16 ms·
People talk of pension like they're a sacred right of workers yet nobody will address the fact that they're entirely unsustainable. Any system that tells a work
by koolba 10y ago
People talk of pension like they're a sacred right of workers yet nobody will address the fact that they're entirely unsustainable. Any system that tells a worker they can work for 25 years somewhere then receive 25+ years of pensions at their inflation adjusted final salary is a crock. The money has to come from somewhere (and don't give me a bullshit about compounding ... we're talking way more than that).
The non-employer (or even worse municipal - yuck!) pension can be created synthetically through a combination of annuities and life insurance. The problem with that approach is that since the other side is a private company that cares about the pay outs (and not just promising obligations to be paid by someone else), it ends up costing way more. Guaranteeing a perpetual $X/month (inflation adjusted) pay out twenty-five years from now is way more expensive than people realize or would be willing to pay for.
The real answer is: Accept that fact that most people cannot retire at the same lifestyle the enjoyed while working or adjust the latter well in advance so that instead of saving 5-10% you're saving 50+% of your money.
- ivraatiems 10y agoI think you're presenting a false choice. We live in a society where an awful lot of money goes to things and people that don't particularly need or merit it. What you mean to be saying is "accept the fact that without a radical change in how we view the purpose of employment and retirement, most people cannot . . ." Basically, what's the goal? The goal right now is for each entity in the system to hold onto as much money as it possibly can. It's a company-first view of the problem, and therefore not one that really addresses the main point: People shouldn't be expected to work into their old age.
- koolba 10y ago> I think you're presenting a false choice. We live in a society where an awful lot of money goes to things and people that don't particularly need or merit it. That's why people don't have a higher savings rate. Most people are idiots when it comes to spending, the dumbest habit of which is increasing your spending on pace with increased in income. Okay maybe not the dumbest as it's even dumber when they increase it faster than income (ex: new job => new car with higher monthly payment v.s. difference in salary). > What you mean to be saying is "accept the fact that without a radical change in how we view the purpose of employment and retirement, most people cannot . . ." > Basically, what's the goal? The goal right now is for each entity in the system to hold onto as much money as it possibly can. Why is the company holding onto anything? If you're working as an employee and want to retire one day, demand to be paid for the services you're providing now, save them up, invest them, and then it's yours to spend. Why have the company guess at how to manage that? It's putting an awfully lot of eggs in one basket as well as if the company goes under, your pension will take a hit as well (since no company actually has a fully paid for sinking fund). > It's a company-first view of the problem, and therefore not one that really addresses the main point: People shouldn't be expected to work into their old age. Why not? What else are they going to do anyway and why should they be granted N years of do nothingness just because they're old? Sure sounds like a ponzi scheme to me ...
- ivraatiems 10y ago> That's why people don't have a higher savings rate. Most people are idiots when it comes to spending, the dumbest habit of which is increasing your spending on pace with increased in income. Okay maybe not the dumbest as it's even dumber when they increase it faster than income (ex: new job => new car with higher monthly payment v.s. difference in salary). It's also why megacorporations and a very small percentage of people have such immense amounts of money and give essentially nothing back for it. > Why not? What else are they going to do anyway and why should they be granted N years of do nothingness just because they're old? Sure sounds like a ponzi scheme to me... What is so valuable about forcing everyone to work their whole lives? Who benefits?
- koolba 10y ago> It's also why megacorporations and a very small percentage of people have such immense amounts of money and give essentially nothing back for it. Besides you sounding bitter and misinformed or changing the conversation to one about converting the USA to communism, I don't see how that's relevant to this. > What is so valuable about forcing everyone to work their whole lives? Who benefits? They benefit by providing for themselves and their families. They're not being forced to do anything (though food, shelter, and self preservation tend to be good motivators). To flip your question around, why should they get a free ride because they past a certain age? I'm not saying people shouldn't retire, I'm saying that if they want to do it, they need to be realistic about what's financially involved and either save significantly more or realize they're going to be living off of rice and beans.
