3 ms·
The EU has been around for 50 years in evolving forms. It's easy to cherrypick failures, but the achievements ought to get some mention too. After the fall of
by pavlov 10y ago
The EU has been around for 50 years in evolving forms. It's easy to cherrypick failures, but the achievements ought to get some mention too.
After the fall of the Soviet Union, about twenty countries wanted to join the EU as soon as they could. Some like Serbia are still working to fulfill the entry criteria. Brexit does nothing to change that: Britain was always an exception with its recent imperialist past.
The EU institutions are often bureaucratic. Yet they offer more representation and individual freedom to small countries than does the American constitution, for example. Given the often conflicting requirements, many aspects of the EU work amazingly well.
- marcoperaza 10y ago>Britain was always an exception with its recent imperialist past This is a joke, right? Ever heard of French Indochina, French Syria, or the Algerian War? Or how about the Belgian Congo? Or Spanish Morocco? All from the second half of the 20th century. And let's not forget the Germans conquering all of Europe. And your own country, Finland, siding with them.
- pavlov 10y agoThe difference is that Britain still has factions clinging to the remnants of the Empire. Among Brexiteers, this was a common theme: "We should work with Commonwealth nations rather than continental Europe". As far as WWII and Nazis -- that is precisely the reason why we have the EU, and shouldn't be brash in dismissing it. Nationalism in Europe ends up badly.
- marcoperaza 10y agoI'm not sure how wanting closer economic relations with former colonies is equivalent to lusting for empire, or even a bad thing. With Canada, Australia, New Zealand (and the US) especially, the UK has a lot of cultural and political synergy.
- pavlov 10y agoMy point exactly. What does that have to do with the EU? If Brexit proponents feel Britain should work with English-speaking former colonies on the other side of the planet, that's fine -- but why come up with lies about the EU to advance that goal?
- marcoperaza 10y agoGiven that the EU has a common external trade policy, that's kind of difficult. Also, closer economic ties with countries outside of the EU are not the raison d'etre of Brexit, but a proposal for a viable alternative economic arrangement that would make Brexit feasible.
- pavlov 10y agoAnd that's why Britain is an exception. If they don't want to be part of the EU, it's not a failure of the EU.
- lacampbell 10y agoThe UK joining the EEC in the 70s had a huge effect on the New Zealand economy.
- maverick_iceman 10y ago>Yet they offer more representation and individual freedom to small countries than does the American constitution I had to laugh after reading this line. American constitution gives much more power to the residents of the smaller states because of the Senate and the electoral college. In addition, US offers everyone much stronger civil liberties than most European countries. Compare the First Amendment with Germany's hate speech laws for example.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 10y agoThe European Council is the most powerful decision maker in the EU, and it decides by consensus except where treaties specifically provide otherwise. For a small country that's hell of a lot more power than the biases of Senate and electoral college representation. Civil liberties between USA and EU are a toss: the First Amendment is strong in its scope, but on the other hand things like privacy are much better protected in most EU countries. American legislation doesn't do much to protect citizens against corporations.
- lacampbell 10y agoI feel like I need much more protection from governments than I do from corporations - so putting the government in charge of protecting me from something much less dangerous/violent seems very very odd. I suppose governments are regarded as inevitable, which is why this strange double standard exists.