workers $0.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI'm not sure what your question is. Costco runs smaller margins than Walmart due to the founders religious ideology that prohibits him from operating like Walmart. Walmart is by far a more profitable model (121 billion gross for Walmart compared to 15 for Costco). The wages paid by Walmart are below the cost of living, if they simply paid them without subsidy their employees would be often unfed and homeless. >Costco is paying those same workers $0. Why would Costco pay its competitors employees? (Beyond what is does already via taxes)
- FussyZeus 10y agoThese situations are not solvable by doing basic math, you miss the complexities of the situation. To pay employees better, he'd shift the cost of the salaries to the goods in question, and possibly provide new/different products to address market conditions. Additionally everywhere I've worked, and this is anecdotal but still, when you pay your employees better they don't loathe their jobs quite so much, which leads to better customer service. Some people do still shop for service. If his response to rising operating costs is to not respond at all and continue charging the same prices for the same goods and not move at all in terms of addressing the problem, then he shouldn't be in business in the first place, he clearly has no idea how to run one.
- mcphage 10y ago> By the time minimum wage hits $15, he will be operating at a $200k loss. Are you implying that he is lying about that? Now, that's a good question. Are companies lying when they fight against every law enacted to protect their employees? Are they mistaken? I think most likely: they don't care if what they're saying is true or not. Is that the same as lying? Well, I'll leave that to you to decide. > Or would you rather the business fold entirely and all of them become unemployed including the owner? Well, if the company you work for paid you 33% less, would you rather they folded immediately, so you could look for work elsewhere? Or would you rather that they went on paying you less so they could stay in business—succeeding as a company merely because they're unwilling to pay people what they should?
- youdontknowtho 10y agoAgreed x100. Another way to think of this would be that if this business can only afford to operate while the state subsidizes its employees dietary, medical, and transportation costs then maybe it is a bad business. Walmart apparently has the same problem.
- VLM 10y agoThe state isn't subsidizing a penny. The taxpayers are paying directly into the parasites profits. What a crook!
- youdontknowtho 10y agoAgreed. By the state, I meant the public. Tax money supports his paying people low wages and everyone is supposed to act like he's a captain of industry. Notice that he didn't talk about his profit margins either. He'll be losing 200K out of what exactly?
- hueving 10y agoWhen someone says a business is operating at a 200k loss, that means it's not making any profits and it's losing money. It's a standard way to talk about a business.
- cmdrfred 10y agoThat often doesn't show the whole picture. Let's say Viacom operated at a 1 billion dollar loss, does that mean the CEO doesn't get paid? We would have to know how this business is structured to know if that figure means anything. 200k loss after the owners 500k salary could be the case here.
- hueving 10y agoOf course the salaries are part of a business's expenses. That still means the company is going to run out of money though. Basic math...
- VLM 10y ago"but not so much that he's willing to pay them a living wage?" The problem with word choices like that is the implication the human beings working for him are not living, and further, that's OK. The reality is that "we" are paying the living wage to his employees via higher taxes in very expensive government services so he can pocket more profit than if he responsibly took care of his own employees. If all the welfare queen small business owners left, tax rates could drop quite a bit. Life would, frankly, improve for everyone except the parasites future hosts in LV and other areas.
- hueving 10y ago>welfare queen small business owners left, tax rates could drop quite a bit. Life would, frankly, improve for everyone except the parasites Inflammatory comments like these are anti-intellectual and don't belong here. It's the same thing as referring to people on unemployment as welfare queens.
- coldtea 10y ago>The problem with word choices like that is the implication the human beings working for him are not living, and further, that's OK. They are barely living hand-to-mouth or need to have 2 jobs to make even that.
- chillydawg 10y agoThe "welfare queens" are operating in a competitive business environment where they have to compete to survive. Don't hate the player, hate the game. Obviously, we want to remove as much corporate welfare as possible, to allow the market to operate smoothly while still allowing for subsidies in well thought out places like clean energy or investing in new business sectors.