- ivraatiems 10y ago> Besides you sounding bitter and misinformed or changing the conversation to one about converting the USA to communism, I don't see how that's relevant to this. I didn't say that. I think you're leaping to conclusions. What I'm trying to do, to be frank, is poke holes in the assumptions you're making in the first post about how things are and should be. I'm not a communist (it's never worked as envisioned, and likely can't), but I'm getting pretty sick of the notion that our system as-is is the best one for most people. I want to have a conversation about ways it could either be made better, or what it could be replaced with. > They benefit by providing for themselves and their families. They're not being forced to do anything (though food, shelter, and self preservation tend to be good motivators). Again, this is a false choice. It actually is a couple of false assumptions: First, the idea that food, shelter and self-preservation are things that people must earn, rather than have a right to. Second, that people who are in a "do it or die" situation have any real choice, given that almost nobody would choose the "die" part of that. > To flip your question around, why should they get a free ride because they past a certain age? I'm not saying people shouldn't retire, I'm saying that if they want to do it, they need to be realistic about what's financially involved and either save significantly more or realize they're going to be living off of rice and beans. So, first of all, I agree with the notion that in the system as it is, one has to be prudent and thoughtful, one has to save money, one has to plan for oneself. We're in agreement on all that: With the world the way it is, it's important for each individual to plan and put themselves first. I fully understand how to work within the system we have to keep oneself afloat, and I'm not suggesting people shouldn't. Why shouldn't people get a free ride for food, health, shelter? Why are those things things which must somehow be earned? I'm talking philosophically here, not practically. I'm not saying everyone is entitled to caviar and vegan d3 supplements on private yachts, but I don't understand the assumption that, given a society which could technologically provide basics for everyone, people shouldn't have them.
- kobeya 10y ago50% would be enough to retire in 7-10 years btw. Actual required savings rates would be lower.
- kgwgk 10y agoCan you explain your calculation? Let's say your income is 100. You spend 50 per year, save 50 per year. How much do you have in 7-10 years? How many decades of retirement can you finance with those savings?
- the_gastropod 10y agoAssuming we're starting at $0, saving 50% will more realistically let you retire after ~17 years. Here's a pretty good article from Mr. Money Mustache that explains the math: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim...
- fnovd 10y agoThe big problem with this table is that it assumes that you want to live on the same amount that you do while saving. If I'm saving 50% of my income to retire in 17 years and then decide I can bump it up to 65% of my income (let's say by no longer dining out) all of a sudden my "retirement" happens 7 years earlier. It feels good to read that because it looks like I'm saving 7 years of work by just saving a bit more. However, the new "retirement income" that I'll be living at goes down from 50% of my income to just 35%--the table expects that, since you can live on the new income, then it is enough for you to retire on. If I raise my savings rate by cutting things I can live without (for now), I'm "locked in" to not having those things in retirement. If I'm making $5k a month after taxes and saving 90% of that (so, living on just $500 a month), MMM's table says I can "retire" in under 3 years. However, that retirement is one in which I live on just $500 a month--not what everyone has in mind when they consider retirement. If I'm making $5000 a month and want to live on $2500 in a month in retirement, I will have to save for considerably longer than 3 years. This is the most glaring at saving 100% of income. It doesn't really make sense that I can "retire" in 0 years by saving 100% of my income. The table is basically saying, "If you can afford to work and not spend any of the money you make, you can drop your income from $5000 to $0 and live without worry!" Never mind that people may have children, or get sick, or feel like traveling, or any other possible scenario in which an extra cost is incurred.
- pdq 10y agoDefined contribution plans are such a simpler system. Defined benefit plans need professional actuaries to estimate a future with so many unknown variables: interest rates, rates of investment return, employee lifespans in 20+ years, retirement ages, voluntary employee exit rates (just to name a few). Plus you have the problem of so few companies lasting anywhere near as long as a pension plan would last, so these legacy pensions have to get offloaded to the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation. It's no wonder that the private sector has moved from 30% defined benefit and 10% 401k back in 1980, to 2% defined benefit and 33% 401k today.
- toast0 10y agoI think this is exactly right, a defined contribution is simpler, more transparent, and less risky for the employee and the employer. The employee knows exactly how much the employee is contributing (and if it's being contributed in timely fashion), and (vested) contributions are safe from employer bankruptcy or change of jobs. The employee still has market risk, which was present before in that a pension with poor investment results may lead to the pension being assigned to the PBGC and result in a reduced pension. The employer benefits by paying for today's workers only today, and does not have to manage and fund the pension. There are certainly concerns about investment costs / poor investment choices within 401(k) plans, but I think some recent litigation results are likely to improve the landscape. Good plans are available, and companies may have a duty to provide a good plan.
