4 ms·
This is several days after the WP shamelessly said that Russian hackers had attacked a fundamental part of the US's infrastructure, without doing any research w
by ekianjo 10y ago
This is several days after the WP shamelessly said that Russian hackers had attacked a fundamental part of the US's infrastructure, without doing any research work before publishing their article.
The WP is becoming the voice of the White House.
- myowncrapulence 10y ago.. isn't "the voice of the white house" the voice of the nation? You seem to believe the White House wasn't voted into power and somehow does not have America's best interest at heart. Don't forget to remain just as critical when the next president takes office.
- trhway 10y ago>.. isn't "the voice of the white house" the voice of the nation? >You seem to believe the White House wasn't voted into power and somehow does not have America's best interest at heart. your statement sounds just like the propaganda from my childhood in USSR. Substituting the voice of the governing body for the voice of the nation has been a kingpin of any totalitarian state known to date.
- tristanj 10y ago> isn't "the voice of the white house" the voice of the nation? Hardly. Only two of the ~4000 people who work for the White House are actually elected. A further dozen or so need to be approved by congress. The rest are chosen without the consent of the people.
- ekianjo 10y ago> You seem to believe the White House wasn't voted into power and somehow does not have America's best interest at heart. Voted in power by a bit more than 50% of voters, of which only 60~70% amongst the registered ones bothered to vote. That's a minority no matter how you look at it. And on top of that, people under a certain age are not considered able to vote - and in certain times women and people of different races were removed from voting either. Add to this that a president can do the total opposite of what he was elected for, and there is no guarantee at all that you get what you voted for even if you were in the lucky minority who "won".
- Bartweiss 10y ago> somehow does not have America's best interest at heart Not at all. You only have to believe that the White House isn't guaranteed to have America's best interest at heart. We don't emphasize a strong and independent press because the President is always evil, or un-American. We emphasize it because we elected Nixon, and we could elect someone far worse than him. (We may well have just done so.) Like maintaining a military in times of peace, we benefit from maintaining a free press as long as there is the possibility of a White House working against our best interests.
- metaphorm 10y agoand yet there is much disagreement about what actions are in America's best interest. and even then, why are you so confident that politicians and bureaucrats are motivated by "America's best interest"? Even supposing they are, and do not have complicated and conflicting motivations (as most human beings tend to), why are you so confident that they know which actions ought to be taken to advance those interests?
- mistermann 10y agoMore like Jeff Bezos maybe realized a newspaper is only effective as a propaganda tool if people don't regularly ridicule what you publish.
- pg314 10y agoDo you have any indication that Bezos is exercising editorial control? According to a Poynter interview [1], Marty Baron, editor at the Washington Post, says "Bezos doesn't try to influence editors". The Washington Post doesn't seem to avoid putting Amazon into a negative daylight either. E.g. the article [2] mentioning Amazon using cobalt from dubious sources. Pushing the narrative that traditional newspapers like the Washington Post are propaganda tools without supporting evidence, looks suspiciously like propaganda in itself. [1] https://www.poynter.org/2016/marty-baron-on-spotlight-jeff-bezos-donald-trump-and-the-slow-death-of-printed-news/442691/ https://www.poynter.org/2016/marty-baron-on-spotlight-jeff-b... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/congo-cobalt-mining-for-lithium-ion-battery/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/business/batteries/c...
- puranjay 10y ago> According to a Poynter interview [1], Marty Baron, editor at the Washington Post, says "Bezos doesn't try to influence editors". Gee, I wonder why the editor won't publicly admit that the man who pays his salary maybe sometimes try to influence him
- pmyteh 10y agoI think you underestimate the importance of culture in organisations, and particularly the fierce independence maintained by the 'news' side of the major American press from the 'money' side. They care a lot about editorial independence and I'm quite sure they would shout if it happened rather than lie about it. The same strictures don't apply, for example, in the UK (my country) which has much more fluid boundaries between journalists and proprietors. Were I to read something similar about the Sun, for example, I would be pretty sceptical...
- mSparks 10y agoDont think there is any doubt Russian (and Chinese) hackers completely own most US infrastructure. Only need visit a few Russian hacking forums to see that. It "was easy" because the NSA put so much effort into making systems insecure. (Have the US government replaced those Juniper routers yet?) The only "doubt" is whether or not they are working for their state or just condoned by their state. Plus a big chunk of playing to public opinion because it's heresy to imply let alone state as fact that Russian or Chinese offensive comp sci is better than US defensive comp sci. Even though, in your hearts, you all know it to be true.
- Bartweiss 10y agoThe WP story, and the BBC story derived from it, were very explicit about this being a Russian government attack. They didn't hedge, they didn't talk about possibilities and Russian actions increasing scrutiny. They quoted a stream of (also irresponsible) politicians who personally blamed Putin, and talked about how this was discovered as part of a hunt for Grizzly Steppe (true, but falsely written like the malware was Grizzly Steppe). This one has been a pretty impressive round of narrative-fitting, and it's just going to be an embarrassment that makes it hard to convince anyone when foreign governments do get up to something.
- metaphorm 10y agonot the White House. the Clinton-aligned faction of the state department and intelligence community.