2 ms·
Good catch--- it appears in a paragraph discussing why the court should consider the case at all, so is mostly a jurisdictional comment. Courts are by default r
by _delirium 17y ago
Good catch--- it appears in a paragraph discussing why the court should consider the case at all, so is mostly a jurisdictional comment. Courts are by default reluctant to issue declaratory judgments, because the U.S. legal system requires an "actual case or controversy" to consider a case. So AFP is arguing that, by setting up an "antagonistic assertion of rights", Morel has initiated an actual controversy over the matter that the court should consider, i.e. it's not just AFP asking for a declaratory judgment on a purely hypothetical issue. Of course, Morel's countersuit dispenses any doubts on that point.