- crdoconnor 10y agoIt simply moves the investment work and risks to the individual. It's a minefield for the individual and vastly more complex to manage (individuals are effectively forced into being investment managers... like that's an easy job?). It's ultimately just one part of the seismic shift in wealth to the 0.1%. "Sustainability" is just the thinly veiled excuse.
- saryant 10y agoIs it really unreasonable for someone to read something like Bernstein's "If You Can"? It takes an hour. https://www.etf.com/docs/IfYouCan.pdf https://www.etf.com/docs/IfYouCan.pdf
- ams6110 10y agoIf you save 10% of your income from your early 20s to 65 you should be quite well set, presuming your expenses drop after retirement (kids are supporting themselves, house is paid off or you downsize to a lower cost smaller residence). If you can save a little more than 10% even better. Problem is most people don't really think about it until they're in their mid 30s at earliest. When you are in your 20s or early 30s and have young kids so many things seem like more important priorities. And most people in their 20s can't even really conceptualize retirement. It seems impossibly far away, time-wise. But missing that first 15 years has a huge impact on the total compounding potential. If you start saving at 35 you have to save a lot more.
- closeparen 10y agoIt's amusing to me that people in the tech community think they will get to work that long. Look around your office. Do you see anyone over 40? No? Are you saving enough to retire at 40? Then what do you think is going to happen? EDIT: I will point out that this comment has fluctuated quite a bit between +2 and -2. So, clearly some very different experiences, which is good to hear. Perhaps not as dire as it looks.
- jghn 10y agoYes I do.
- swsieber 10y agoI see many people over 40. I have co-workers with children my age. Perhaps if you move, you'll find a more respectful and receptive environment for those who are seasoned.
- ThomaszKrueger 10y ago54 here. Will work until drop dead.
- skookum 10y agoBy this logic, there must be millions of unemployable past-40 software engineers out on the streets. Or maybe the simpler explanation: Our industry has been growing exponentially for two decades and the cohorts that are past 40 are small compared to the ones that came later. Further, the "look around your office" result varies wildly from office to office. Looking around your average SV startup will skew to gullible, er, I mean risk-tolerant mid-20s engineers. My office is more than half composed of experienced engineers in their mid 30s and up who know their market rate.
- hudibras 10y ago>Any system that tells a worker they can work for 25 years somewhere then receive 25+ years of pensions at their inflation adjusted final salary is a crock. Nice strawman you got there. I doubt there's even one pension plan, public or private, in the U.S., Europe, or Asia which is as generous as your example.
- patio11 10y agoCalifornia public safety employees (police, fire, etc) get all four prongs of that deal, I think. Technically it's 90% of peak salary but "spiking" is culturally accepted, so in practice you can have more than 100% of your final year salary in pension benefits.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> California public safety employees (police, fire, etc) get all four prongs of that deal, I think. Technically it's 90% of peak salary but "spiking" is culturally accepted, so in practice you can have more than 100% of your final year salary in pension benefits. Government postings are even better. The UN requires only five years of service before you're eligible for pension benefits, and you can still collect those on top of whatever pension your home country government gives you (which is common), or even while being employed in a different government posting. It's not 100% of salary if you only stay 5 years, but it's pretty large - you can easily reach eligibility for a pension that's large enough to live on before you're 30, and then "double up" by taking other government postings whose pension eligibility is handled separately.
- hudibras 10y agoUN pension is 1.5% per year, which you can start collecting when you're 62 years old. Not that unreasonable.
- chimeracoder 10y ago> UN pension is 1.5% per year That's the minimum. It goes up from there depending on your position. Typically, you could expect to make a lot, lot more than that, even for very short tenure: http://www.un.org/Depts/OHRM/salaries_allowances/salary.htm http://www.un.org/Depts/OHRM/salaries_allowances/salary.htm > which you can start collecting when you're 62 years old ...yes, but the point is that you only need to be employed for five years to be eligible for lifetime benefits. Work there for 5 years in your 20s and you're set.
- closeparen 10y ago>People talk of pension like they're a sacred right of workers yet nobody will address the fact that they're entirely unsustainable If I go eat an expensive meal and, when the check comes, say "sorry, these prices are unsustainable, and making money is not your sacred right" I would be arrested.
- gohrt 10y agoPensions are funded. There is a national pension insurance fund. They are completely sustainable, as long as they are funded. A pension is an annuity. The pension money comes from money that is withheld from wages. Now, if some company engages in wage theft (raids its pension fund), that's fraud just as any Madoff-esque pyramid scheme.
