3 ms·
My suspicion was that SpaceX was rushing to validate their carbon fiber tank plans, which is why they did it on stage 2 (process is lower scale and easier to ex
by dnautics 10y ago
My suspicion was that SpaceX was rushing to validate their carbon fiber tank plans, which is why they did it on stage 2 (process is lower scale and easier to experiment). Well, at least they failed fast. I made this prediction in a private twitter DM (yes, weaksauce, I should have been bolder with a public post) the day that Musk announced their plans for giant carbon fiber tanks, with no knowledge that the stage 2 tank was made of carbon fiber.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B3uVSPZl-I22UjE4aElRcDFaaEk https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B3uVSPZl-I22UjE4aElRcDFaaE...
- greglindahl 10y agoAre you confusing the small COPV helium tanks with the much larger metal LOX tank?
- InclinedPlane 10y ago100% wrong. COPVs and carbon fiber tanks are entirely different beasts. In fact, if carbon fiber He tanks had been used instead of the COPV bottles this failure wouldn't have happened.
- snrplfth 10y agoThe Carbon-Overwrapped Pressure Vessels are quite different from the large-scale carbon fiber tanks they're building now. The new large tanks are designed to be able to contain large quantities of propellant at moderate pressures, possibly without a liner, while the COPVs are meant to contain pressurant gas at extremely high pressure, with a metal liner. SpaceX has been using COPVs to hold helium pressurant since the first Falcon 9 back in 2010. This is not a new technology. What is new is the large propellant tanks, which have not been done before at this scale, and have not been used in Falcon 9s at any point. So no, you shouldn't have been bolder with a public post.