4 ms·
Horrific, inexplicable tragedies happen in hospitals and emergency rooms because in the normal chaos of medical emergencies and communication snafus, surgeons d
by danso 10y ago
Horrific, inexplicable tragedies happen in hospitals and emergency rooms because in the normal chaos of medical emergencies and communication snafus, surgeons don't properly wash their hands or mark which limb is meant to be amputated [0]. But your experience with such institutions is that while they may fuck up the routine small things and kill patients, they are yet able to pivot like well-oiled military units when their information technology infrastructure is unexpectedly cut?
[0] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist
- strainer 10y agoIf we can appreciate inexplicable medical tragedies - can't we appreciate a mans emotional response? If he was wrong was he yet not caught in a tragedy? >their information technology infrastructure is unexpectedly cut You are attributing offence of a kind which is far removed from his case - he never attacked the kind of critical systems which you indicate with the Newyorker article. He pestered and temporarily disabled a medical company website to highlight the maltreatment of a patient, now he is facing many years in prison for the protest. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/why-i-knocked-boston-childrens-hospital-off-the-internet-a-statement-from-martin-gottesfeld_us_57df4995e4b08cb140966cd3 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/why-i-knocked-boston-chi... " I also knew from my career experience as a biotech professional that no patients should be harmed if Boston Children’s was knocked offline. There’s no such thing as an outage-proof network, so hospitals have to be able to function without the Internet. It’s required by federal law, and for accreditation. The only effects would be financial and on BCH’s reputation. "
- danso 10y ago> He pestered and temporarily disabled a medical company website to highlight the maltreatment of a patient, now he is facing many years in prison for the protest. Uh, OK... You'll have to pardon my skepticism that you actually read the New Yorker article when it appears you didn't even read the OP whom you defend. Here's one sentence you appear to have skipped over: > Almost unbelievably, they kept their donation page on the same public network as the rest of their stuff. Rookie mistake. To take it down, I’d have to knock the whole hospital off the Internet. Edit: clarification. The thing that I quote directly above is not in the OP, but in the link u/strainer provided as rebuttal, i.e. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/why-i-knocked-boston-childrens-hospital-off-the-internet-a-statement-from-martin-gottesfeld_us_57df4995e4b08cb140966cd3 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/why-i-knocked-boston-chi...
- grzm 10y agoPlease don't imply that a commenter has not read an article, no matter how apparent it is to you or how obtuse you believe them to be. It does nothing to further the discussion constructively, but rather only increases animosity between participants. Simply pointing out what the article does say in contradiction is strong enough, and any ignorance or otherwise on behalf of the commenter should be apparent in and of itself.
- danso 10y agoI agree that we should err on the side of civility. But in this case, I think it's important to call out u/strainer for his mistake. Note that I said "mistake" and not "lie", because I do think it was an honest mistake, but a major one that was made in a rush to judgment. No big deal. Me and u/strainer are just two people opining about things we read on the Internet on a late Monday night. But that's kind of the bigger picture, isn't it? If the allegations against Mr. Gottesfeld are materially true, but we assign the best of motives to him, then he himself is also just another guy who read something on the Internet. Except, instead of just opining about it, he allegedly tried to shut down an entire hospital's IT. u/strainer wants to believe in the narrative that Mr. Gottesfeld is competent and knowledgeable enough to know how a hospital's IT is configured. I'm of the belief that maybe Mr. Gottesfeld is overconfident of what he knows about hospital IT. And perhaps he was overconfident of the issues regarding the plight of the girl and her family. Because it's easy to miss even the big details when reading things on the Internet.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 10y agoDude if anyone here "wants to believe in a narrative" it's got to be you. Gottesfeld's "narrative" is simple. He wanted to interrupt fundraising, so he interrupted fundraising. It's BCH and DoJ that have the complicated yarn to spin, about how torturing little girls is OK and all of their life support equipment relies on constant access to Instagram and the best response to your connection coming under DDoS is to just unhook the damn thing. You aren't actually being civil, when you pretend that anyone whose argument you have misunderstood is some sort of moron.