- hudibras 10y agoThe HN crowd will never believe this, because it runs contrary to the beliefs of libertarianism and the what-I-vaguely-remember-from-Econ-101 crowd, but correctly-funded public pensions are completely sustainable. The main reason is that public pensions operate on a nearly infinite time horizon, unlike a worker's 401(k).
- analog31 10y agoLong ago, conservatives believed that public assistance made people immoral. Then Ronald Reagan discovered that his own followers actually like their public assistance when it benefits them and not those "other" people. So conservatives changed their tune and began claiming that public assistance is "unsustainable."
- grzm 10y agoThe HN crowd will never believe this Please don't make generalizations like this, especially of a community you choose to participate in. Your comment reads perfectly well if you omit everything up through but.
- hudibras 10y agoGood point, thanks.
- sigzero 10y agoCalifornia is in a pension crisis because they screwed they whole thing up. When people are involved, expect those screw ups.
- shorttime 10y agoIf the book I'm reading is to be believed, pensions were paid for by the company with money that would have went to the worker, if not for the pension. This money would then be invested over the career of the worker, similar to a 401k, but the risk is on the company to manage - not the worker. The pension to 401k transition simply offloaded the risk of financial maintenance to the worker, rather than the company. Salaries, supposedly, adjusted accordingly when 401k's came around, which is a whole story in itself. Originally, 401ks were for executives seeking tax-differed income from the company and it morphed in the 80s to become what we see today.
- hudibras 10y agoYou're mostly right, but it's also the spreading of risk across many employees (including future employees, not even hired yet) which make pensions viable.
- bradleyjg 10y agoA company, even a fairly big one, can go out of business. Also, most companies are not in the business of managing investments. They are in the business of selling shoes, or oil, or internet ads. There are companies that are in the business of managing investments for the very long term and are regulated so as to minimize the risks of bankruptcy. You or you company can incrementally buy a pension from such a company in the form of a deferred annuity. The only disadvantage to a defined contribution plan with a deferred annuity option is that you and your employer can't mutually pretend there's such a thing as a free lunch in the form of risk free investments with eight percent returns. But on balance I'd consider that a good thing.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If the book I'm reading is to be believed, pensions were paid for by the company with money that would have went to the worker, if not for the pension. This is evidently not true, as employers did not, when discontinuing pensions, add equal economic value in other compensation. Pensions are a retention program as well as a compensation program.
- shshhdhs 10y ago
- dragonwriter 10y ago> People talk of pension like they're a sacred right of workers yet nobody will address the fact that they're entirely unsustainable. They aren't entirely unsustainable. It's possible for them to be underfunded, but that's structurally avoidable if anyone was concerned. > Any system that tells a worker they can work for 25 years somewhere then receive 25+ years of pensions at their inflation adjusted final salary is a crock. Sure, but real-world pensions rarely come anywhere close to that; even generous ones are almost never fully inflation-adjusted (while COLAs are common, they are often capped at, e.g., 2% annually -- each year, not cumulatively, so they permanently fall behind each year inflation is above the cap) and they usually don't come anywhere close to 100% at 25 years. (I think the most generous rank-and-file current CalPERS plan is 2% per year of service at 55 years, which maxes out at 2.418% at 63+ years, and so would take more than 40 years of service to reach 100% of the base used for calculation -- which for employees hired in something like the last decade is actually the average salary of the last 3 years, not the last single year.)
- WildUtah 10y agoCalPERS users can take extra overtime and duty pay in those last years to inflate the base, also. And that base even without overtime is much higher than the average working salary. And CalPERS assumes a rate of return far higher than it can achieve through investments. That's how CA employees end up with million dollar per year pensions. [0] Happily, some abuses have been reduced slightly in recent years. There's far to go yet. While it is possible for pensions to be funded properly, it's not something state and municipal governments do and the few private companies with defined benefit pensions rarely do so either. In fact, it's literally illegal to fully fund pension benefits in the United States without paying a steep tax penalty for saving too much. The IRS and Congress know that exposing the full cost of what we're promising to pay out would shock too many people and they don't want to know. Better to defer the problem to the next Congress and let them sort it out. The only hope is massive productivity growth. So, techies, get programming those robots and AI bots and new chemical materials and cheap new energy sources. The government has already assumed that they're all going to take off like crazy and forced us to bet the country on that assumption. We're going to need a tech explosion just to keep our heads above water. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Bell_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Bell_scandal