3 ms·
I said this when the first article was posted here, and I'll say it again: This is journalistic ethics in action. Greenwald spoke, you spoke, and The WaPo lis
by woodruffw 10y ago
I said this when the first article was posted here, and I'll say it again:
This is journalistic ethics in action.
Greenwald spoke, you spoke, and The WaPo listened. They've done exactly what they should do in this situation, and a certain contingent will find fault regardless.
- john_butts 10y agoThere is a huge difference between "evidence shows that there is no link" and "we were mistaken, there actually was never any evidence of a link"
- beaner 10y agoWouldn't journalistic ethics have been to not be so sensationalist to begin with?
- woodruffw 10y agoYes. In the absence of the most right path, they've taken the least wrong path by amending their article, appending an editor's note, and now apologizing in a subsequent article.
- john_butts 10y agoNo way Jose, they are absolving themselves of jumping the gun by invoking "officials" that deny the dumbass thing they said in the first place.
- temp 10y agoThe last wrong path would have been not to milk a sensationalist story without any research whatsoever.
- belovedeagle 10y agoAnd wouldn't journalistic ethics have not littered this very article with dozens of references to "Russian hackers" — evidence of whose existence is still completely absent? Twenty-four hours from now, essentially no one who has read this article will remember anything but the incessantly repeated notion that there are dangerous Russian hackers out to compromise US national security in some way, and that we need to be vigilant.
- woodruffw 10y agoRegardless of whether the WaPo operated with a story in mind, they did operate with sources: > The investigation by officials began Friday, when the Vermont utility reported its alert to federal authorities, some of whom told The Washington Post that code associated with the Russian hackers had been discovered within the system of an unnamed Vermont utility. > A senior DHS official, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss a sensitive security matter, defended the report. > “We know the Russians are a highly capable adversary who conduct technical operations in a manner intended to blend into legitimate traffic,” the official said. The indicators of compromise contained in the report, he said, “are indicative of that. That’s why it’s so important for net defenders to leverage the recommended mitigations contained in the [report], implement best practices, and analyze their logs for traffic emanating from those IPs, because the Russians are going to try and hide evidence of their intrusion and presence in the network.” You may not like the quality or the presentation of the sources as more weighty than they turned out to be, but they are sources.
- smitherfield 10y agoSources that are "anonymous" for no good reason might as well be fictional. The only reason for the source to be anonymous is because they were blatantly lying, which they were.
- woodruffw 10y agoI'm assuming you've never held classification before. Talking to the press without being expressly permitted to is a one-way ticket to a dismissal, at the very least. Anonymous sources are a cornerstone of the free press.
- smitherfield 10y agoIt's a political talking point soundbite (a PROVEN FALSE one, at that), not classified material.
- Noseshine 10y agoIt's like hitting someone very hard on the head and then apologizing. The damage is already done - 90% of the people who read the headlines won't notice the retraction. So preventing false headlines should have far greater priority than apologies/retractions - which are 90% useless. No, it is not all good now! Even the very continued mentioning of "Russian hackers" achieves a goal, very subtly. Just having that term out is enough. Given how much more advanced other countries are, I can't believe all the stuff the Russians suddenly are supposed to be capable of. To me it seems that the real "hackers" (of public opinion) are located in places very different from Moscow or Leningrad, much farther West.
- woodruffw 10y agoSee my response to belovedeagle.
- temp 10y ago>This is journalistic ethics in action. No, the term you're looking for is damage control.
- woodruffw 10y agoOne and the same.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIf damage control is your standard operating procedure, we're not talking ethics, but lack of it. Doing evil until caught, and then apologizing, can be excused once, but not when it's a strategy.
- woodruffw 10y agoI was taking a dig at the ambiguity of the word "damage." "Damage control" can either mean "controlling the damage done to the organization" or "controlling the damage done to the public by the organization." Anyways, I think it's wrong to characterize the WaPo as "evil" in this situation for following an editorial rulebook. There's no evidence that they published the first article with intent to apologize later - if there was, this case would be complicated significantly.
- puranjay 10y agoThe apology never gets as much press as the accusation. Journalistic ethics would be to never make the assertion without evidence in the first place. An apology is the last thing a newspaper should run
- woodruffw 10y agoSee my response to belovedeagle. There was evidence, but it was evidence that you or I would call insufficient to meet the weight of the accusation. You can find fault with that as shoddy journalism, but I don't think it meets the standard of unethical journalism. > An apology is the last thing a newspaper should run An apology is the first thing a newspaper should run, once it knows that its original story is faulty.
- metaphorm 10y agojournalistic ethics would have been to diligently research the story before going to press. what they should have done in this situation is make sure they had the facts in order before making statements of the gravity they made.