4 ms·
I have a comment further down mentioning the horrendous mess that a P2P architecture would present. It would work for techies like us, but it wouldn't work for
by cookiecaper 17y ago
I have a comment further down mentioning the horrendous mess that a P2P architecture would present.
It would work for techies like us, but it wouldn't work for the segment that is making Facebook so transcendently popular. MySpace was a "teen" thing, others before it, too, but Facebook is mainstream; my grandma has a profile, my parents have profiles, and such is true of many.
Also mainstream is turning off your computer when you're not using it. Almost every non-techie I know is really interested in having their computer turned off. They don't really care about waiting for it to come back up. Telling them that their profile is only accessible while their computer is on is an instant killer. And what if their internet goes out? They're down for that time too. For people with spotty or wireless connections, saying "your profile will only work when your connection works, like 30% of the time", is not going to be too encouraging.
What if a user's hard drive dies? Do you really expect people like my 86-year-old grandmother to make backups of her social network profile frequently enough for it to be meaningful? Or what if a user just gets a new computer? Are they going to understand how to transfer the profile?
Making users download and run a P2P server 24/7 slows down the computer, increases personal connection bandwidth usage commensurate with one's popularity, and creates a big opening for scammers.
I know Facebook would be much less enjoyable if I had to sit around and wait for the dial-up AOL connections of the old people I know to upload their photos. Or even home broadband connections; in the US, those are usually capped at 60-70kbps upload, which is pretty slow.
How easy would it be to create a page that looks like your network's page and say "We've updated our client! This is a special update that we can't auto-update for these smart-sounding technical reasons, so please download and install it." People would do this immediately because social networks are a major part of their web usage; for some, the only reason they use computer. And your network would be poisoned and the users' profile disabled just that easily.
I just don't see how a P2P social network would gain mainstream appeal. What are your solutions to these problems?
- nkassis 17y agoI don't think anyone is suggesting self hosting of profiles, just to go from one provider to many providers. That would involve interoperability. The advantages of this are many, no service could just query one host and get all profiles that cross their path. A user would explicitly give pandora or Microsoft access to their profile by providing something like their email or some similar identifying string that could be tied back to the host of the profile.
- wmf 17y agoThis is why your "peer" should be a cloud server, not a PC. Call it S2S architecture.
- cookiecaper 17y agoRight, but then you still have all of your data off somewhere in someone else's control. It'd possibly even be worse than Facebook, because an open "provider" that doesn't do anything except host data for Facebook & co. wouldn't be bringing any revenue, and thus would be tempted just to sell all the data you upload. The point shouldn't be to cut out Facebook, it should be to keep the user in complete control of their data. You can transfer control to an arbitrary entity but what are they going to do to make money, and are they going to become corrupt or not? And if you asked yourself the same thing about Zuckerberg the day after Thefacebook went online, what would your answer be?
- wmf 17y agoObviously you can only trust a server if you pay for it and have a good contract. It's like an apartment or a safe deposit box.
- cookiecaper 17y agoAnd how many are going to pay for server space when you say "this is like Facebook, but more secure", and how many are just going to stick with Facebook?
- wmf 17y agoIMO people deserve as much privacy as they're willing to pay for. If some people choose to stick with Facebook, that's not my problem.